News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by Roritharr on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @04:30AM (#17817225)
I always love to imagine the havoc it would wreak if Sysadmins went on strike...
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by dagw on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:16AM (#17818120)
Unless the sysadmins had a big powerful union (or sabotaged the system on their way out the door) their tasks would just be handed off to other computer literate people in the company who would end up becoming de facto sysadmins.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by 8_hours_ago on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @01:24PM (#17820277)
"I'm sorry, the IT department can't install mysql on your workstation because only sysadmin union members have root access to your workstation and they all left at 5pm. This doesn't qualify as a level 1 emergency so we can't page the on-call sysadmin. You can open a ticket and they will prioritize it tomorrow"
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by lithos on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @08:35AM (#17818217)
I'd love to imagine them taking online help articles down for the duration of the strike. Blogs/whatever overflow/forum posts/similar.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by colonelpopcorn on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:24AM (#17818496)
I thought about Stack Overflow going down for a minute, and I got really scared.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by antisthenes on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @12:51PM (#17820041)
That's sort of crossing the line between refusing to work and doing deliberate sabotage.

Especially if the help articles are on an internal network.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by eru on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:57AM (#17818690)
That would take a world-wide strike and no strike breakers. Unlikely.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by kazagistar on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:56AM (#17819114)
Doesn't need to be worldwide. A single tech company having everyone strike would be enough.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by eru on Sunday August 26, 2018 @03:23AM (#17844734)
They could still hire strikebreakers world wide, or not?
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by beauzero on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:03AM (#17818384)
I used to think that until I worked at a couple different places as developer/sysadmin which was due to not being"core product". There were several systems that would have ceased functioning within a week and we're never allocated requested funds because "that's what we have you for."
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by dagw on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:08AM (#17818411)
My point is that there are lots of ex-sysadmins (like me), programmers and DBAs out there that have the base knowledge necessary to relatively quickly retrain as sysadmins if that was to become necessary.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by merpnderp on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:47AM (#17819049)
That's why sysadmins don't need a union. You'd have to pay programmers and DBAs a premium to get them to do sysadmin work. There's literally no one to replace sysadmins except sysadmins and more expensive less well trained (in sysadmin work) employees.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by dagw on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @02:28PM (#17820771)
That's why sysadmins don't need a union.

I'm confused. All your arguments seem to be for why sysadmins _do_ need a union. If they're irreplaceable (at the current wage level) and underpaid like you seem to claim then it sounds like they're leaving money on the table by not bargaining collectively.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by tomjen3 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:11AM (#17819212)
Sure. The question would be how well would they be able to run the systems? My guess is mostly not at all.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by Ntrails on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:53AM (#17817546)
Much like the bankers, the world would largely just keep running.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by citation_please on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:10AM (#17817613)
I think we're merely highlighting the distinction between what level of responsivity a job actually requires. Those who deal with things that require near-immediate attention (janitors, sys admins, doctors) would stop the world. Everyone else the world can (by definition of responsibility) continue without any issue for awhile, and maybe at worst stagnate.

I think this might be a completely orthogonal concept to measuring how "bull shit" a job is, despite how often it gets brought up in this context.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by perfunctory on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:00AM (#17817773)
The article actually touches on this point. It doesn't claim that we don't need financial system. On the contrary. In fact, while bankers were striking people recreated their own financial system of some sort. Only it turned out you could do it more cheaply without mega bonuses.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by deathhand on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @07:22AM (#17817873)
Bankers is a very broad term. "High financiers" are bankers and so are people who work at a bank who do not get 'mega bonuses'. The article was talking about the latter.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by foxhop on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @10:22AM (#17818852)
I would like to add farmers, plumbers, utilities workers, and anyone who keeps ISP networks online, to your list.

There are very few doing the essential jobs.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by citation_please on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @12:18PM (#17819800)
I agree with your list! Except with your use of the word essential, because I was trying to draw attention to the fact that these jobs are highly reactive, which I think is orthogonal to how essential they are to society (i.e. not "bull shit").

As a counter-example, I think everyone who is currently working to reduce environmentally-damaging emissions of industrial processes are essential to society, but if they all disappeared tomorrow it would have little immediate impact.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by code_duck on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:41AM (#17817708)
For a time. I think the situation would be similar to an auto mechanic strike - everything keeps working until it stops working, at which point society would start to experience considerable hardship.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by rini17 on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:25AM (#17817659)
Banking and few other things can be replaced by whiteboard, but not everything ( https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-sussex-45247499 )
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by maze-le on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @06:52AM (#17817751)
Right up until someone in your company decides it is a good idea to introduce this new piece of infrastructure...
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by protonfish on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:14AM (#17818436)
Yes, because I have to have a sysadmin to run all my computers at home...

Sysadmins in an org are there to stop you from doing things, not help you.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by jcadam on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:55AM (#17819592)
Yes, every company I've worked in, there's been an adversarial relationship between IT and the regular users. Software Engineers are especially hated by sysadmins.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by no_one_ever on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @09:22AM (#17818484)
Only if your computer is a black box isolated from the rest of the world...
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by snackbugs on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:47AM (#17819523)
The sysadmin field has always seemed more conservative in my experience. When I hang out with them or spend time in online spaces where they talk, water cooler discussions wander into things that seem informed by right-leaning perspectives. I feel like many sysadmins would proudly and happily scab or cross picket lines.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by kamaal on Thursday August 23, 2018 @03:12AM (#17825207)
It will mostly be developers taking over their jobs and sysadmins being replaceable getting more pronounced.

In fact in most companies this is always the case. They routinely lay off sysadmins, qa and other support personnel and ask developers to take over.

I'm now seeing trends of tech leads sort of roles doing the same jobs as a managers.

If your job involves some prime mover to which you are just a helper/enabler, its likely you can be easily eliminated.

Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by needlepont on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @11:02AM (#17819164)
Not so much these days with the devops reaction. Now you need to package your work and a good remote worker can figure out what is needed in a few minutes. Not a bad thing for either party TBH. Sysadmins can chase butterflies when they burn out and 3rd worlders get a remote gig to pay for food.
Re:Bullshit jobs and the yoke of managerial feudalism by hw_penfold on Wednesday August 22, 2018 @05:55AM (#17817558)
The result would be mixed and scattered.

Basically, we see exactly how it unfolds when a ransomware epidemic breaks out. Ransomware, in many ways tying people hands, such that an outage occurs.

In many areas, servers would chug along undisturbed. In other areas some of them would halt, either requiring input from some attended task, or because of a fault of some kind.

Two other considerations would remain variable, per specific scenario: remote sabotage in the form of zero days appearing in coordination with strike activities, or local on-prem sabotage, in the form of erased disk drives, unplugged cables, or physical damage however subtle.

The remote sabotage could involve a nation-state advanced persistent threat swooping in, or sympathy attacks from external groups which may or may not include those striking, to exacerbate the circumstances. Meanwhile on-prem monkey wrenching would have to occur immediately prior to a walk-out/lock-out.

So, pretty much the same disposition as any other strike, but with the added quirk of remote access, except any or all of the servers could theoretically run problem-free for the duration of the strike, and predicting which systems go down and when would almost always require insider knowlege to accurately estimate.

Meanwhile, everywhere this happens, people in need of a database would just do stuff in Excel, and snailmail USB sticks everwhere. Once that starts happening, it’s anybody’s game.