News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA metadata program “consistent” with Fourth Amendment, ... by rayiner on Sunday September 09, 2018 @06:58PM (#17948249)
Textualism does not mean there is no room for judicial interpretation. Some text is more open to interpretation than other text. In the 4th amendment, the text makes clear that it is a private right—it protects “their” house, papers, effects, etc. We can argue about what that means (I think metadata is not “yours” because you didn’t produce it, you don’t own it, and you typically don’t even have access to it.) But leaving that aside, whatever defintion of “their” we choose, we must respect that the word creates a textual limit. We can’t go applying the 4th amendment to property that is not “theirs” by appeal to some higher values.

But there is lots of text that is open to interpretation. The framers didn’t say “the government shall make no law regulating speech.” If they did, I’d argue all those First Amendment exceptions were unconstitutional. What they said instead is that the “freedom of speech” “shall not be abridged.” They referenced an existing concept (“freedom of speech”) that was understood to have exceptions and limitations.

Likewise, the 4th amendment prohibits “unreasonable” searches. The 8th amendment prohibits “cruel and unusual punishment.” The 14th amendment requires “equal protection of the laws.” What are those things? They are ambiguous concepts that courts can define.

There are no comments on this comment yet.