News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by zoomzoom on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:26AM (#1778809)
This piece is amazing. It masquerades as a critique of science, but at bottom I would argue it is really just a very complicated smokescreen for Obama-hating and anti-Keynesianism. I bet this guy Thiel just wants lower taxes.

Thiel admits that we could print money without fear if our future looked brighter. And the 20th century saw such amazing progress that we did just that successfully. But he says that things are different now. We cannot print money because growth will not support it unless we get sentient robots and nanotech red blood cells, FAST! We better support the Republicans because at least they talk tough and hate Keynes, but it doesn't matter who we support because shit will hit the fan anyway.

But really, how much has technology failed us? Of course we must agree that the Jetson's world is not yet manifest. But the hardest problems that humanity faces are not technological. If anything, the 20th century's lesson was not that we need to get deeper into tech faster, it is that we need to approach the problems in a different way. We built airplanes as soon as we could, and Hitler turned them into blitzkreig. Einstein and Bohr pushed the limits of physics and we built A-bombs. Tesla gave us AC and Radio; and we built coal power plants to power Air Conditioned McDonalds advertised on TV via mass media.

The reason we don't have undersea cities is not because we cannot build them. I believe that we have the technology. But if 100 rich people could live forever in an undersea bubble powered by green nanotech, would it really change the global situation? The real technological problem is bringing the billions of people who eke out a stone-age existence in tribal towns all over Asia and Africa into the modern world. And we are making progress every day at an accelerating rate. Tell Google that AI is a pipe dream. Urbanization, digitalization, communication; these are the things that are accelerating like electrons and oil were 100 years ago. Don't give up on Keynes just yet, HN. Of course it will not be easy for our species to survive another 100 years. But let's not give up on ourselves either.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by apsec112 on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:50AM (#1778849)
"This piece is amazing. It masquerades as a critique of science, but at bottom I would argue it is really just a very complicated smokescreen for Obama-hating and anti-Keynesianism. I bet this guy Thiel just wants lower taxes."

I personally discussed this topic with Peter in that same cafe several weeks ago, and I find that hard to believe. He didn't seem interested in discussing near-term politics at all, or near-term stuff in general. What's your evidence?

"We built airplanes as soon as we could, and Hitler turned them into blitzkreig."

If the airplane had been built fifty years later, is there some reason that it would not have been used to wage war more efficiently?

"But if 100 rich people could live forever in an undersea bubble powered by green nanotech, would it really change the global situation?"

Yes, because the technology that would need to be developed for that to happen would benefit everyone else.

"The real technological problem is bringing the billions of people who eke out a stone-age existence in tribal towns all over Asia and Africa into the modern world."

That's not a technological problem, it's a political problem. The example of China shows that a well-run country is perfectly capable of starting out from ancient-world level and catching up to the industrialized West within fifty years or so; there are no big technological barriers, just political ones.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by zoomzoom on Monday October 11, 2010 @09:34AM (#1779637)
I bet that Peter pretends not to care about taxes. But that is really besides the point. All I am trying to say is that tech is hardly failing us in the drastic way Peter supposes it is.

My point is not to delay the invention of airplanes, but to focus on the political problems first. Technology and politics are connected - that is Keynesianism is all about and that is what Peter, and you (it seems), fail to understand. The problem with medicare and social security, for example, is not "too few robots" but actually probably too many MRIs and prescription drugs. Not that we shouldn't have MRIs.

The political barriers are the hardest ones to jump over, because acts of individual genius are rarely meaningful in a political context. And try mass-producing smartphones (or solar panels) in a world where China and India are regressing towards chaos.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by blazamos on Sunday October 10, 2010 @09:46PM (#1778494)
Free access to the full version through Google News:

http://news.google.com/news/search?q=%22Technology+%3D+Salva...

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by ronnier on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:25AM (#1778806)
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by daveambrose on Sunday October 10, 2010 @11:59PM (#1778765)
Doesn't seem to work on my end when I go through the Google News link.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by hristov on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:21AM (#1778895)
Sigh, he almost has the answer, but he is too limited by his set political believes to actually see it.

Lack of technology is not the problem, the problem is lack of demand, and there is lack of demand because most people are poor. That's pretty much it. Once there is demand the technology will catch up pretty quickly.

For example, when after WWII middle class americans ended up with money (either from their pay as soldiers, or due to the higher salaries during the war time labor shortages), the US economy and technology grew very quickly to acomodate every single desire they might have, cars, houses, highways, boats, every consumer product you may think of, etc. were built in enormous quantities.

But now the middle class is relatively poor and at their best hope is to stay at the same level. So their spending decreases or stays the same. And the economy suffers.

Why aren't there household robots? Because people are too poor. The middle class american is too poor to afford a complex piece of robotics, and also there is a bunch of even poorer people that will do your housework for cheap. So why would anybody invest in a complex expensive Jetson's like household robot?

Take Hacker News for example, full of innovative people but most of them are working hard trying to figure out how to make money from a free product. Why? Because the average American does not have much money to spend.

So IMO, Thiel is in denial when he blames lack of technological know-how and advances for the economic woes.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by callmeed on Monday October 11, 2010 @02:34AM (#1778984)
First of all, there are robots that will vacuum/scrub your floors, clean your pool, and clear you gutter (http://store.irobot.com).

It's the not the Jetsons, but when I think about how complex other household chores can be (from an AI perspective), Thiel's theory makes more sense than yours. Are there even commercial/industrial robots advanced enough to collect, sort, wash, dry, fold and put away my family's laundry?

You say the middle class is relatively poor–relative to what?

I didn't know there was huge demand for self-driving cars–and it's cheaper to ride the bus–but Google is working on the technology.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by yummyfajitas on Monday October 11, 2010 @09:16AM (#1779579)
...the US economy and technology grew very quickly to acomodate every single desire they might have, cars, houses, highways, boats, every consumer product you may think of, etc. were built in enormous quantities. But now the middle class is relatively poor and at their best hope is to stay at the same level.

Please name a single consumer good or service which the Americans had more of after WWII than they do now.

Products made obsolete by new technology don't count.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by shin_lao on Monday October 11, 2010 @04:59AM (#1779202)
>But now the middle class is relatively poor

Relatively poor? Relative to what? To their parents who lived a golden age?

There are so many reasons why our countries aren't doing as great as they can and the wealth of middle classes isn't a cause but a consequence.

As an entrepreneur I observe that companies that innovate a lot do much better than those who don't.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by TedBlosser on Sunday October 10, 2010 @11:12PM (#1778660)
"The great exception is information technology, whose rapid advance is no fluke: "So far computers and the Internet have been the one sector immune from excessive regulation."

-so true, and let's hope we can keep it that way.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by stretchwithme on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:16AM (#1778792)
Can you imagine if government had tried to pick winning information technologies the way its now trying to do with electric cars?

Yep, its all over transportation. And you can see from the daily block long backup in front of Apple's global headquarters of cars waiting to get on the clogged highway 280 that innovative entrepreneurs aren't allowed to fix it.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by orangecat on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:59AM (#1778870)
Can you imagine if government had tried to pick winning information technologies the way its now trying to do with electric cars?

For a real-world example see South Korea, where until just a few months ago government regulations mandated the use of IE for all commerce: http://www.electronista.com/articles/10/07/01/korea.no.longe...

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by stretchwithme on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:55AM (#1778940)
wow, that's whacked. And that was in place for over 10 years.

And the reason was so you could have ActiveX verifying your identity. Yeah, bet ya Microsoft worked real hard getting the latest and greatest browser out for that market.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by _delirium on Sunday October 10, 2010 @11:46PM (#1778725)
That's a pretty speculative causal conclusion, if a causal conclusion is what "no fluke" is getting at. The rapid advance of computers and the internet because it's the big recent technology. Many ages have their new technologies that undergo rapid advances, and computing is this age's. You could've predicted in the 1950s, and many people did, that computing would be the big technology of the 20th century, long before you had any idea how its regulation would play out.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by hop on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:20AM (#1778797)
Thiel also invested in a seasteading initiative to build sovereign offshore floating colonies. Maybe its his technological answer to the housing bubble, as well as a libertarian Shangri-La.

http://reason.com/archives/2008/04/28/homesteading-on-the-hi... http://www.wired.com/science/planetearth/news/2008/05/seaste...

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by moultano on Monday October 11, 2010 @03:07AM (#1779028)
>"libertarians seem incapable of winning elections. . . . There are a lot of people you can't sell libertarian politics to."

As soon as I see a Libertarian candidate on the ballot who believes in climate change, they'll have my vote in a heartbeat.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by narrator on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:36AM (#1778918)
I think technological progress has slowed down dramatically. in 60 years we went from the first plane to landing on the moon. We haven't been back to the moon since. The invention of electricity, atomic theory, radio, the internal combustion engine were all far more world changing inventions than anything we've developed over the last 60 years, including the Internet. For instance, we are desperately trying to keep Iran from getting hold of 60 year old technology (uranium refining)!

I love studying the period in history between the franco-prussian war and World War II (1871-1940). The speed at which technology snuck up on the world and completely changed it was astonishing.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by Jeema3000 on Monday October 11, 2010 @09:21AM (#1779592)
I tend to actually think that the period during and immediately after World War 2 saw an even greater increase in terms of technology. Think about this, for example:

In 1940, the US army air force's best fighter plane was probably the P-40: a piston-driven, straight-wing, propeller-driven aircraft that had a top speed of 360mph.

A mere 20 years later they were using the F-106 Delta Dart, a jet-powered, delta wing aircraft that had a top speed of 1,525mph (Mach 2.3)...

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by dlnovell on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:09PM (#1780120)
I'm not sure how you don't qualify the internet as being as world-changing as the rest of the inventions you've listed. Perhaps that being a part of the revolution it's caused has blinded you to it's dramatic influence on the direction of human progress?
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by tocomment on Sunday October 10, 2010 @10:33PM (#1778578)
When is his book coming out? This idea of technological stagnation really rings true to me.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by amatriain on Monday October 11, 2010 @04:34AM (#1779169)
"The West, he says, needs to do "new things." Innovation, he says, comes from a "frontier" culture, a culture of "exceptionalism," where "people expect to do exceptional things"—in our world, still an almost uniquely American characteristic, and one we're losing."

Ok, the article lost me there. I really can't connect with that way of thinking.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by donaldc on Monday October 11, 2010 @02:26AM (#1778975)
Except for computers and the Internet, the idea that we're experiencing rapid technological progress is a myth.

First, even if this were true, that's a gigantic except. By comparison, one would probably not talk about the mid-1400's being a time of little progress, except for the development of the printing press.

Second, the U.S. GDP has been roughly doubling every 20 years since at least 1890 (source: http://norvig.com/speech.html), and I doubt such a longstanding trajectory is going to change anytime soon, Thiel's pessimism notwithstanding.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by mr_twj on Monday October 11, 2010 @03:24AM (#1779055)
Theoretically speaking, in a future where the world runs itself and all notions of "scarcity" are eliminated by energy, technological, and agricultural abundance, what need would there be for capitalism, let alone money?
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by bad_user on Monday October 11, 2010 @10:03AM (#1779721)
There wouldn't be, that's why technological progress is always hampered by politics.

And if the economical system would be a pure capitalism, we'd get there anyway, but unfortunately people feel the need for government regulation, which produces more scarcity and monopolies, ultimately hurting innovation (e.g. DMCA, DRM, patents, or my recent favorite, Net neutrality).

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by skybrian on Sunday October 10, 2010 @10:44PM (#1778596)
It's a pretty bizarre claim. How can anyone credibly claim that the housing bubble had anything to do with science? But I can see why the Wall Street Journal editors like this guy.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by kiba on Sunday October 10, 2010 @11:06PM (#1778650)
You're misreading.

You see, people are betting that technological progress will take of everything. You can keep inflating and there will still be price deflation. Unfortunately, that's a rather naive notion.

Technological progress are not guaranteed. You have to work at it to ensure that technological progress outpace the bad behaviors of politicians.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by orangecat on Monday October 11, 2010 @12:55AM (#1778864)
Right. Moore's Law vs Medicare: http://www.ideasinactiontv.com/tcs_daily/2003/07/the-great-r...

It's clear that neither party in the US has the slightest interest in fiscal responsibility, not as long as it's a winning strategy to buy votes with tax cuts and free benefits. The only way I see to avoid the coming demographic and financial time bomb is massive economic growth, e.g. one or more of AI/robotics (replace most human labor), nanotech (make material goods much cheaper), and biotech (cure aging, radically reducing medical expenses and increasing productivity).

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by izendejas on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:54AM (#1778938)
Bad behavior by politicians... who are practically at the mercy of special interests. AND bad behavior by many individuals who are always looking to cut corners* or are too irrational they end up forcing leaders to overstep their oversight boundaries.

*excuse the cliche', trying to be concise.

Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by tocomment on Sunday October 10, 2010 @09:43PM (#1778485)
Is there a full version for free? It looks like an interesting read.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by jdale27 on Monday October 11, 2010 @01:02AM (#1778873)
Usually you can access full WSJ articles through Google News.
Re:Technology = Salvation: An Interview with Peter Thiel by mwytock on Monday October 11, 2010 @02:22AM (#1778969)
also through search, top result for [thiel wsj]