News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by fipple on Thursday August 16, 2018 @09:49PM (#17779751)
These valuations are driven by huge liquidation preferences which will totally wipe out common stockholders in any down round or distressed sale.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by stanleytang on Thursday August 16, 2018 @11:52PM (#17780175)
Nope. We raised on clean terms, 1x liquidation preference, no ratchets. Has been true for every single round —- we have and will never take dirty terms, even if it means a lower valuation
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by fipple on Friday August 17, 2018 @03:57AM (#17781055)
Huh, cool to know. Congratulations and sorry for assuming.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday August 17, 2018 @09:10AM (#17782520)
Just a hint for next time, if that's the case then perhaps you should start your comment with "I assume..." instead of stating it as fact.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by askafriend on Thursday August 16, 2018 @11:09PM (#17780022)
They have a 1x liquidation preference from what I was told when I was given an offer somewhat recently.

So 1x is standard, and nothing crazy like what you're implying.

Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by davidmr on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:00AM (#17780198)
Given that Stanley just said precisely the opposite, I'm wondering why you made this comment. I'm not being a jerk, but I wonder why you spoke so authoritatively. Do you think that he's lying, or were you just speaking in generalities?
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by colinhmit on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:14AM (#17780238)
Its a decent assumption at this stage in the VC cycle, especially when an established player (doordash v postmates) has a surprising multiple - Uber is a great example: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2017-11-16/softbank-...
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by tptacek on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:08PM (#17779824)
Wait, explain the connection between liquidation preferences and valuation?

Or is the argument that these companies get very high nominal valuations but the terms on the rounds they raise include punitive preferences?

Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by charleslmunger on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:05AM (#17780221)
Investors are willing to pay higher prices for less equity for two reasons:

1. Normal investment of $Y at valuation X implies that you, the investor, think that the company is worth more than X. If it exits for more, you'll get more, less you'll get less. But investing $Y at valuation X with a 2x liquidation preference means that you think the company is worth merely Y. The valuation basically doesn't matter any more. If I invest $10 at a $100 valuation and the company exits at a $500 valuation, I get a $40 profit. If it exits at a $50 valuation, I've lost $5. The valuation I invest at makes a big difference for my profitability. But consider the same scenario with a 2x liquidation preference - in the happy case, I get the same profit. In the sad case, I've still doubled my money.

2. Investors in startups are not perfectly rational investors. If I own an existing stake in a company, I would fight tooth and nail to prevent any new money coming in from having a liquidation preference over me. But in truth, if the company can raise money at a $2 billion valuation normally, or a $4 billion valuation with a preference, a fund can report double the gains to the people who actually put money in it. So they stay quiet, show off the impressive paper returns of their current investment fund, and go on raising the next one. This effect is doubly pernicious when the later investors are also earlier investors - they can basically juice their own balance sheet. On paper, the existing stake is worth more because of the inflated valuation, and the new stake is a heads-I-win-tails-you-lose.

And at the lowest preference are all the employees. Founders take money off the table in the inflated new rounds, so while they technically have a lower preference they've still cashed out significantly.

Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by WisNorCan on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:12PM (#17779830)
Liquidation multiples and preference gives the investor protection when things go bad (and also a kicker when it goes well). Let’s say you put in $100M and have a 2x liquidation multiple at a $4B valuation.

Even if the company falls apart and sells for $100M you still get your money back. If it declines to $200M you get all of that before anyone else.

In reality terms vary substantially. In this case, Doordash had just raised and didn’t need to raise again. Depending on how desperate investors were to get in, they might have gotten clean terms.

Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by tptacek on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:14PM (#17779840)
No, I get what a preference is; I'm wondering what the connection between them and valuation is.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by vecter on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:20PM (#17779871)
I think he's saying that the valuation would be lower if the liquidation preference were lower. This makes sense since a higher liquidation preference reduces the risk of the investment, thus allowing you to grant a higher valuation.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by mbesto on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:41PM (#17779949)
Exactly. This basically makes later stage investments risk-free (nothing is risk free, but you get my point) while pushing all of the risk to the founders and employees.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by aslkdjaslkdj1 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @11:34PM (#17780113)
The press derived a valuation using valuation = price paid X 100/percent equity

Those liquidation preferences mean that investors will pay more for their equity % than they would have without them which inflates the valuation estimates used by the above formula. The basic idea is that not all % equity is the worth the same amount, but it is assumed to when a valuation number is reported.

Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by dasil003 on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:18AM (#17780251)
You're being unusually oblique. It's conventional wisdom that liquidation preference multiples are tied to higher valuation, but you already knew that. Do you disagree with this or have some more interesting theory regarding liquidation preference?
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by bkohlmann on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:22PM (#17779879)
Founders may trade a higher valuations for investor preferences. A Stanford professor of mine who studies VC noted that preferences a few years ago were most prevalent when just pushing startups into unicorn terriory.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by naveen99 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:41PM (#17779946)
Is there a similar interplay between valuation and friendliness to secondary markets for employee shares.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by williamscales on Thursday August 16, 2018 @11:11PM (#17780033)
I expect you would see that the value of shares where the stock purchase agreement says the company has the right to block the sale would be lower
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by ghazak on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:23AM (#17780272)
My assumption is that you sell a given stock with 1x liquidation preference, and the price of that stock is used to determine the valuation for the company, pretending the price is the same for the common stock as the stock with 1x liquidation?
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by WisNorCan on Thursday August 16, 2018 @10:17PM (#17779854)
Higher multiples and preference means that you have less downside and higher upside in the investment -> higher valuation.
Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by rahimnathwani on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:05AM (#17780220)
Yes, that's the usual case (but not in this case apparently).

If a company has 5 classes of shares (common, A, B, C, D), then it's reasonable to value the company's equity by estimating the value of 1 share of each class, multiplying by the number of shares issued, and summing up these products.

The more common method used by PR folks and journalists is:

[Price at which class D shares were last bought] * [Total number of outstanding common, A, B, C and D shares]

This is incorrect if the rights attached to the different classes are different enough that the values of the shares are different. And that's the usual case.

Re:DoorDash Valuation Nearly Triples to $4B in Six Months by scarejunba on Friday August 17, 2018 @12:44AM (#17780336)
You're just making up stuff. Why?