How did the bank lien from the mortgage get handled in the sale?
Pretty funny you mentioned the interest. In the 11 years it's been like $50.00, since I keep it in just a regular account (instead of CDs or whatever).
Which country was this in? Banks don't typically hand people hundreds of thousands of dollars without making sure that they'll get their pound of flesh when things go south. Not having any kind of collateral is a pretty big mistake on the bank's side.
The debt could also be subject to a state of limitations, and you could potentially be clear. If its been 11 years, I would ask a lawyer about it. You may be able to safely use the money you've left set aside.
I'll be 100% honest here, and I don't know the finest of the details. I worked through a local realtor I've used for everything I've ever done, a local financial advisor, and my lawyer. User user5994461 is expressing the same fear I had in that I was afraid of doing something illegal. I've always kept a chunk of cash on hand equal to what I would owe just in case someone came after me.
At some point the service provider got confusing. I actually paid two different providers in one month in a panic about missing a payment. You cannot believe the paperwork I got. One of them was like "Uh, we don't know what to do with this," and the other took the money, but then that's when the issue of who owned the loan came up.
So as we were starting to sort out actually who to pay, and who actually was getting the money, that's when I stopped paying. At the time it didn't seem so much like stopping payment but instead of just not paying until we sorted it out.
The actual sale of the house was to a Korean family who wanted to house for their children who were going to go to college in our town. The realtor handled the sale, the lawyer checked everything out, and the only loose end was I accidentally left the gas in my name and bought the students a years worth of gas ($1000).
I do know that after they sale we were still trying to resolve what I owed and to who on the original mortgage. I guess technically that is still going on.
My subject take away from this was, "this is an avalanche of paperwork." We wanted to sell the house. Under the circumstance, we did whatever it took to sell it even if we didn't know who I owed the money to.
Also, up until this event, I didn't have a lawyer, or a realtor, or a financial advisor. When there is six figures, it's a big boys game, and you pay to play.
Edit for typo.
It seems like one of the mortgage owners probably removed the lien when they sold the mortgage and the buyer never put their own lien on.
I don't know the machinations involved with mortgages, but it seems to me like I'd like that to have been the case.
Source: I was IT support (among other hats I wore) for the band debt team at a hedge fund for 7 years at a previous job. We held about $20B in notional debt running up to the 2008 crash. Was not a fun time to be in the industry.
It was hell on earth trying to sort it out, and the sale almost fell through because of it. The real kicker was that our lawyer basically told me he wished I hadn't noticed it because the sale would have just gone through and nobody would have cared... but since I did, we were legally obligated to fix it.
Perhaps this is why 'nobody noticed'?
An ethical breach by a title insurance company likely violates its bylaws, and at the very least opens them up to liability.
It seems like this is a title error so the insurance company would be responsible. I don't see why a lawyer wouldn't report the error to the insurance company. It's billable time that the insurance company would need to pay for and they'd be working to keep their industry with clear deeds instead of faulty ones.
Also, as in any client relationship, a lawyer’s first priority is the person paying his bills, not necessarily the industry. Even if it would be better in the long run and more ethical, when someone pays you there is a natural obligation attached to the relationship.
I used to be idealistic, but experience has shown me that people do what is expedient.
I actually called the title insurance company at one point to ask what the heck something was, and was connected to an experienced person who was very happy to fully explain what they'd found.
My guess is that because the history of our house was pretty complicated, the title searcher was relieved to have something out of the ordinary to work on.
The upshot? That title search is really important, particularly if you're buying a property that predates electronic property systems.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mortgage-backed_security
A lot of mortgages changed hands several times, the original bank who setup the mortgage would have no longer been involved at that point.
That doesn't explain how OP was able to get the lien on the land title removed when they sold the house.
Unless they don't notify you on purpose to continue to receive the monthly payment, while cashing out on the resale, in which case that's fraud.
I can also imagine that the next buyer would try to pull the same trick. That obviously causes a problem. It seems to be what happened in the US, in which case everyone should check their mortgage to make sure who owns it.
Until midway through the Obama administration, nobody had any obligation to notify you if your mortgage was bought or sold. Payment servicers had no obligation to tell you who they were forwarding your checks to. Your mortgage could be bought and sold multiple times, but as long as the same servicer was used, you'd never know (there were/are only a few big servicers). If the mortgage buyer used a different servicer, you'd get a letter from your current servicer about the new servicer you should send your checks to, but no info about who now owned your mortgage.
The servicers existed to serve as a smoke screen for mortgage securitization shenanigans. The servicers sent the payments to trusts that had dubious possession of the mortgages.
Trusts and banks passed ownership of mortgages amongst themselves, though tax law was supposed to prevent them from doing so. Ultimately the servicers had no more idea of who actually owned the mortgages than the homeowners.
If there are court proceedings attached to the sale of the house, the corrections might be done there.
I owned a house along with someone else, an okay house, bought it for $115,000, held onto it for 5 years, until it appreciated to $350,000 in those hurly-burly days.
At some point, and I forgot why it came up, we needed to figure out who owned the loan. And we never did. It the morass of paper work and nearly fraudulent claims by various people who claimed to own the loan, we stopped paying on the loan. We literally had more than one company claim to own it at one point. What was weird is it was kind of a slow burn, even after we stopped paying. No one really seemed to care as much as you'd think $900 a month would make you care.
In the end, we sold the house, never paid off the remaining debt, and split the cash. I told my lawyer I'd hold onto savings to cover the debt if they ever came back and could legally claim it.. It's been 11 years. Nothing yet.