News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by pietroglyph on Friday August 24, 2018 @02:46AM (#17833221)
> "To photographers and stargazers in northern climes, Steve has been a familiar night phenomenon for decades. But the mysterious ribbons of light only entered the scientific literature for the first time earlier this year"

It's so exciting to realize how little we really know. Think about how many fantastic unexplained things there must be in the universe if we haven't even finished understanding the ones right under our noses. There's so much complexity that we can easily create things that are too complicated for one person, or even many, to fully understand.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by fsloth on Friday August 24, 2018 @04:17AM (#17833537)
"Think about how many fantastic unexplained things there must be in the universe if we haven't even finished understanding the ones right under our noses."

Well said. I think because so much is already in our books we forget how much miraculous things actually surround us and we forget to look at them and seek them.

Some biologist anecdotally said that the best place to hunt new species unknown to science is your own back yard.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by AstralStorm on Friday August 24, 2018 @04:32AM (#17833581)
So many fantastic things you won't get to research or even see because you're working half your life for someone or something.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by throwaway76543 on Friday August 24, 2018 @04:54AM (#17833668)
On the other hand, without all this working for others we wouldn't have a system which lets us spend that other half of our lives seeing the things we do get to see.

It's a net win overall.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Friday August 24, 2018 @05:58AM (#17833918)
That's just speculation, what system are you imagining in place of 'wage labour'? chattel? I imagine UBI and an explosion in the sciences; When anyone with interest can afford to follow that interest.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by throwaway76543 on Friday August 24, 2018 @06:32AM (#17834042)
No, it's not speculation. I have a cite: literally the entire progression of human history and societal development.

Steady (and in the last century, enormous) progression toward more leisure time, with more wealth and latitude at our disposal than ever before.

UBI is good. You're going to fund UBI by working for other people.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by rfrey on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:10AM (#17834693)
How are you measuring leisure time? My impression is that great gains were made in the union heyday of the 40s-60s, but that leisure time for most workers has been declining since then. The move to almost universal dual income households means outside-work time is spent doing the stuff that used to be done during the day. Also many more people have a second job. I’d be greatly heartened by data showing leisure time had increased in, say, the last 50 years.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by throwaway76543 on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:42AM (#17835613)
If the context here is the development of human history leading up to notions of private employment then our timeline is in the tens of thousands of years and variations within past decades become almost irrelevant. Comparing hunter-gatherers or roaming tribes with modern city dwellers? Enough said.

I'm not sure I disagree with you about the last 50 years. I think it's a bit of a hard topic to dissect because the notion of a "workday" is relative and changes over time. I think a day of work is a lot easier now than in the 1950s and I think the ancillary work we perform to care for ourselves and our homes is reduced. By how much, I'm not sure how to quantify.

I recall Hans Rosling did a great talk along these lines, "The Magic Washing Machine." It's mostly talking about the mechanization of household labor in the mid century which we agree took place. I think since then we no longer spend as much time cooking, or cleaning, maintaining our appliances or cars. I think improvements in communication systems save a surprising amount of time -- consider how many hours a month you might waste if cell phones didn't exist? If you had to drive to a place to sign paperwork instead of fill out an online form?

There's nothing so large as the washing machine in the last 50 years but I think we have a significant amount of small improvements. Coupled with work becoming more palatable (part of why work/life becomes blurred is that some large percentage of us enjoy working) I think there's a possibility that labor has shrank in the last 50 years even if people work longer hours. Which they may not, factoring in household labor.

I know many people who do not need to work as hard as they do -- some who do not need to work at all. Yet they still do, even when the requirement is removed.

My opinion about the last 50 years is fairly weakly held, I'm basically just thinking freely. My strong comments above are in reference to the development of much more basic notions like "private employment."

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:31AM (#17834490)
Having a system to enriches the few who don't need more wealth reinforced by impoverishing the many is better than chattel slavery and worse than a system which offers real choice and ownership of ones labor.
[dead]
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by dang on Monday August 27, 2018 @10:20PM (#17856172)
Can you please not do flamewars on HN?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:02AM (#17834650)
maybe. History shows me that, unregulated, our system makes kings and queens that own not only own land and wealth but people as well.

If i wanted to make a system that insured the absolute minimum advancement and progress, the absolute maximum misery and poverty, while giving a random few almost god like powers..

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by hueving on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:16AM (#17834416)
UBI doesn't work because it depends on people working to fund it. The amount of money required for poverty level UBI in the US (one of the richest countries) is more than all of the federal current tax revenue, which comes from working people.

We can't all decide we are going to live for free and magically still get to drive cars, live in houses, eat food, have running water, etc.

The entire point of the economic system is to motivate people to help each other. If the money motivation goes away, people either stop helping each other or you have to motivate with violence.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by jon-wood on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:39AM (#17834526)
The funding for UBI would require more funding than the current federal tax revenue. One of the things that would be necessary to make it work is redistribution of wealth. Taking taxes large corporates who are increasingly making more money through automation and the removal of jobs, so that it can be used to fund a better lifestyle for the majority of people.

Sadly I don't see a political environment where that's actually viable any time soon, but at some point we're going to have to see a move in that direction because there will be an ever decreasing pool of jobs that require actual people.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by throwaway76543 on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:52AM (#17834594)
The cost of UBI depends entirely on the magnitude of the benefit; your position is indefensible given we haven't established the magnitude.

Obviously increasing welfare implies increased taxes. I don't see anything controversial there? I do agree the USA currently lacks the political will to move much in this direction.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:24AM (#17834463)
..in your opinion. But in reality the current system doesn't work and needs constant massive bailouts and public funding R&D to just barely operate for the minority..

The entire point of the current economic system is to motivate the masses to enrich the few. If the motivation goes away then maybe people will work to enrich their own lives.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by windows_tips on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:42AM (#17834544)
>But in reality the current system doesn't work and needs constant massive bailouts and public funding R&D to just barely operate for the minority..

Says an HN comment..

Maybe try to rework this sentence, because it doesn't appear to be true. While things may not be excellent for everyone, clearly the "system" works to some extent.

>The entire point of the current economic system is to motivate the masses to enrich the few.

Do you have a source on this? What do you consider to be the current system? The Federal Reserve System?

>If the motivation goes away then maybe people will work to enrich their own lives.

Do you seriously not think that people work to enrich their own lives right now? I can tell you that I'm posting this to enrich mine.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:58AM (#17834631)
>Maybe try to rework this sentence

The current state of our market system requires massive bailouts and massive funding into research and development, massive subsidies (e.g. arms), and an overworked and underpaid workforce to limp along and pay out a healthy dividend to the richest(few) investors.

>source on this?

Just look at any multi billion dollar company; whats the difference between shareholder payout and worker payout? How else would you define this system where a company can declare hundred million dollar profits while paying minimum wage?

>Do you seriously not think that people work to enrich their own lives right now?

We try. for the last 8 hours i worked to make money that would enrich my life, but my work made someone else a hundred times this amount so 1% of my last 8 hours was for me.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by dexterdog on Friday August 24, 2018 @12:19PM (#17835869)
If somebody else is making 100x off of just your work you need to quit yesterday and find somebody to pay you 2x what you are currently making. They will be more than happy to do so as they will still be making a 50x profit on you.

Either that or you have absolutely no clue as to how much value you actually create for your company. Nobody generates 100x profit, not even slaves.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Friday August 24, 2018 @04:28PM (#17837672)
thank you for your advice, i think you missed my point though.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by dexterdog on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:25AM (#17858593)
I thought your point was that somebody else is actually making 99-100 dollars for every dollar that you make. I would like to know how you came to that number.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by cortic on Monday September 10, 2018 @10:35PM (#17956799)
i worked out those numbers roughly for myself. My point though, was; most of, or at least the majority of my working life is to enrich someone who is richer that could can ever be. This is the nature of the relationship between the shareholder and the common worker.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by wallace_f on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:39AM (#17834530)
ubi isn't doing away with markets or the profit motive. it's just: here is enough money you don't die. so more people can pursue their passions. OP is probably excessively optimistic that will be science. in reality it will probably not be. but it's a lot better than useless bureaucracies, inefficiencies and the willingness to do whatever so you don't die
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by tomrod on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:02AM (#17834648)
UBI currently exists, it's level is just 0,if you don't count existing community welfare programs.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by pc86 on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:16AM (#17834725)
> UBI currently exists

I mean if we're willfully misinterpreting what UBI is to prove a worthlessly pedantic point, sure.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by sametmax on Friday August 24, 2018 @05:07AM (#17833709)
Even things we do understand and that we have documented are underused.

Let's take a few examples.

I had Malaria 10 years ago. Well, did you know Atovaquone-Proguanil (e.g: Malarone) can not only prevent Malaria, but also __cure__ it, killing the plasmodium in the liver?

Still, most people, including a lot of doctors, think you can't cure Malaria and you have to live with it for life.

The first documented death related to asbestos was in 1906, yet it was only banned a century later (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asbestos).

WHO declared in 2015 that processed meat was now classified as carcinogenic to humans. The information is publically available on their website (http://www.who.int/features/qa/cancer-red-meat/en/), but who knows about it ?

So not only our understanding of the universe is very limited, but also, our ability to propagate (https://xkcd.com/1053/ :)) and use said understanding is even more limited.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by ljcn on Friday August 24, 2018 @05:49AM (#17833870)
> The first documented death related to asbestos was in 1906, yet it was only banned a century later

Incredibly it's still not generally banned in the USA; only a small list of products are banned by the EPA federally.[0] It was increasingly banned in Europe from the mid 1980s, and totally banned throughout the EU in 2005.[1]

[0] https://www.epa.gov/asbestos/us-federal-bans-asbestos [1] https://cordis.europa.eu/news/rcn/13445_en.html

> but who knows about it ?

That was big news in Europe, e.g. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-34615621

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by ekianjo on Friday August 24, 2018 @06:35AM (#17834046)
>Incredibly it's still not generally banned in the USA; only a small list of products are banned by the EPA federally.[0] It was increasingly banned in Europe from the mid 1980s, and totally banned throughout the EU in 2005.[1]

Like everything else, everything is deadly at large doses. Even water. Alcohol clearly causes stomach cancer too at large doses, yet alcohol is not banned, right? If we were to ban everything that leads to a certain point of toxicity, we would not be able to live with anything around us. Toxicity is factored by exposure, which is why "carcinogenic risk" is not a binary variable.

https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/s...

> Everyone is exposed to asbestos at some time during their life. Low levels of asbestos are present in the air, water, and soil. However, most people do not become ill from their exposure. People who become ill from asbestos are usually those who are exposed to it on a regular basis, most often in a job where they work directly with the material or through substantial environmental contact.

The ones who are at the most risk in regard to asbestos are workers in construction or demolition. And in most countries how they should work with asbestos is now clearly regulated (safety gear and procedures).

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by wowDude on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:58AM (#17834341)

  everything is deadly at large doses

  ...

  if we were to ban everything that leads to 
  a certain point of toxicity, we would not 
  be able to live with anything around us
No, that's not how this works.

The salient point here, is that we know about specific things which are predominantly non-essential, and atrociously bad for everyone.

Lead. Asbestos. Cigarette smoke. DDT. Plutonium. This list is not exhaustive.

Believe it or not, humanity is well acquainted with some natural, persistent, toxic villains, that no one needs to share a room with. No one's life is actually better with any of these things.

Yeah, coffee has low concentrations of acrylamide in it. Then, use that to argue that there's the same sort of calculated risk in the stimulant side-effects sought by those who self administer a cigarette's dose of smoke.

People try to form the same sort of argument, when contrasting natural substances and materials, versus synthetic counterparts. Gee, everything's natural! Yes, and the sun will swallow the better part of the solar system during its red giant phase. Except, that's not the point.

Muddying the waters, by digging up grey zone edge cases doesn't make asbestos a desirable choice for consumer goods, or even professional products. It doesn't make cigarettes good for anyone. It doesn't make lead a practical additive for gasoline. It doesn't mean we should render random birds extinct as by-catch, so we can barbecue all summer. It doesn't mean plutonium, in any amount, should be handled beyond the watchful eyes of armed guards by pretty much anyone.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by tomatotomato37 on Friday August 24, 2018 @10:39AM (#17835169)
The thing is though that most of the materials in that list can still be used in ways that don't incur risk. Just because making your water system out of a toxic metal is a bad idea doesn't mean you should outlaw the use of fishing weights and lead-acid batteries, in the same way the banning the shoving of asbestos into every corner of a house doesn't mean you have to also stop using it in firefighting equipment.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by wowDude on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:49AM (#17839603)
Actually, it kind of does. We really should stop selling lead fishing weights, and avoid using lead-acid batteries as much as possible. Mostly, because the world really is a better place for everyone, when consumer retail channels aren't fire-hosing these things into the waste stream. Lead acid batteries probably have unique applications to brag about, but fishing weights don't.

Yes, on shelves, it's all controlled behind appealing packaging, and a yeah quantity of people derive pleasure from using things properly, and disposing of their waste responsibly, but another portion of people take it home will simply spew it out into the open, dumping it into landfills, where maybe it leaches into a water table, and maybe it doesn't. But if you look at the inputs, it all started with making and selling such products at all.

Fire departments probably benefit from the use of asbestos, as a niche class of use cases. Simply knowing that there are exceptions to general utility, should not guide choices about broad marketplace availability.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by kurthr on Friday August 24, 2018 @11:55AM (#17835718)
Relative Risk

The problem with DDT was that while it didn't cause significant problems for people (at the concentrations used), it caused huge problems for birds (thinned shells). At the same time it wiped out the mosquito carrying malaria along the gulf coast. The ecologic side effects were terrible, but in many cases human risk may well have been reduced.

Some asbestos is extremely dangerous, some is not (it depends on their chemical composition and microstructure)... using the same name for all of them is not helpful to safety, nor is declaring all of them dangerous.

There is Plutonium in the Pacific ocean. Should we guard the ocean, ban swimming in the ocean, ban fish caught in the ocean? Why, when sun exposure is much more likely to kill you with carcinoma than ocean plutonium?

I definitely am still going to go outside during the day even though the dangeous sun is irradiating me. I'm going to eat toast with dangerous acrylamide.

...And I'm not taking off the dangerous lead weights ballencing my tire rims on the drive to work, because I want to live.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by nate_meurer on Saturday August 25, 2018 @06:44AM (#17840344)
> And I'm not taking off the dangerous lead weights ballencing my tire rims on the drive to work

Yes you will, because they are being banned in a growing number of states and countries. Lead weights are already illegal in the EU and in several of the most populous states in the U.S.

> because I want to live.

That's silly. Unbalanced wheels are annoying, but they aren't dangerous unless the shimmy is extreme, like when you have a lot of mud stuck in your wheels, in which case wheel weights won't help anyway.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by wowDude on Saturday August 25, 2018 @12:32AM (#17839555)
Yeah, I mentioned all of those specific examples, because it brings exactly your kind of response out of the woodwork.

Come back to me and say that lives were saved.

- Malaria spreading mosquitos went away.

- Asbestos: it depends.

- Ban the ocean because Plutonium??? Well, that's just crazy talk!

- Rebel against the wind in your face! Let the sun shine! Drive a convertable, because lead makes it possible! Treat yourself!

All of those points are the kind of attitude that defers coping with the consequences of something, for selfish reasons now.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by sametmax on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:28AM (#17834235)
> The ones who are at the most risk in regard to asbestos are workers in construction or demolition. And in most countries how they should work with asbestos is now clearly regulated (safety gear and procedures).

Yes but this is something that is commonly badly understood: the problem with asbestos is not that we can't manage it, it's that it WILL be badly managed at some point.

If you handle arsenic, you won't put it in schools and offices. You will manipulate it in very specifically environment that accommodate specific activities and is filled with specific people.

With asbestos, you have it in unmarked exposed building parts. Some accident may damage them. Somebody may drill a hole to fix something. Some contractor may rebuilt part of something without noticing. And then a small but continuous dose of asbestos will invisibly goes into the occupant lungs for years.

It's like lead in water pipe. It's insidious.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by ljcn on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:36AM (#17834511)
I think sametmax wrote a great reply already. I'll just address your logical fallacies.

Generalisation fallacy 1: "some harmful things are not banned; asbestos is a harmful thing; asbestos should not be banned".

Thankfully most governments are more nuanced with their regulations. In the case of asbestos, since comparable materials exist with less potential for harm, they are favoured and/or the more harmful stuff is banned. Where not possible there can be exemptions, e.g. see my European Commission link earlier, along with the "ban" it says:

> One remaining use of chrysotile has not been banned, however - in diaphragms which are used for electrolysis in certain chlorine plants. This exception is justified because no safe alternative has been developed and this process is carried out on closed sites under strictly controlled conditions.

Generalisation fallacy 2: "asbestos can be dangerous; if handled safely asbestos is not dangerous; asbestos is not a large risk".

Because it can be used safely does not make it generally safe.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by mcguire on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:29PM (#17838590)
A list of known and probable carcinogens: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-causes/general-info/kno...

Posted while smoking my pipe and watching the sunset. Considering a ham sandwich, too.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by wildmusings on Friday August 24, 2018 @06:38AM (#17834064)
The ones at the most risk are those who also smoke tobacco. The difference in cancer rates between smokers and non-smokers with equal exposure is huge.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by abainbridge on Friday August 24, 2018 @07:10AM (#17834176)
> Incredibly it's still not generally banned in the USA

Surprisingly (to me) the restrictions on asbestos use were relaxed on 1 June 2018:

https://www.fastcompany.com/90208948/under-trumps-epa-asbest...

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by rbanffy on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:38AM (#17834846)
Sadly, it's not that surprising.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by sametmax on Friday August 24, 2018 @06:02AM (#17833929)
Making the news once doesn't mean people know about it, unfortunately.

Otherwise people would not vote for crooked politicians after their first idiotic behavior.

Unless you educate again and again, generation after generation, abstract knowledge doesn't stick.

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by Sharlin on Friday August 24, 2018 @05:19AM (#17833760)
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"

—Upton Sinclair

Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by nashashmi on Friday August 24, 2018 @08:32AM (#17834493)
We often get lost in the verbosity of textbooks and the amount of information bombarded at us that we fail to realize how primitive and simple the steps to discovering scientific knowledge were and how many centuries it took to compile this information into something we sort of understand today. Had we learned the science with this conscience in mind we would not only have taken the science with healthier doubt but also kept our own eyes open to find possibilities of deviations and reasons to make further discovery.
Re:Eerie Skyglow Called 'Steve' Isn't an Aurora, Is 'Complet... by some_account on Friday August 24, 2018 @05:31AM (#17833799)
There is a lot of "explained" things that are very wrong as well, it's just that scientists pick the "most likely" explanation since they have to.