News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by MarkMc on Thursday August 23, 2018 @04:46AM (#17825623)
Person A says prosperity not increased for the middle-class since the 1970's, person B says it has.

Do they have to rely on historical data, or is there some experiment they could perform to determine who is right? For example, suppose I offered 10 people the opportunity to live like people lived in the 1970's. I would subsidise their housing and education costs, but they would pay more for clothes and food and air travel and phone calls. They would not have the internet and would only have a black-and-white TV with 4 stations and a gramophone record player for entertainment. If nobody accepted such an offer, would that settle the argument?

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by todd8 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:48AM (#17826113)
I was in college in the 70s, so yeah, it was a fun time for me when I think back on it. Who wouldn’t want to hear Aerosmith live in a club with maybe 80 people there before their first album.

But I walked to class cold and wet on many days. Gortex hadn’t been invented and I couldn’t afford a car. When I got my first real job I bought a car, but I carried a toolbox in the trunk. Cars broke down frequently and with no cell phones you were on your own if the car stopped running. A car accident could kill you in a 35 mph crash. I also carried a state highway map and a city map of around 100 pages in a spiral bound book because there was no GPS.

The best medicine available seems primitive by comparison to today. I had classmates that wore leg braces due to childhood polio. People were still dying from rabies, TB, and even Smallpox. There were cholera pandemics. No MRI, no CAT scans.

I was studying programming. I had to walk to campus at night to punch cards. No internet, no terminal, just a place to drop off cards so that you could pick up your output in the morning.

I was middle class in the 70s so I had it much better than many others. Most of us grew up with a single wired phone in the house, only one full bathroom, one black and white TV that received three channels, no DVD, no CDs.

A VCR player in 1975 was big and heavy and cost over $5000 in today’s dollars so none of us owned one.

Ubiquitous discrimination, bigotry, and prejudice made it harder for many to be middle class like I was.

Even in the 1970s, life was still much much better for me than my parents that had grew up on small farms during the dustbowl days of the Great Depression.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by scarface74 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:59AM (#17826457)
Ubiquitous discrimination, bigotry, and prejudice made it harder for many to be middle class like I was.

When I hear my parents talk about growing up in the segregated south in the 50s, there is nothing about it that makes me think - "wow life was so much better back then".

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by notfromhere on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:24PM (#17828540)
When people talk about how awesome the 60s were, it's usually because they were white middle-class or above in stable households and rising incomes.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by giardini on Thursday August 23, 2018 @02:05PM (#17829368)
The South in the 50s was definitely segregated, although the degree of prejudice varied. Whether white or black, life was likely not better than it is now.

But the OP was talking about the 70s and there is a world of difference. Once you get to the 70s the statement "wow life was so much better back then." becomes debatable for whites, at least.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by giardini on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:37PM (#17828632)
Sorry, your narrative timeline is simply incorrect. Perhaps b/c you did not live in the USA?

Gore-tex was invented in 1969 but was hardly necessary. Wool has always worked extremely well and still does: polyester was pretty good except in northern USA. I lived in the south and wore predominantly cotton: Levi jeans and cotton t-shirts were our uniform in the summer; winter we bought a jacket and lived with it.

In 1971 I bought a used American car with everything on it for $300. My East Indian college roommate loved to ride in it and very quickly got a license and car of his own. I later drove my $300 car from Texas to New York via the Midwest and DC to graduate school. I later drove that car to work and school around DC. I had tools but rarely needed them except for maintenance. The car was extremely reliable and needed only tuneups and tires. I gave it to a friend when I bought another car.

You didn't (and still don't) need a cell phone. It was (and is) easy to get help from strangers.

A car accident can kill you at 35 mph but they usually didn't (and usually don't). Cars are safer now and I appreciate that, but they weren't _that_ unsafe: people would not have driven them otherwise.

You complain about carrying a map and a zip code book - you should still (I do), since your phone or network could fail at any time. But you don't b/c in your heart you believe that you can rely on the kindness of strangers!

Medicine today is not much better than it was back then. Trauma care _is_ improved (the lessons of Vietnam were absorbed). But antibiotics worked better back then than today and other than antivirals and statins, the use of drugs hasn't improved much. As someone once said, doctors got no respect until antibiotics came along and, were they taken away, doctors would not get much respect now.

The remnants of the polio epidemics was still present in students of the 1950s (Salk developed his vaccine in 1952 and I was vaccinated ~1957). I too had classmates with polio braces, but polio in the USA was stopped by the vaccination campaigns before the 1970s.

People didn't die of rabies in the 1970s unless it was untreated.

People didn't die of TB in the 1970s unless it was unattended and/or advanced before treatment.

Smallpox was wiped out and routine immunization halted in 1970. The only cholera pandemics were offshore USA (e.g., the El Tor pandemic in Indonesia->Pakistan in the '70's).

I too carried punch cards (I started in the 60's) and was glad to do so: programming turned into a career. 4 years later in the mid-70's I had a terminal and multiple computers available in a network.

3 TV channels was plenty: I got the news and entertainment too, although after awhile I began to notice TV was turning into something akin to the "Bullshit Web" of today:

https://www.metafilter.com/175703/The-Bullshit-Web

VCRs were about $1000 in 1975 but they were available used for only hundreds of dollars. I have a used one that runs still today! In comparison my first CD player died after 3 years.

Neither discrimination nor bigotry nor prejudice were ubiquitous but they _were_ still present. Your description of prejudice fits the southern USA of the '50's, NOT the '70's.

Indeed my grandparents were small farmers (sharecroppers) and their and their children's (my parents') lives were hard. But the opportunities my parents had during their time were enormous and their lives were rich and memorable.

It probably remains true even today that antibiotics are man's most significant improvement of the last century.

But in summary I find your description of the 70s is off by fully 20 years.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by georgeecollins on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:59PM (#17829320)
> A car accident can kill you at 35 mph but they usually didn't (and usually don't). Cars are safer now and I appreciate that, but they weren't _that_ unsafe: people would not have driven them otherwise.

Cars were a lot less safe in 1971, that is a fact. No air bags, no anti-lock brakes, no traction control. Older cars didn't have seat belts, shoulder belts were rare, cars weren't built to crumple, steering columns would impale you, etc.

Fact, not anecdote: In 1971 there were 4.46 fatalities per million vehicle miles traveled (MVMT). In 2015 it was 1.18 fatalities per MVMT.

So yes, in fact cars were three times as dangerous as today.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by giardini on Thursday August 23, 2018 @05:33PM (#17830872)
1) What I stated was not anecdote: a car accident can kill you at 35 mph but they usually didn't (and don't).

2) I simply don't agree with your use of relative statistics, which reeks of alarmism. My doctors use such arguments in attempts to convince me to take statin drugs, which would at best extend my life for only a few days if I took them for 30 years. He always tells me that I'm "X times as likely to die from a heart attack" unless I take statins. I always remind him of the nature of his statistics, the side-effects of statins, and the non-present longevity payoff of taking them.

Once the number of fatalities per MVMT is below a certain value it ceases to be likely in the overall scheme of things and becomes unimportant.

Relative statistics ignore the prior probabilities - the fact that I'm unlikely to die driving in the first place. Yes, 4.46 deaths per MVMT is about 3 X 1.18, but both are low deaths per MVMT.

I may die from falling off a ladder or get eaten by a shark but neither is likely, nor am I now nor was I likely in the 70s to die in a car accident. Some other damn thing will most likely get me (that isn't anecdotal either).

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by wozniacki on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:04AM (#17826195)
Perhaps the deficit of happiness can be better explained by one of Peter Thiel's most excellent reductionist observations:

  The countercultural in the '60s was the hippies. You know, we
  landed on the moon in July of 1969. Woodstock started three 
  weeks later, and with the benefit of hindsight, that’s when
  progress ended, and the hippies took over the country. [1][2]
Perhaps, for too long, the left has engulfed and held hostage our cultural ideas of progress and advancement. And perhaps that has imbued us with a certain stripe of ideological stagnation not just in the way we perceive modernity but in also the debilitating influence on how we perceive actual technological progress itself and its relevance to the overall happiness of our society.

Perhaps our dominant leftist culture's 'ideological stagnation index' is the unmeasured metric that could explain why we feel the way we feel despite technological progress.

Thiel on the same topic:

  Today the counterculture is to believe in science and technology.
  You know, our society, the dominant culture doesn’t like science. 
  It doesn’t like technology. You just look at the science-fiction 
  movies that come out of Hollywood — Terminator, Matrix, Avatar, 
  Elysium. I watched the Gravity movie the other day. It’s like you
  would never want to go into outer space. You would just want to 
  be back on some muddy island. And so I think we’re in a world 
  where actually believing that a better future is possible that 
  you can have agency and work towards a better future, that is 
  actually radically countercultural.[1]
[1] Glenn Beck and Peter Thiel On How To Change What's Politically Cool

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IER50pX-FuM&t=3m22s

[2] Technology Stalled in 1970

http://www.technologyreview.com/qa/530901/technology-stalled...

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by blanderman on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:42AM (#17828166)
It's odd to me how the president from 1969 to 1977 and 1981 to 1993 was a republican, but the argument is that 'hippies' took over?
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by wozniacki on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:59PM (#17829326)
He's talking about the cultural left not the political one deployed to ensure voter turnout.

Perhaps this will add more context:

  Today’s aged hippies no longer understand that there
  is a difference between the election of a black 
  president and the creation of cheap solar energy; in 
  their minds, the movement towards greater civil rights
  parallels general progress everywhere. Because of these
  ideological conflations and commitments, the 1960s
  Progressive Left cannot ask whether things actually 
  might be getting worse. I wonder whether the endless
  fake cultural wars around identity politics are the 
  main reason we have been able to ignore the tech 
  slowdown for so long.[1]
[1] The End of the Future

https://www.nationalreview.com/2011/10/end-future-peter-thie...

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by blanderman on Thursday August 23, 2018 @03:05PM (#17829771)
I just see a lot of very bold assertions without statistical references to back them up.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by baxtr on Thursday August 23, 2018 @12:05PM (#17828378)
“That’s when progress ended”, really? That alone is enough to discredit Thiel on the topic
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by bachbach on Saturday August 25, 2018 @04:27PM (#17842428)
You're not reading Thiel's full argument, it takes a while to appreciate it, you won't get it from a couple of sound bites. I've read a slew of his essays and watched his talks - it takes a while to absorb how different this interpretation of reality is.

I believe Thiel is correct in what he is saying and that is terrifying. It is going to take Westerners a long time to finally wake up and when it finally does it'll be jarring and immensely depressing.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by baxtr on Saturday August 25, 2018 @05:14PM (#17842607)
Is there any way you could go into more detail on this or refer to some sources? In all honesty, your comment sounds vague and a bit esoteric, still interesting enough that I want to know if there some hidden truth to it. It can’t be that difficult
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by bachbach on Saturday August 25, 2018 @06:42PM (#17842977)
Peter Thiel is really a kind of philosopher - the venture capitalism is more of an outgrowth of something else than his primary focus. This is a person who reads widely, has big ideas and is consistently ahead of everybody else - his reputation is wholly deserved.

I've been following, causally at first, his ideas through books written about or by him, many hours of youtube videos and essays in and around the topics he talks about. It is difficult to distill this into a synopsis because although I can provide a TLDR it doesn't mean you'd get any predictive power of it.

I suggest doing your own homework and coming to your own conclusions. I think I'd give a lot for a photo of his bookshelves.

Here's a start.

https://www.nationalreview.com/2011/10/end-future-peter-thie...

A common theme in Thiel's thought is that 'reality is often very different from the mainstream conception of it'. Ron Unz wrote this essay which gives body to this belief.

http://www.unz.com/runz/our-american-pravda/

Another theme is that humankind is highly mimetic - meaning they have a desire to be copying each other. This comes out of the philosophy of René Girard and you'll have to read something of his to fully understand where we're going with this.

https://woodybelangia.com/what-is-mimetic-theory/

Watch this if you only watch one video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tw-rxtwhzcY

Peter Thiel is at the intersection of an unusually large number of obscure and strange topics, that's the reason why he's ahead of the curve over and over. Things like Seasteading, Urbit, if you ferret away at the peripheral you start to see interesting stuff, some of which gets ferried back to the mainstream sooner or later he's not the only talent scout for weird ideas like this but there's surprisingly few people out there in these strange circles - I've found that I keep running into the same people over and over, only a few hundred of them I'd guess. I'm tired now, it's near GMT midnight but good luck on your quest!

A lot of Tyler Cowen's ideas intersect with Thiel, that's another good line of enquiry.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by ridewinter on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:51AM (#17826787)
Those hippies brought us Apple computer and the Internet. What have conservatives contributed other than environmental destruction? Legit question.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by rjkennedy98 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:00AM (#17827789)
I'm very far to the left, but the military made almost all the major inventions that silicon valley has packaged up for consumer use. The iPhone is nothing but a collection of technologies designed for war. GPS, small cameras, the internet, ect were all designed by the military not by Silicon Valley.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by ridewinter on Thursday August 23, 2018 @01:19PM (#17828973)
The hackers contracting in the 60s for the government and military were hardly conservative.

Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/25/arts/25conn.html

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by bachbach on Saturday August 25, 2018 @04:29PM (#17842434)
The point though is that some people in SV think that a monoculture of liberals were/are behind everything and that is just not true. Technology is a full spectrum ideological bloodsport.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by ForHackernews on Thursday August 23, 2018 @05:48AM (#17825900)
I would absolutely consider that offer. I get cheap housing, healthcare, and education and as an added bonus I get rid of social media and my nagging smartphone?

(Btw, TV was in color by the 70s and literal gramophones were long gone)

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by austhrow743 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:03AM (#17825960)
Knowing things exist and not having them and them not existing in the first place are two very different things.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by Retric on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:39AM (#17826081)
Exactly, failing to keep up with the Jones has real impact on happiness. Absolute vs relative prosperity is like buying a top of the line new computer in 1995 or a used computer today built in 2010 that is vastly more powerful yet can’t run a lot of current software well.

One issue is we are constantly bombarded with things we don’t have. Basic cable has far more channels than existed in 1960 but the menu constantly shows every channel you don’t have while making menus harder to use.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by scarface74 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:10AM (#17826520)
Exactly, failing to keep up with the Jones has real impact on happiness. Absolute vs relative prosperity is like buying a to of the line new computer in 1995 or a used computer today built in 2010 that is vastly more powerful yet can’t run a lot of current software well.

A computer you bought in 2010 would be more than capable of running most modern non game software well.

https://www.computerhope.com/history/2010.htm

In fact, I was using a Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz Dell (circa 2009) running Windows 10 as my Plex Server until last week. It was only slow when trying to do something interactively while Plex was transcoding. It also ran PlexConnect to serve a Plex client to my 3rd gen AppleTV.

The 1st gen iPad was also released that year. I still have one (not my main iPad). I reset it last year. It can still be used for most of the streaming services - Netflix, Hulu, etc.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by barrow-rider on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:30AM (#17827557)
Bingo. I have a 2009 Thinkpad that's still kicking; both it refurb'd. Does everything just fine for day-to-day purposes, and runs Alpha Centauri in WINE/DosBox like a boss.

For a couple years it was a dedicated seedbox. It's mostly by BTC-trade-only box these days, but if my desktop died I could re-image it and use it for 95% of my life without issue.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by Retric on Thursday August 23, 2018 @08:45AM (#17826747)
I am mostly talking about games. Still, a good PC from 2010 holds up well, but low end PC’s from 2010 could have as little as 2GB of RAM which would have issues with a modern OS and a wide range of applications. Other issues where anemic SSD storage space, a HDD from 2010 holds up ok, but SSD’s tended to just barely work.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by chronial on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:13AM (#17825999)
It's like the difference between prosperity and happiness.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by bumholio on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:17AM (#17826011)
It's also like the difference between poverty and ignorance.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by close04 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @05:12AM (#17825737)
Pretty sure you couldn't convince a teenager to give up Snapstagram or Instabook or whatever is the next thing. Must be that these bring prosperity to their lives :).

I think we have to go to even more basic questions: what do people think about when they say prosperity? Having more money? But is it having more money than today's average or having more money than they used to have?

One thing's for sure, I wouldn't say more tech = more prosperity. By this definition alone almost every person is the world lives a more prosperous life by virtue of having a $20 burner phone that they didn't have in the '80s.

No, prosperity is "financial success" and that's related to the people around you and to some basic standard, a baseline of the times you're living in.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by taway_1212 on Thursday August 23, 2018 @05:33AM (#17825841)
> No, prosperity is "financial success" and that's related to the people around you and to some basic standard

If that's the case, then prosperity is purely relative term (as I suspect the "basic standard" will be redefined every decade or so) and hence can never improve. To me, what you're describing sounds more like inequality than prosperity.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by collyw on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:00AM (#17826179)
Really you would need people to live each of the lives and get them to judge afterwards rather than just ask what they would prefer when they only really have experience of teh current version.
Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by sixstringbudha on Thursday August 23, 2018 @06:56AM (#17826161)
> I offered 10 people the opportunity to live like people lived in the 1970's

Do I also get a dozen brothers and sisters? Eat food, drink water and breath air without having to constantly worry about being them polluted or toxic?

> would only have a black-and-white TV with 4 stations and a gramophone record player..

Sure. I would rather have a gramaphone record player or cassete player (which is more like 70s i think) that played ABBA or BoneyM than a 4k lcd tv that plays Lady gaga or Justine beiber or what ever crap that is "trending" today.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by maccard on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:22AM (#17826278)
> Eat food, drink water and breath air without having to constantly worry about being them polluted or toxic?

Sorry but you have a very rosy view of the 1970s. Would you drink this water [0]? Or fill your car with leaded Gas [1]? Use asbestos in your building [2]? DDT on your fresh food? [3] Air quality around the world is vastly superior to the 70s (people are still suffering because of it [4]).

> than a 4k lcd tv that plays Lady gaga or Justine beiber or what ever crap that is "trending" today.

It's your choice. Your 4k TV today can still play Abba or boney M, and many other bands you couldn't afford. A record cost $3 in 1970, which adjusted for inflation is about $19. For the same (adjusted) cost as an album a month in 1970 you can have access to basically every artist from the 70s (Spotify) along with most TV shows (nrtflix/) and still have enough change for a beer to go with it. Nobody is forcing you to leave your TV tuned into listen to Bieber. There was also a deluge of crap in the 1970s that you just weren't exposed to. There is also plenty of great music being produced now that can easily be found.

[0] https://www.flickr.com/photos/usnationalarchives/3769068219/... [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asbestosis [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/DDT [4] https://www.newscientist.com/article/2076728-people-today-ar...

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by sixstringbudha on Thursday August 23, 2018 @10:20PM (#17832291)
> Sorry but you have a very rosy view of the 1970s.

Who said pollution did not exist back in 1970. Just that it was more feasible to get stuff that you know that is not polluted. From local produce or farmed yourself.

> Air quality around the world is vastly superior to the 70s (people are still suffering because of it?

Oh yea? Can you provide some citations. By what factor have the number of automobiles multiplied?

> Your 4k TV today can still play Abba or boney M.

You are missing the point. The point is that the technology to consume art is irrelavant if the art produced is low quality in itself. I mean, where is M-tv today?

>There is also plenty of great music being produced now that can easily be found.

Oh yea? Again, where is M-Tv then? It's been ages since a new song have really captured my attention.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by maccard on Friday August 24, 2018 @09:09AM (#17834684)
> From local produce or farmed yourself.

There are plenty of ways to get locally farmed meat and vegetables. The fact that battery farmed chickens and industrially grown tomatoes are now easily accessible all year around in your local Walmart/Asda doesn't change the fact that I can go to my greengrocer and get fresh fruit and veg from 30 miles away.

> Can you provide some citations.

Yes, I did for everything I said in the previous post at the bottom. I even numbered them.

>art is irrelavant if the art produced is low quality...

> where is M-tv today

You don't have to judge by the lowest common denominator.

Just because the most popular music right now doesn't capture your imagination doesn't mean that 1) all popular music is bad, or 2) the older forms which you enjoy have been taken from you.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by sixstringbudha on Friday August 24, 2018 @01:03PM (#17836179)
> I can go to my greengrocer and get fresh fruit and veg from 30 miles away.

And you think that is free of toxins?

>Yes, I did for everything I said in the previous post at the bottom. I even numbered them.

No. You said air pollution around the world is vastly superior now. The link you provided said "People are dying from pollution sustain during the 70s". If you don't see the difference, then I wish you a good day and let us drop this conversation.

Re:Why Prosperity Has Increased but Happiness Has Not by wavefunction on Thursday August 23, 2018 @07:21AM (#17826268)
The 70s had a fair amount of pollution and crime above what we experience now. I'm guessing the OP didn't graduate with decades of student loans though. Or a five year loan for that car of theirs.