Even if there is "someone else" that may not be enough. It the "alternative" cannot support video (such as YouTube and Netflix), or can't upload my data at a reasonable speed, it isn't really a competitor.
Now this might apply poorly to ISPs where there are all kinds of frictions and potential barriers to entry, so maybe the regulator is getting this one wrong. But the court decided not to wade into an argument that is more about economics than law.
We could have laws where there was less regulatory discretion. But they would need to be written differently, and as a society we would have to just accept that they will sometimes throw up absurd results in corner-cases.
If it is, the incumbent will be more restrained in their prices, to avoid inducing the competitor to enter that market.
That's basically the crux of the matter, and the judge rules both ways of looking at things are reasonable since no one knows the future.
It's realistic to imagine a competitor could expand, but it's a far cry from actual competition.
These half-mile ranges shouldn't be lumped in with locations that have choices.
Right. Businesses are often currently wired for only one ISP. And the question is: "Can I buy future service from the other guy?"
It's a fuzzy question, because you can essentially always buy service...for some amount of money.
The evidence presented (and deemed credible by the court) is that ISPs will frequently build connections for businesses up to one mile away. And most of the businesses in question were less than half a mile away. And so the court ruled that the FCC could choose to call the market competitive, based on that evidence.
It's an unsatisfyingly fuzzy question, with perhaps an equally unsatisfying answer.