It seems highly reasonable that China would be doing better if they toned down their protectionist policies.
You can pull off protectionism to the extent: that you don't need others; or so long as it's limited given your context; or depending on your strength and or ability to command concessions (eg lopsided deals); or depending on what you're willing to give up to protect something (eg give up cheaper prices to shield farmers, or ensure strategic national production of a thing).
Ask France about its agriculture. Ask the US about its truck tariffs. Ask Germany about its car tariffs (EU facade). Ask China about, well, everything. Ask Japan about, well, lots of things. Ask Brazil about its wild economic controls. Ask Mexico about its restrictions on the energy industry. Ask Russia about, well, everything. The list just keeps going.
You can list on one hand the relevant economies with zero or near zero protectionism.
I dont know if such consensus is really justified (since these economists could be politically/ideologically biased).
However, the wikipedia article did not mention the other side of the coin - namely, what protectionism does, and if it has any benefits (and drawbacks).
Protectionism exists in the financial sectors (in which a majority of wealth is being created in the USA). I suspect that those that argue for free trade only argues for free trade for things they benefit from (but protectionism for things that might hurt themselves - even if free trade overall helps others).
Do you have evidence for this, or are you just saying it because you don't like the conclusion?
If that were the case, the US, China, Japan, South Korea, Britain, France, etc wouldn't be major economic powers. Every major economic power today copied the US protectionist model of the 19th century to become rich. Every single one.
The US was explicitly protectionist well into the 1900s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protectionism_in_the_United_St...
Since 1945, we became implicit protectionists while touting free trade.
Without protectionism, japan and south korea wouldn't have toyota, sony, samsung, etc. Without protectionism, china wouldn't have baidu, tencent, etc. Without protectionism, our industries would be owned by britain and europe and we'd only be a raw materials supplier.
"Washington and Hamilton believed that political independence was predicated upon economic independence. Increasing the domestic supply of manufactured goods, particularly war materials, was seen as an issue of national security. In his Reports, Hamilton argued that the competition from abroad and the “forces of habit” would mean that new industries that could soon become internationally competitive (“infant industries”) would not be started in the United States, unless the initial losses were guaranteed by government aid (Conkin, 1980). According to him, this aid could take the form of import duties or, in rare cases, prohibition of imports. He called for customs barriers to allow American industrial development and to help protect infant industries, including bounties (subsidies) derived in part from those tariffs. He also believed that duties on raw materials should be generally low (Dorfman & Tugwell, Early American Policy, 1960). Hamilton explained that despite an initial “increase of price” caused by regulations that control foreign competition, once a “domestic manufacture has attained to perfection… it invariably becomes cheaper”."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tariffs_in_United_States_histo...
Washington, Hamilton and most of our founding fathers were protectionists because our industries were young and needed protection against more established industries of britain.
> There is a consensus among economists that protectionism has a negative effect on economic growth and economic welfare, while free trade, deregulation, and the reduction of trade barriers has a positive effect on economic growth.
When you have to lean on consensus it usually means they have no idea what they are talking about or are pushing political ideology. We have historical proof that protectionism works. It's called the US, China, Britain, Japan, South Korea, etc.
Always take evidence over consensus.
Not among any economists I talk to or read. (Which is the bulk of the mainstream.) The consensus was “tax cuts are real, tariffs are bluster.” Hence the stock market rally. The moment the second part was proved untrue, the rally faltered (but has not stalled).
No, there wasn't. At most, there was concensus that certain policies he proposed would have adverse impact, but not all of those policies were implemented, and policies rarely have their full impact within a 1-2 year period.
> and that it can't grow at anything over 3%,
No, there wasn't.
> and that "those jobs are not coming back"
To the extent that there has ever even a widespread belief among economists, much less a consensus on that, it was (and is) on the long-term trend in certain sectors, not about the absence of positive short-term fluctuations.
> Paul Krugman, the perennial darling of progressive intelligentsia
Krugman isn't a progressive or particularly a favorite of progressives. The darlings of the progressive intelligentsia don't generally have gigs in the corporate media.
> There is a consensus among economists that protectionism has a negative effect on economic growth and economic welfare, while free trade, deregulation, and the reduction of trade barriers has a positive effect on economic growth. In fact protectionism has been implicated by some scholars as the cause of some economic crises, in particular the Great Depression.