Even if we accept that premise, the fourth amendment still protects against "unreasonable searches and seizures". This means that the government needs to go through a meaningful review process to take possession of other people's property. This is unquestionable not the case with PRISM / FISA court approvals. Blank checks for the government to access whatever data it wants is unreasonable searches and seizures
The fact of the matter is that metadata is somebody's property and by forcing all third-parties to be unable to defend their data about their customers, the government denies enterprises the ability to compete in the marketplace on as many privacy features.
Since that time, it's been generally understood that to get the actual data requires a warrant whereas the metadata just requires asking whoever is storing the metadata.
If we want to roll that back - and I do - we need to demonstrate that the metadata is just as telling/informative/sensitive/damaging as the data itself and therefore should be protected under the same standards.
And how the heck can you interpret the word "unreasonable" literally?
By your interpretation, because the phone companies' wires and the voltages thereon are not yours, wiretaps have nothing to do with the fourth amendment. If I place a GPS tracker on your car, that's not "yours" so none of its data is "yours", and I didn't literally search or seize your car, so I'm in the clear. And so on and so on.
It’s not like the defintion of “their” as a word denoting possesson or ownership has changed since the 18th century. And it’s not like third party data was an unknown concept in the 18th century. It was an age of commerce, with merchants and bankers keeping extensive records about the dealings of third parties.
As to wire taps—the Supreme Court decided it right the first time when it found in Olmstead that a wire tap was not a fourth amendment search. The contrary decision in Smith was based on this expansive “reasonable expectation of privacy” articulation which has no basis in the Constitution.
GPS trackers are a different story. There, the government is treapassing on your char (your chattel property) to conduct a search.
GPS trackers don’t provide information that’s unavailable to high altitude drones/aircraft/somone following the car. Their advantage is how cheap they are not that they provide non public information.
Further privacy is never directly mentioned. So, a pure textual reading suggests it’s not protected rather than say the inconvenience of somone searching your stuff.
What you say on the last line implies that all of the US' flawed constitution should be taken word for word, and nothing else! In that case, you should be able to have nuke's; as you have "the right to bear arms". Cognitive dissonance is what seems to be the problem with your take.
“nuke's“ Arms did not nessisarily include personal cannons which where available back then. (It has been interpreted this way though.) So, that’s arguably a distinction already in the constitution.
But again if you want to take a more expansive reading that’s reasonable, you simply can’t defend both interpretations. So, if you want reading A that also supports personal nuclear weapons then that’s included in reading A despite the unwanted side effects.
Attaching a brick to someone’s suitcase with a magnetic clamp would be a trespass to chattels (which can result from any intentional physical contact, even if it does not damage the property). You can’t go around attaching things to other peoples’ property.
Our legal system is not base on such meaningless distinctions. But, it’s to interpret things such that the rule is you (government agents) can place a tracker in the bed of a pickup truck as long as it’s not attached. But, cases are decided based on context not the form actions take. So this is a privacy issue not a private property issue.
Trespass isn’t expressly mentioned in the constitution, but it is one that is at least consistent with the text. The 4A lists several kinds of private property, and prohibits unreasonable “search” or “seizure” of that property. What is an “search” or “seizure” of private property? The structure of the text makes clear that it is a wrongful intrusion by a government agent onto property. What do we call wrongful intrusions onto private property? Generally, it’s trespass.
“Privacy,” on the other hand, doesn’t fit the textual formula at all. The text says nothing about “privacy.” The contemporaneous debate said nothing about privacy. Saying that the fourth amendment is about “protecting privacy” totally abandons the textual nexus between a “search” and some private property. It is in fact an example of fallacious reasoning. It is the conclusion that because a “search” is one way to invade someone’s privacy, that anything that invades someone’s privacy is a “search.”
Interpreting the word “their,” meanwhile, to encompass all third-party data pertaining to “them,” does a lot more violence to the English language.
I have to sincerely disagree w/ you here. To me, "papers, and effects" effectively covers both data at rest and data in transit. To have the government meddle with your property is a "search". Colonial-era founding fathers would not have thought stopping a messenger on horseback and searching his belongings would fly, and there is no material difference to modern-day communications.
From the article, Kavanaugh writes:
> The Government’s collection of telephony metadata from a third party such as a telecommunications service provider is not considered a search under the Fourth Amendment, at least under the Supreme Court's decision in Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735 (1979).
In Smith v. Maryland, the telecommunications provider was complicit in installation of a pen register; from Smith v. Maryland,
> The telephone company, at police request, installed at its central offices a pen register to record the numbers dialed from the telephone at petitioner's home.
But to apply a ruling from a case where one party is okay w/ the police monitoring a communication (the "third-party doctrine") and applying that to a case where no party is okay with the communication (NSA's spying on Americans' communications, such as through hacking communications lines of companies such as Google) is to misapply the precedent where it didn't belong. (Particularly in a request for an en banc hearing.)
Facebook, Google, Apple, Microsoft, Yahoo, and other tech companies were also named as defendants in the case; calling them "telephone companies" is a stretch.
> who cooperated
You're perhaps right that we need to demonstrate that the companies did not cooperate. The judge's ruling in that case includes that the companies were under a FISA warrant, thus, not willingly. (The companies own public statements also demonstrate this, but those are not under oath.) A warrant of the size alleged in the case would be unconstitutional, unless you believe searching millions of American's communications can someone be considered "reasonable", but it should at least be challengable in a court of law.
But further I worry this will be used for other (non-PRISM) programs, that did not involve warrants or cooperation, and were blatantly unconstitutional. If I have the timing of events here right, the Klayman case was a few months too soon; shortly after its filing, information about MUSCULAR (an NSA program capturing internal datacenter traffic in several tech companies, "the exploitation relied on the fact that (at the time at least) data was transmitted unencrypted inside Google's private cloud"[1]).
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MUSCULAR_(surveillance_program...
Only if you're a lawyer or a judge. To the people of this country, the Constitution does represent a set of values. Some founders protested the inclusion of the Bill of Rights on the grounds that the constitution already protected many of these things, and that their inclusion would elevate these particular points above others. So why include it, then?
It's not unreasonable to see the Bill of Rights as a sort of airing of grievances. For the lawyers and judges that doesn't have any practical value, it's just a system of words to navigate. But just because it's of no use to a lawyer doesn't mean that is the only perspective to consider. Our government ostensibly serves the people and the work of the lawyers and judges and legislators is supposed to manifest as a government that the people want.
Regular everyday normal guys look at these programs, we think about what inspired these amendments and how it reflects some set of values, and we think that it still resonates with us today and would like to have a government that is aligned with those values. Us regular everyday normal guys don't care how you lawyer-types get us back there, we just want it done.
Really, I think you and I are advocating for the same thing. I realize that surveillance hasn't been struck down because there's no real legal reason to strike it down. What I'm saying is that this isn't a good reason to abandon the system altogether. But I wouldn't go as far as you to say that some set of values doesn't exist, and that the constitution is only a legal document, and that everything is exactly how it's supposed to be.
Is there a pithy way to phrase it?
What would that imply for any jurisdiction that does not consider the US constitution to be ground truth?
Is it not possible to have a democracy that is at odds with the US consitution? Clearly, it is possible. Therefore the US constitution does not define the outer scope of democracy.
It's plain to me that the call records are 'my' data. I don't see why your interpretation has a superior legitimacy to mine; we both know that there are many serious arguments on both sides (let's spare HN from repeating them). Honest question: Why would your position be 'plain', and the other an imposition of values?
Also, I would appreciate if you would provide some expert context: The comment reflect an approach to the law that is one philosophy among several leading ones, or perhaps rather one position on a continuum between 'strict construction' and interpretation.[0] But I'm not an attorney and I'm hoping you can provide better context than my amateur attempt at it.
Also, clearly we do not and cannot follow the 'plain meaning' of the law. For example, even in something so prominent as the U.S. Constitution: The First Amendment is treasured and protected, but exceptions are (and must be) made for slander, fraud, significant threats, etc., and none of that is anywhere to be found in the text. The Second Amendment's text doesn't make exceptions for regulating more dangerous weapons, but we must not allow anti-aircraft weapons or nuclear bombs in private possession. So among real practitioners and experts, how are simple algorithms such as 'the plain meaning' squared with those realities?
I really do mean them as serious questions, not as a debate; I think the heart of these issues is in the nuance on that continuum, and we can't understand them without understand it.
[0] As an aside, I think that strict construction appeals to many HN readers because it is familiar, the way the compiler/processor interprets code/instructions. But consider that strict construction can face the same limitations in real-world applications as code, and while we sometimes must say 'computers can't solve that problem', courts don't have that luxury - they must output a solution, even if the code isn't up to the task.
But there is lots of text that is open to interpretation. The framers didn’t say “the government shall make no law regulating speech.” If they did, I’d argue all those First Amendment exceptions were unconstitutional. What they said instead is that the “freedom of speech” “shall not be abridged.” They referenced an existing concept (“freedom of speech”) that was understood to have exceptions and limitations.
Likewise, the 4th amendment prohibits “unreasonable” searches. The 8th amendment prohibits “cruel and unusual punishment.” The 14th amendment requires “equal protection of the laws.” What are those things? They are ambiguous concepts that courts can define.
The Constitution isn’t a set of “values” against which judges must assess law. It’s a written set of directives and constraints. It’s a contract that defines the outer scope of democracy.
The 4th amendment, likewise, doesn’t articulate a set of “values.” It says:
> The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated
Interpreting the word “their” does not require resort to “values.” Google’s server logs are not “your” data just because they record a hit from your computer. A phone company’s call records likewise are not “your” data. It’s not about “values,” but the plain meaning of ordinary English words.
Blaming “precedent” here is even more misguided. Precedent long ago departed from the text of the 4th amendment, importing this expansive “reasonable expectation of privacy” concept into a document where the word “privacy” or anything like it never appears.
If we get the courts to strike down things like metadata collection in 4th amendment grounds, it will only be because the courts ignore what the Constitution says, expands this precedent, and impkses one group’s “values” onto the public.