The shack-dwellers have no land or strata title or security, often reduced access to utilities and services (or none at all), and thereby live in a state of relative fear and insecurity.
Often owing to this situation they also periodically lose what little they have to thug-teams called in to clear illegal dwellings, and even if they can hold on tend to lack access to education for their children who grow up with stigma and reduced opportunities which results in a cycle of poverty.
Simplistically, you can look at slum-dwellers as landless peasants.
Price per square m/ft is much lower in the slum than in the gated community.
If you couldn't aford a place in the gated community, would you use that money to buy a place in the slum? Or would you try elsewhere?
The problem in general is not absolute lack of space for building (except islands like Japan, ...), but lack of place to build in desirable locations.
Sure, you can get a 2500 sq ft house on a quarter acre lot for $500k, if you’re also willing to drive for 2 or more hours a day to go to/from work. If you want a 15 minute or less commute, prepare to spend 3 times more for the same sized house on a smaller plot of land.
What’s crazy to me is when you have communities like Medina, WA or Atherton, CA where this extremely conveniently located land is all single family houses. When inequality is low you have people living close to employers for convenience and living far to get more house per $ - now inequality, especially in certain regions, is making it so that the rich people are able to get the best of both worlds
To me the high premium on convenience these days indicates that these regions are in need of a public transportation upgrade, but that’s another story.
https://www.wsj.com/articles/mumbais-slums-make-way-for-luxu...
Then when they finally reach the point where they can afford to buy, they'll apply for huge mortgages to buy in the slum they effectively converted into a desirable place. Profit.
This is what seemed to play out in The Mission district of SF over the past decade or so.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/02/technology/google-maps-ne...
But a few things to consider:
One is that shacks tend not to be built by the owners on their own land. i.e., they're not paying for the land, therefore the value of the land plays does not prohibit them from building a shack there. Instead, they're occupying the space illegally. A shack only costs a little in bricks (these lowgrade ones are probably about 10 cents a piece) and some metal roofing.
Second is that shacks in some countries are built in high-demand locations as a political and economic instrument by poor people. In Morocco for example, those who live in slums often get bought about for about 25k per family by a public-private investment project aimed at building luxury apartments. They then take this money to build/buy-into a low-quality apartment building in the city's poor periphery. They're often staying illegally and refusing low-ball offers. If you kick them out by force, you have a moral and socio-political problems and the problem only relocates (waterbed effect). Further, local politicians will often cater to these people for their votes, when the majority of the country is below middle-class, that's who you pander to. In essence, these slums and the related buyout acts like a sort of earmarked social-housing tax on luxury housing projects.
Sometimes the slums are actually owned by those who live there (unlikely, usually it's based on forged documents). But even then, no developer will buy a small plot in the middle of a slum for luxury apartments. You need to be able to buy-out families consisting of hundreds of people before you have a large enough plot of land to develop in. That isn't easy and people know they can fetch a high-price. They also know they have to, finding another place to live isn't cheap.
And lastly, there actually are tons of shacks being sold every day, replaced by apartments due to the value dynamics you described. It just doesn't happen overnight to the entire stock.
In places where upscale market demand isn't overwhelmingly high, this keeps land prices low enough that residents of nearby low-class housing aren't priced out, or the landowner (who may or may not be the resident of the dwellings above) doesn't feel sufficient pressure to sell.
The article starts out talking about the airport being surrounded by shacks. Airports cause tremendous air pollution and noise pollution.
The shacks are likely concentrated in areas that wealthier people generally wouldn't want to live as those areas tend to take a toll on health no matter how nice the building.
There is plenty of evidence that poor people generally live in places with serious environmental issues which negatively impact their health. This just compounds their poverty by adding medical expenses and reducing productivity.
I think we need to rewrite budding codes to say, in essence, that you can live in a small space, but it needs to be one that doesn't harm your health. This would eliminate one of the mist profound differences between rich and poor, a difference that helps keep poverty entrenched.
The land that the shacks are built on is much cheaper because the surrounding land is covered in shacks.
Source: an acquaintance is going through something functionally similar in Turkey, though the material conditions are much different (its a modern apartment, not shacks, and it’s because of a mis-issued land grant, not just building on gov’t land like these shacks I assume are)
Further by this measure, it appears that there are many, many more apartment dwellers than shack dwellers. Because shacks are one story tall after all, so the population density per acre is relatively low.
What am I missing?