News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ... by rayiner on Sunday September 09, 2018 @06:34PM (#17948154)
> Trackers can be ‘attached’ while in a public space with magnetic clamps that don’t harm the car or need it be inside it. I can clearly leave a brick by your suitcase in the public space so it’s a privacy argument not a private property argumennt

Attaching a brick to someone’s suitcase with a magnetic clamp would be a trespass to chattels (which can result from any intentional physical contact, even if it does not damage the property). You can’t go around attaching things to other peoples’ property.

Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ... by Retric on Monday September 10, 2018 @07:39AM (#17951012)
I did not say attachment of the brick. But anyway, where and under which reading standards does the constitution prohibit this.

Our legal system is not base on such meaningless distinctions. But, it’s to interpret things such that the rule is you (government agents) can place a tracker in the bed of a pickup truck as long as it’s not attached. But, cases are decided based on context not the form actions take. So this is a privacy issue not a private property issue.

Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ... by rayiner on Monday September 10, 2018 @01:59PM (#17953633)
The brick/suitcase example doesn’t make any sense without attachment, so I read it into the hypo. But any physical contact inconsistent with ownership can be a trespass. You can’t go around putting bricks into peoples’ trucks either!

Trespass isn’t expressly mentioned in the constitution, but it is one that is at least consistent with the text. The 4A lists several kinds of private property, and prohibits unreasonable “search” or “seizure” of that property. What is an “search” or “seizure” of private property? The structure of the text makes clear that it is a wrongful intrusion by a government agent onto property. What do we call wrongful intrusions onto private property? Generally, it’s trespass.

“Privacy,” on the other hand, doesn’t fit the textual formula at all. The text says nothing about “privacy.” The contemporaneous debate said nothing about privacy. Saying that the fourth amendment is about “protecting privacy” totally abandons the textual nexus between a “search” and some private property. It is in fact an example of fallacious reasoning. It is the conclusion that because a “search” is one way to invade someone’s privacy, that anything that invades someone’s privacy is a “search.”