News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by philipkglass on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:21PM (#17870935)
The atmospheric noble gas concentrations, in ppmv:

Helium 5.24

Neon 18.18

Krypton 1.14

Argon 9340

Xenon 0.087

http://www.gly.uga.edu/railsback/Fundamentals/AtmosphereComp...

Krypton is rarer in the atmosphere than helium (by molar/volume concentration), though more abundant by mass. Krypton is commercially produced by atmospheric separation. I would therefore expect helium sourced by air separation to cost roughly 1/4-1/5 the cost of krypton production, per liter, or 4-5 times as much per gram. A quick search on Google shows krypton at 65 cents per liter in the early 2000s (according to an article about windowpane gas filling). An Alibaba search indicates that 10-15 cents per liter may be more typical now.

If those krypton prices are accurate, and I haven't made any major mistakes with my helium ballparking, I would expect that applications like helium filled hard drives would see only a tiny cost increase should they be forced to use helium separated from the atmosphere. I think that most cryogenic cooling applications would have to move to closed-cycle reuse of helium. I don't know about welding and leak testing.

EDIT: "The Energy-Related Applications of Helium", 1980 report from Los Alamos National Laboratory, specifically considers helium production from atmospheric separation and from lean natural gas streams in section X.

https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/5141581

A.W. Francis has discussed the recovery of helium from the atmosphere by conventional methods. He predicts that, for helium produced from the atmosphere as a by-product from air separation plants, the cost would lie in the range of $200 to $300 per Mcf in 1973 dollars (over ten times present cost).

...

To go further and separate helium by similar techniques but with helium as the primary product would raise the cost by more than another order of magnitude to about $7000 Mcf in 1980 dollars.

Apparently one Mcf is 28,317 liters in SI units. That's 24.7 cents per liter of helium from the atmosphere in 1980 dollars, or 80 cents per liter in CPI-adjusted 2018 dollars.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by restallus on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:46PM (#17871854)
Krypton is relatively cheap because, while it is produced by atmospheric distillation, it is a by-product of oxygen/nitrogen production. The boiling point of oxygen is -183 °C, and the boiling point of krypton is -153 °C. This means that when you distill air and obtain liquid oxygen, krypton will necessarily also be obtained as a liquid.

Helium, however, has the very low boiling point of -267 °C. Commercial, high-scale production of oxygen doesn't even approach this temperature, so helium will never be distilled and instead be vented as a gas along with a residual air stream.

The point is that the price of krypton is actually the marginal cost of producing it from an existing process, while the price of helium will approach the cost of energy required to extract it, which can be calculated and is quite high.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by philipkglass on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:02PM (#17872006)
Those are good points. The report from LANL that I edited in after my original rough estimate mentions these issues too. It estimates an electricity requirement of about 170,000 kWh to produce one Mcf (28,317 liters) of helium by atmospheric separation in a dedicated plant. The cost of electricity dominates the overall process cost for helium production via atmospheric separation. In the state with the cheapest industrial electricity, Washington, it would cost nearly 27 cents per liter of helium for the electricity alone.

https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph...

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by dopamean on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:00PM (#17871987)
I've got a really dumb question that maybe you can answer. Keep in mind the last time I was in a chemistry class was 10th grade (half my life ago)...

How is the boiling point of any of these elements determined? I cant imagine that we got some helium in its gaseous form and cooled it down below -267 degrees and then heated it up slowly to find out. Is there something about it's atomic makeup that allows that number to just be calculated? Thanks.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by iaw on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:45PM (#17872353)
No one really answered your question so I'll give it a shot.

Increasing the pressure on a gas increases it's boiling point. If you have a lot of pure helium gas and a really good compressor you can increase the pressure until the boiling point is high enough to exceed the temperature of the gas, so now you have a liquid helium at an insane pressure.

Next, drop the pressure and stick a thermometer into the liquid. When you hit atmospheric pressure the liquid will be boiling, but boiling liquids don't exceed their boiling point/temperature so helium is going to be waaay cold.

You can see this yourself: take a can of dust off or butane, turn it upside down and spray a bit into a shot glass (do not drink or breathe, super toxic). Instead of an aerosol spray a liquid will come out and begin to boil in the process making the glass super cold...

So, what's happening here you may wonder? It's chemistry/physics in action. When a pot of water boils on your stove it takes the heat energy from the burner and uses it to change states from liquid to gas. If you pour liquid water onto a piece of hot metal it turns into steam (boiling) while cooling off the metal (removing heat).

So when you take any liquid and rapidly raise it above it's boiling point (due to pressure or temperature changes) it will lower the temperature around it in order to obtain the energy it needs to change states.

All that being said, compressed helium is the most abundant means of cooling for low-temperature purposes because of these properties.

By boiling compressed helium at room temperature and pressure we can make something that super cold -267 degrees, at least while the helium continues to boil.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by black6 on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @07:19PM (#17872913)
> If you have a lot of pure helium gas and a really good compressor you can increase the pressure until the boiling point is high enough to exceed the temperature of the gas, so now you have a liquid helium at an insane pressure.

The critical temperature of Helium is 9.35 °R -- above that it will not be a liquid at any pressure. So we have to go through successive phases of compression (which heats it up), cooling via another cryogen (liquid nitrogen initially, then liquid hydrogen in subsequent passes), and expansion (at the right conditions, because of the oddities of the Joule-Thompson effect[0] for elements like Helium), in order to cool it enough to produce a liquid.

[0] https://chemistry.stackexchange.com/questions/61517/reason-f...

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by magicalhippo on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @06:00PM (#17872450)
Not only did we do just that, it was done for the first time 110 years ago, in 1908.

You can read more and see some pictures here: http://www.dwc.knaw.nl/wp-content/HSSN/2007-10-Van%20Delft-F...

Illustration of the helium liquefier at page 403.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by garmaine on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:06PM (#17872052)
> How is the boiling point of any of these elements determined? I cant imagine that we got some helium in its gaseous form and cooled it down below -267 degrees and then heated it up slowly to find out.

Why not? That's relatively easy to do in any moderately equipped physics lab.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by salty_biscuits on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @08:21PM (#17873191)
A lot of these macroscopic features of things are really, really hard to work out from microscopic details from first principles. Things like why is coal black, water wet, etc? Not a stupid question at all.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by thaumasiotes on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:24PM (#17872195)
> Is there something about it's atomic makeup that allows that number to just be calculated?

Yes, of course, but sadly we don't know how to do that.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by dnautics on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:55PM (#17872422)
Helium is extra special because some quantum weirdness happens, e.g. superfluid things
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by InclinedPlane on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:08PM (#17871445)
This is a hugely flawed analysis. Noble gases are extracted from air through liquefaction, which requires dropping the temperature of air to the point where certain component gases are liquid, allowing them to be separated off.

Krypton has a boiling point of 120 Kelvin, far higher than even Oxygen (90 K) or Nitrogen (77 K), making it trivial to extract Krypton at low cost from the atmosphere in any air liquefaction facility also set up to separate Oxygen and Nitrogen (which is basically all of them). Helium, however, boils at 4 Kelvin. It is not merely cryogenic, it is super cryogenic, and it can only be separated from air via liquefaction at extremely low temperatures.

Instead, the method that is actually used to produce almost all Helium is to use natural gas (which contains as much as 7% Helium) and then separate out all of the stuff that isn't Helium (starting with the hydrocarbons, of course). This makes it possible to produce 99.995% pure "grade-A" Helium fairly cost effectively. Every cubic meter of natural gas processed could yield up to 70 liters of grade-A Helium. Compare that to processing air, where every cubic meter of air processed would yield just 5 milliliters of low grade Helium. And Helium isn't valuable enough to simply run those plants and throw away the other gases produced.

By some estimates, if all of the Neon production facilities were modified to produce Helium as well then we might be able to meet 1/1000th of the world's Helium demand, so this is not a near-term solution to the problem, even if it might be able to produce the gas inexpensively.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by Boxxed on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:14PM (#17871511)
Naively, couldn't you extract helium by liquifying everything else and taking the leftover gas? So instead of cooling to 4 kelvin, cool to the boiling point of the element with the 2nd lowest boiling temperature. Or is that not helpful because that happens to be very low too?
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by ant6n on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:05PM (#17872035)
Even further, shouldn't it only be necessary to liquefy down to Nitrogen, which should leave some gas that has a very high percentage of helium, and then use the same method that's used in separation of natural gas and Helium?
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by thaumasiotes on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:27PM (#17872218)
Further? That's the same idea.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by ant6n on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @06:54PM (#17872793)
The difference is liquifying "to the boiling point of the element with the 2nd lowest boiling temperature" (likely Neon @ 27K) and "liquifying down to Nitrogen" (77K).
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by thaumasiotes on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @09:47PM (#17873556)
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural-gas_processing , the helium is recovered from natural gas during the phase in which nitrogen is removed. Natural gas has very different content compared to the atmosphere.

Let's also note that even ignoring the specific details of the process, what you're proposing is to use a pipeline which produces helium as a side effect of its intended use of producing methane, and which is usually run on a mixture of gases that is 1% or more helium, and apply it to a mixture of gases which will produce no methane and is 0.0005% helium. The helium is nearly worthless and there's barely any to harvest in the first place; there is no possible way for this to be economical.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by ant6n on Thursday August 30, 2018 @11:04AM (#17877319)
Well, the idea is to produce Helium as a by-product of producing liquid nitrogen. But indeed, the numbers may not work out:

About 8 million tons of liquid nitrogen is produced per year, growing 5% every year [1], largely from Cryogenic distillation. By mass, the ratio of Nitrogen and Helium in air is about 1e6 [2]. So that means, about 8 tons would be produced, which is 3.5 orders of magnitude away from the current size of the market (like 30 thousand tons). But it may be possible to use non-cryogenic processes [3] to increase the ratio of Helium in the air before separating out the nitrogen. So between the increase of the nitrogen market, the decrease in demand if Helium gets more expensive when traditional sources run out, and better processes, this means that Helium will likely continue to be available for very valuable use cases almost indefinitely.

[1] https://www.grandviewresearch.com/industry-analysis/liquid-n...

[2] http://www.uigi.com/air.html

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_separation

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by InclinedPlane on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @07:27PM (#17872964)
Yes, that's how you could do it by modifying liquefaction plants that can produce Neon. In theory, you could take the leftovers after separating out Neon and you'd have a small amount of Helium. As I mentioned, at 5 ppm that doesn't give you much Helium, and you still need to purify it.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by mehrdadn on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:41PM (#17872318)
I'd guess you'd still have problem separating helium from hydrogen?
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by amluto on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @06:07PM (#17872501)
That seems relatively straightforward to solve chemically. Hydrogen can be adsorbed by many different materials. Or you could add just the right amount of oxygen to burn the hydrogen and then condense the water out.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by zrm on Thursday August 30, 2018 @01:42AM (#17874331)
Couldn't this also be done for the other reactive components (especially nitrogen and oxygen) before cooling the gas? Removing ~99% of the mass ahead of time would require that much less energy for cooling.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by londons_explore on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:02AM (#17874851)
Liquid oxygen and nitrogen both have some commercial value.

The tricky but is the liquidation process only liquifies some small fraction of the gas. The rest remains as a gas, so you now have "helium enriched" air, but it is still a very small percentage helium.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by HarryHirsch on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:08PM (#17871453)
You wonder about krypton and xenon, these are gases with only speciality applications and are probably minor byproducts from an air liquefaction plant. The market for helium is much much larger.

To ramp up production you'd have to build a new plant, and pay for it only through the sale of minor noble gases, the cross-subsidy from nitrogen and oxygen suddenly disappeared. Markets involving joint products are funny things.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by ridgeguy on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @09:03PM (#17873374)
OT, but kind of interesting - Xe, one of the 'inert' gases you've listed, is a remarkably effective and safe general anesthetic as well as a cardio- and neuroprotective agent for some kinds of ischemic events [1].

Still a little weird to those of us who studied chemistry when the 'noble gases' were famously reluctant to mingle.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenon#Anesthesia

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by goatsi on Thursday August 30, 2018 @12:28AM (#17874090)
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by dogma1138 on Thursday August 30, 2018 @04:19AM (#17874934)
So does Freon, I got “high” on that one once was the weirdest trip of my life it’s an extremely short trip but time simply froze for me.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by criddell on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:48PM (#17871231)
Helium is so light, won't it rise to the top of the atmosphere? Wouldn't that make it more difficult to extract from the atmosphere?
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by philipkglass on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:54PM (#17871310)
Earth's atmosphere does not exhibit notable stratification by molecular weight until about 100 km up. The lower well-mixed portion is called the homosphere, and it is where these standard atmospheric composition values are measured. This near-uniform composition is also why, for instance, chlorofluorocarbons emitted at the surface reach the ozone layer and decompose it catalytically, even though their molecular weight is much greater than that of air.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by garmaine on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:26PM (#17872211)
It's not rising to the top of the atmosphere per se, but rather that atomic helium is so light that at atmospheric temperature a significant percentage of individual atoms are moving at Earth's escape velocity. Usually they bounce into something else, but there's always some lucky few that make their way through the upper atmosphere... and keep going.

That's why, for example, Saturn's atmosphere is 25% helium and 75% hydrogen, but Saturn's moon Titan is basically all nitrogen-methane.

Which is also the real answer about helium. Hydrogen we have in near-infinite supply by breaking chemical bonds (e.g. in water). Helium doesn't react with anything, so so the small amount trapped in oil and natural gas deposits from Earth's radioactivity over billions of years is all we have. After that... we'd better start investing in outer solar system mining operations, skimming the atmospheres of gas giants.

I, for one, look forward to a future working the gas mines.

Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by DonHopkins on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @10:07PM (#17873643)
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by saagarjha on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:53PM (#17871289)
Helium is constantly produced by radioactive decay in the Earth’s crust. I’d assume that this is the helium that’s found in the atmosphere; the rest probably escapes.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by ant6n on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:03PM (#17872010)
The Helium in the atmosphere is in the equilibrium of being produced by radioactive decay and escaping to space.
Re:We Discovered Helium 150 Years Ago. Are We Running Out? by saagarjha on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:52PM (#17872396)
Yeah, that's what I meant. Thanks for putting it into words better than I did.