Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by dfsegoat on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:07PM
(#17776493)
Genuinely curious - What is the current state / precedent for this type of situation in the US?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by ThrustVectoring on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:19PM
(#17776620)
Complicated. 5th amendment protections against self-incrimination prevents the court from using the fact that you can unlock your phone with a password you know from being used against you. Court opinion has been mixed as to whether you can have an obligation to reveal a password. Even then, the government requires a warrant to search the phone, and that requires a reasonable belief that they would find evidence on it. They can't just go fishing and make you help them.
There's less protection for fingerprint based unlock mechanisms and the like. It's not "something you know", so they're free to compel you to provide it.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by oxplot on Thursday August 16, 2018 @06:51PM
(#17779065)
Interesting. Latest Android (pie) lets you "lock down" your phone using a quick shortcut which basically locks the phone, hides all notifications and will require your PIN to unlock it not your fingerprint. Wonder if that's related to the law you mentioned.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by ransom1538 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:17PM
(#17776599)
US: Life sentence. If a judge orders you to unlock your laptop/phone and you don't -- it could be a life sentence. IMHO, they go around the constitution with "Contempt of court".
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2017/03/man-jailed-indef...
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by LanceH on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:20PM
(#17776631)
Unless you're a politician, then you can just "have no recollection."
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by mindslight on Thursday August 16, 2018 @02:17PM
(#17777210)
Politicians and plebs have the same exact ability there - in both cases what is already happening will just continue unimpeded. That's a principle called equal protection!
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by peeters on Thursday August 16, 2018 @03:18PM
(#17777692)
Granted my source for this is The Newsroom, but IIRC contempt of court is a tool that can only be used coercively, and not punitively. In other words, if you refuse to give your password, you could be detained indefinitely for contempt. But if you forget your password, you should be released immediately. Obviously that's open to interpretation and abuse, I'm just saying contempt would only be correctly applied here if there was reason to believe a witness/suspect was withholding the information, not when they're not able to provide the information.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by gknoy on Thursday August 16, 2018 @05:15PM
(#17778472)
refuse to give your password: detained indefinitely
forget your password: should be released immediately
How could that possibly work? The court has no way of knowing whether someone is refusing to comply, versus being unable to because they don't know (or never knew) a secret. Because of this, it seems very likely that any claim of having forgotten (or having never known) something will be treated as contempt.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by candiodari on Friday August 17, 2018 @04:00AM
(#17781076)
Every system builds on the humans implementing it. So in other words, this system gives judges the power to imprison anyone indefinitely.
These guys, for example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kids_for_cash_scandal
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by mirimir on Thursday August 16, 2018 @04:22PM
(#17778138)
Well, that ex cop in Philadelphia claims that he forgot his macOS FDE password, but he's still in jail.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by cryptonector on Thursday August 16, 2018 @03:26PM
(#17777750)
Contempt of court is not a life sentence. It ends the moment the defendant complies. Whereas a sentence for a "10 years in jail for not revealing password" charge would not be vacated when you decide to reveal the password.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by crooked-v on Thursday August 16, 2018 @04:17PM
(#17778113)
What if the defendant has genuinely forgotten the password?
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by mirimir on Thursday August 16, 2018 @04:24PM
(#17778153)
That could be bad, if the court believes that they're lying.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by adventured on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:25PM
(#17776688)
You're dramatically over-simplifying by using one example to claim it's law. That is not the US law, that's one individual instance. In fact it's unsettled legal territory. The Supreme Court has yet to settle it, and they will very likely be the final word.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by ransom1538 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @01:45PM
(#17776912)
I re-read my comment, I didn't say "That is the US law".
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by ben509 on Thursday August 16, 2018 @02:06PM
(#17777112)
Re-read the parent as well, because it also doesn't claim you did.
You absurdly oversimplified the situation, which is the criticism, please address that.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by emiliobumachar on Thursday August 16, 2018 @03:15PM
(#17777663)
That one precedent sets the most reasonable expectation of what U.S. law means in practice, unless and until overturned.
Re:Australians who won't unlock their phones could face ten ...
by eric_the_read on Thursday August 16, 2018 @04:25PM
(#17778164)
Only in the 3rd Circuit; other jurisdictions aren't obliged to follow its precedent.