"Suffering is optional" is a concept that dies immediately if you apply even a tiny amount of creativity to the question. It also fails if applied to animals.
It's really only available to people in a specific range of situations, and often it's stated not because it's actually true, but because it makes people feel powerful in situations where they're rather powerless. Which is mostly the point of stoicism anyway, as it is a philosophy developed during a time when people felt that they couldn't change anything about the world.
Of course, this means it's a poor philosophy to follow if your interest is in things improving, and not in just you personally not caring about them, something that many people already accomplish all too well...
> it's a poor philosophy to follow if your interest is in things improving
Stoicism helps people accomplish more, by letting them transcend the things that are holding them back that they control.
I think you’re projecting your own beliefs onto others.
So you claim that love, justice, truth, and honor are not real “by definition”? And, moreover, that everyone agrees with you on this?
> I think you should find another fight to pick with someone else.
Who’s “picking a fight” here? You’re being weirdly defensive.
Semantic arguments are a complete and utter waste of time.
Also, there are plenty of “abstract concepts” which are not empirically observable but which most people would agree should be considered “real” in some measure. If you require empirical observability for something to be real, you end up like Descartes, believing only in your own consciousness (and God for some reason). While there’s some wisdom in this viewpoint, there are more practically useful definitions of reality.
Also also, it’s worth pointing out that the position you’re arguing for is called empiricism, and it is one of many theories of what comprises reality. You are participating in an argument by stating that your position is obviously correct and beyond reproach.
The normal way out of a semantic argument is to just acknowledge the different definitions people are bringing and moving on with that in mind, but you’re not willing to do that. You are the one instigating the semantic argument here.
Frankl was a Jewish psychiatrist who survived Auschwitz, and one of his points (as I understand it) is that humans deeply desire to know that their life is meaningful, and even if another person is torturing you, you can find meaning by maintaining your human dignity in the face of the evil around you.
The stories in the book are heartbreaking, but there is a clear sense that it's possible to find something even when it seems like there's nothing. I guess he would say: perhaps you can't always find peace, but you can find meaning.
It’s an absolutely different story when you are being wrongfully interrogated in the USSR and thus giving up simply implies a life in prison. And the other option is another day of torture.
Suffering is relative.
* you feel less pain if you cause it for yourself (you've already conquered fear)
* mindfulness eases pain because of more knowledge / seeing, less fear
I wonder if suffering is only optional if you inflict it on yourself.