News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by projektir on Friday September 07, 2018 @05:14PM (#17937700)
At the very least, you could damage someone's brain faculties to the point that they can no longer philosophize their way out of suffering. And that is likely unnecessary, some drugs should suffice.

"Suffering is optional" is a concept that dies immediately if you apply even a tiny amount of creativity to the question. It also fails if applied to animals.

It's really only available to people in a specific range of situations, and often it's stated not because it's actually true, but because it makes people feel powerful in situations where they're rather powerless. Which is mostly the point of stoicism anyway, as it is a philosophy developed during a time when people felt that they couldn't change anything about the world.

Of course, this means it's a poor philosophy to follow if your interest is in things improving, and not in just you personally not caring about them, something that many people already accomplish all too well...

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by odyssey7 on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:57PM (#17938540)
This is an interesting take. But I'd have to disagree about this:

> it's a poor philosophy to follow if your interest is in things improving

Stoicism helps people accomplish more, by letting them transcend the things that are holding them back that they control.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Friday September 07, 2018 @07:53PM (#17938520)
There are quite a lot of things which people transmit as true beliefs, which we all know are false. We tell people that not only love exists, but true love, and justice, and objective truth, and honor. No one has ever touched or measured an atom of love -- but we all need to feel loved, and acting like love or truth or honor don't exist leads to atrocities. Funny old world, ain't it?
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by antidesitter on Saturday September 08, 2018 @01:35PM (#17941830)
> which we all know are false

I think you’re projecting your own beliefs onto others.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Saturday September 08, 2018 @08:13PM (#17943551)
I was speaking a little loosely, but if you want to advance an argument for the empirical existence of abstract concepts, I'm sure I'd be interested.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by antidesitter on Saturday September 08, 2018 @08:37PM (#17943636)
It’s not about what I believe. It’s that your original comment made it seem that everyone “knows” these things are false, which is not true (not even loosely).
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Saturday September 08, 2018 @09:40PM (#17943825)
Those are abstract concepts, which are considered to not be real by definition. I think you should find another fight to pick with someone else.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by antidesitter on Sunday September 09, 2018 @11:00AM (#17946192)
> which are considered to not be real by definition

So you claim that love, justice, truth, and honor are not real “by definition”? And, moreover, that everyone agrees with you on this?

> I think you should find another fight to pick with someone else.

Who’s “picking a fight” here? You’re being weirdly defensive.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Sunday September 09, 2018 @12:39PM (#17946635)
You're making a purely semantic argument, concerning some very common words, which I actually consider to be somewhat rude. It doesn't seem to be the case that you did not understand the intended meaning, but rather that you are deliberately choosing misconstrusion. If you don't think that there is a well-understood sense by which "abstract" means "not real", then that sounds like an argument that a dictionary or encyclopedia would be better-qualified to answer than myself.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by drdeca on Sunday September 09, 2018 @12:50AM (#17944428)
By definition? I don't consider abstract concept to be not real by definition. I don't think you are using a definition that I am familiar with.
[dead]
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by burke on Sunday September 09, 2018 @11:37AM (#17946370)
The issue here is that no one in this thread is being clear about what they mean when they say “real”.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Sunday September 09, 2018 @12:11PM (#17946518)
The distinction between "abstract" and "measurable" is not ambiguous. "Real" in this context (and most others) means "empirically observable", as in, you and I are able to make an observation or measurement and arrive at similar values. Abstract concepts are by definition not empirically observable.

Semantic arguments are a complete and utter waste of time.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by burke on Sunday September 09, 2018 @01:00PM (#17946740)
There is no one true definition of “real” until you bring in your accessory definition of “empirically obserble”. Semantic arguments are typically a waste of time, and by not being clear about your definition and berating everyone for not being in your head already, you are creating one.

Also, there are plenty of “abstract concepts” which are not empirically observable but which most people would agree should be considered “real” in some measure. If you require empirical observability for something to be real, you end up like Descartes, believing only in your own consciousness (and God for some reason). While there’s some wisdom in this viewpoint, there are more practically useful definitions of reality.

Also also, it’s worth pointing out that the position you’re arguing for is called empiricism, and it is one of many theories of what comprises reality. You are participating in an argument by stating that your position is obviously correct and beyond reproach.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Sunday September 09, 2018 @02:54PM (#17947207)
It's still a semantic argument if you repeat it.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by burke on Sunday September 09, 2018 @06:17PM (#17948087)
You can’t just shut down a semantic argument by taking a position, asserting its correctness, and refusing to acknowledge other views, as a premise of your broader argument.

The normal way out of a semantic argument is to just acknowledge the different definitions people are bringing and moving on with that in mind, but you’re not willing to do that. You are the one instigating the semantic argument here.

Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Monday September 10, 2018 @11:32AM (#17952512)
Bullshit. I said exactly what I intended to say; the distinction between empirical observation and other forms of truth was pretty much the entire point. I mean, you did actually read what I wrote, right?
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by erikpukinskis on Saturday September 08, 2018 @12:45PM (#17941590)
What’s your proof that love, honor, and truth don’t exist?
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Saturday September 08, 2018 @08:11PM (#17943545)
That would be the definition of an abstract concept, I believe.
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by erikpukinskis on Tuesday September 11, 2018 @12:12PM (#17961038)
What’s an example of something that’s not an abstract concept?
Re:'Mindful people' feel less pain by canhascodez on Saturday September 15, 2018 @06:28PM (#17996331)
Well, if this is Philosophy 201, then clearly everything is abstract, and something something Plato's cave. However, the default position is that (surprise!) objective reality exists. Things that are observable and measurable are not abstract. Those things around you that you can perceive with your senses are not abstract. For a more in-depth perspective, you could take a look at the Wikipedia pages for: empiricism, epistemology, philosophy of science. Also, the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy should have a reasonably topical article about Rationalism vs. Empiricism.