Re:Apple confirms TV series order of Asimov’s Foundation
by stormbrew on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:59PM
(#17829324)
I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with taking a sparsely plotted novel (like The Hobbit or Foundation, both of which have a lot of details happen off-stage and sometimes bafflingly so) and fleshing out the details.
The problem with the Hobbit movies is just that they did that very badly.
Re:Apple confirms TV series order of Asimov’s Foundation
by fullshark on Thursday August 23, 2018 @02:06PM
(#17829375)
But that's why it would be such a great miniseries. You should use the novels as a framework, and allow showrunners to get creative fleshing out the characters and plot details. The Novels are pretty short, but dense with plot and ideas. A direct translation of the source material would be bad but the potential is there for a great adaptation if characters are more fleshed out.
Re:Apple confirms TV series order of Asimov’s Foundation
by true_religion on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:09PM
(#17831344)
There is precedent.
Look at Altered Carbon which got 10 hours for the first book, or The Man in the High Castle which was adapted into 2+ seasons for a book that's only 240 pages.
10 hours is the equivalent of the entire Hobbit trilogy of movies, for a book that is much shorter - and we all know how that turned out.