News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by plicense on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:47PM (#17735337)
"Unlike Apple, which only allows apps to be downloaded from its own storefront, Google’s platform is more open."

Oh the irony. Android is more open than iOS and yet its Google that EU found to be at fault with Android. How is this not a classic example that, if anything, Android provides a more open platform?

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by lucideer on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:51PM (#17735388)
It's (unfortunately) not illegal anywhere to have non-open platforms. It is illegal in the EU to use the dominant market position of one product to push another product in an anticompetitive manner.

The latter is what Google got done for in the EU. You might think what Apple does is worse, and should be illegal, but that would be a separate hypothetical law.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by lucisferre on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:04PM (#17735508)
Is this not what happens with the bundling of Mail, Calendar and Music in iOS and the fact that many default actions and integrations for these apps in iOS are not available to alternatives?
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by redbeard0x0a on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:26PM (#17735670)
No, Google got in trouble for mandating other companies/products to include Google products (gmail, chrome, etc) in their products (Samsung Galaxy 9, LG whatever phone, etc).

Apple doesn't mandate any other company to change something with their product (Apple installs mail, calendar, music on their own iPhone, iPad, etc). They aren't using their market position to coerce another company to do something in Apple's favor. (as far as Android vs. iOS and the associated hardware phones and tablets).

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:32PM (#17735708)
> No, Google got in trouble for mandating other companies/products to include Google products (gmail, chrome, etc) in their products (Samsung Galaxy 9, LG whatever phone, etc).

If you only look for one thing they got in trouble for. Other things include prioritizing their shopping results on their search engine. There are cases and rulings that don't have anything to do with "coerce another company" wrt monopoly laws. You can be in trouble for only putting your own products on your own products too, no other company has to be involved...just have to be large enough (by volume).

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by muro on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:36PM (#17735741)
Only Chrome, Play Store and Search app.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by jeffbax on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:45PM (#17736225)
… and Google Play Services, which is the bigger angle and what took Android from being "open" to arguably impossible to support the bulk of "Android" software

https://stratechery.com/2018/the-european-commission-versus-...

You don't get Google Play Services without a lot of terms and conditions, and without it you can't really be a useful Android product short of trying to replace the whole store like Amazon does to questionable degrees.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kevinh on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:13PM (#17735583)
My understanding is that Apple does not have a large enough market share in the EU to be considered for similar violations.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by ocdtrekkie on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:27PM (#17735675)
The primary concern is that Apple puts it's own software and features on it's own devices. That's fine, and what Google does on the Pixel line is also fine and not under scrutiny.

The issue is that Google uses blatantly illegal terms to force bundling of various apps upon other manufacturers, and this is illegal in both the US and the EU and most other jurisdictions.

This is a business-to-business issue, not a business-to-consumer issue. Hence why Apple putting it's own software on it's own hardware is not similar. (Also, Apple is not even approaching being a monopoly, Google already is one.)

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by yandie on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:52PM (#17735401)
The reason EU fined Google wasn't that Android was not an open ecosystem, but that Google leveraged other dominant services (Youtube, Maps etc...) to enforce manufacturers to install Search and Chrome on Android phones.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by annabellish on Friday August 10, 2018 @01:52PM (#17735393)
Apple aren't doing anything to prevent competition with their platform. Google are/were. It's that simple.

iOS is a closed platform, and Android is a more open platform, but that's 100% orthogonal to Apple or Google's _business practices_. Closed platforms are not illegal, while anticompetitive behaviour is.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:12PM (#17735579)
> Apple aren't doing anything to prevent competition with their platform.

This is a categorically false statement. I can point to a lot of places where Apple are doing quite a bit to prevent competition on their platform. I mean, browser engine choice is the easiest to see of dozens of ways Apple is doing something to prevent competition on their platform. Did you mean something else by your statement I do not understand?

Even if you mean "with their platform" vs "on their platform" as if users can go somewhere else, that's a far cry from "aren't doing anything" as they are in fact doing lots of things.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by bena on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:19PM (#17736044)
The best way I can think of describing this is like going into McDonald's and asking for a Whopper. You're not going to have a good time. You can't get whatever you want. McDonald's controls everything involved with their own operation, so they get to decide what's on the menu. And competitors products are not on it.

That's Apple.

Google is more like the only lumberyard in the reasonable vicinity. But they'll only sell you lumber if you also buy nails, a hammer, paint, and pipe from them as well even though there are closer, cheaper, or better alternatives elsewhere for those. They're using their position to force others into deals they don't want to be in.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by annabellish on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:30PM (#17736132)
I do mean with their platform, which is why I wrote that and not on their platform.

Only offering your software on your hardware isn't anticompetitive. It's the default for almost everything - your smart fridge isn't anticompetitive because you can't install a different web browser, your modem/router isn't anticompetitive because you can't switch to openwrt, your smart toothbrush isn't anticompetitive because you can't install custom firmware, et cetera.

What is anticompetitive on Google's end has absolutely nothing to do with the software, and everything to do with the licensing. Google have a couple simple rules that make their behaviour anticompetitive. If you want to ship an Android phone with google apps, then:

1) You may not ship any android phones without google apps 2) You may not ship a phone with google apps and a default search engine which is not Google

So, if you're a new manufacturer, Smasung, and you wish to make an Android phone, you have two choices:

1) Use Google Apps and immediately get an extremely mature operating system with a very large software library, but you may not compete with google. Not even that you may not use _that device_ to compete with google. You're not allowed to make any Android-based devices which compete, even if those themselves don't use google software.

2) Develop API-compatible replacements for everything in Google apps, or you can't access the android ecosystem because of how tightly integrated things are. Note, some of these APIs are not clearly documented and have mysterious behaviour. This option is thus only really available to megacorporations who can afford to sink a couple years of development into the project before selling a single device.

This is fundamentally different from what Apple is doing, which is simply selling a product.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:49PM (#17736252)
> Only offering your software on your hardware isn't anticompetitive

I'd say that it has been upheld that only offering your software on your platform has been ruled as anticompetitive if you are large enough. Same with prioritizing your results on your platform, etc. Regardless of if that platform is hardware or any other restricted area with a majority presence.

> your smart fridge isn't anticompetitive because you can't install a different web browser

Unfortunately, I'm afraid if you have the vast majority of the fridge market, and you lock out development for it, you very likely will be accused of anticompetitive behavior.

> This is fundamentally different from what Apple is doing, which is simply selling a product.

Yes, that is very true it is fundamentally different and the specific part about the Android licensing is anticompetitive for those reasons and Apple would not be subject to those rulings. Many of the other software installation practices that Google/Microsoft have been ruled anticompetitive for, however, are very similar to what Apple is doing and only their smaller market share prevents the violation. But we shouldn't pretend that Apple isn't doing anything to prevent competition here, just not in the way that Google did with the most recent Android ruling. Apple does plenty to prevent competition with their platform as do most companies. To say it does nothing is wrong.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:47PM (#17735820)
So a lot of places is “1”?
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:04PM (#17735945)
I was just trying to avoid a large and obvious enumeration in my comment. I assumed we all knew things like browser engine, development/compilation hardware, app store choice, software installation method, system OS choice, runtime eval approach (e.g. JIT), phone/sms app choice, keyboard choice, etc, etc are not subject to choice and in most cases competition is actively prevented. I suppose my assumption was wrong though.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:12PM (#17736004)
You can develop on other platforms - see Xamarin

You want to be able to install another OS on an iPhone? Unless you happen to have an Android phone that has hardware that is supported by one of the forks - good luck with that.

Yes you can use scripting languages with iOS apps, games do it all of the time.

Alternate voip apps integrate well with the native iOS dialer. For instance a call using Skype looks just like a call on the native phone dialer and your Skype call history is integrated with your regular phone call history. You can even say call X using Y with Siri and it will use the alternate app - same with messages. If you use a third party VoIP app, and you’re connected to Bluetooth in your car, it uses the phone call Bluetooth protocol just like the native dialer.

Third party keyboard support has been available for 3 years and unlike Android, you can install a third party keyboard and not give it network access so you’re not installing a keylogger.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:27PM (#17736101)
Sigh. My comment has nothing to do with what you can do elsewhere. I was responding specifically to the false claim "aren't doing anything to prevent competition" which is untrue, they are doing things.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:30PM (#17736126)
Your claim was that you couldn’t have third party keyboards on iOS (untrue), you couldn’t have third party dialer (untrue), you couldn’t use third party development environments (untrue), you had to develop on the Mac (untrue). You couldn’t use a third party SMS client- Google Voice let’s you do that.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:59PM (#17736303)
Unfortunately, whether we agree or not, automatic defaults, prominence of placement, ease of change, and several other factors all contribute to rulings of active competition prevention. That you can change (with or without caveats) is often not enough. None of it relates to the original false statement that Apple does nothing to prevent competition with their platform which it does for many values of platform.

I was incorrect on the keyboard choice, but caveats about what the dialer can be used for or what system that you have to compile on remain. Again though, that's nitpicking here, they have restrictions on all sorts of places that will conveniently be ignored in responses (e.g. alternative installation methods) to make specific points. The general point stands, they actively stifle. To say they don't or that it's only 1 comes off as bias. To ask someone to list some examples to make the general, obvious point is a bit derailing.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @04:37PM (#17736551)
Now you're changing the argument...

What are the caveats with the dialer?

To ask someone to list some examples to make the general, obvious point is a bit derailing.

How is it "derailing" to ask you to give specifics and then systematically get them torn down?

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by tzakrajs on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:03PM (#17735505)
Can you explain to me how the Apple Maps limitation of Siri is not anti-competitive? I believe you are right but I am curious as a layman.
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by gcburn2 on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:13PM (#17735585)
Apple is 24% of the smartphone market so anything they do on their their systems only affects that minority portion and isn't denying competitors access to the market.

Android on the other hand has a 74% share of smartphone market so anything they do impacts a majority of the market and could limit others access to the market.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:50PM (#17735844)
What Apple Maps limitation? You can open Google Maps with Siri now with an ugly work around (https://www.tuaw.com/2012/12/17/how-to-use-google-maps-with-...)

And in iOS 12 any app will be able to provide a Siri shortcut.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:46PM (#17735810)
There was nothing “open” about Google not allowing manufacturers to ship phones using Android forks if they also ship Google certified Android phones.

On the scale of 1-10 openness, that’s a -100

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by skybrian on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:16PM (#17736028)
What's your rating for not allowing anyone else to build compatible phones at all?
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by scarface74 on Friday August 10, 2018 @03:20PM (#17736059)
The same but Steve Jobs never ranted back in the day....

https://mobile.twitter.com/arubin/status/27808662429?lang=en

the definition of open: "mkdir android ; cd android ; repo init -u git://android.git.kernel.org/platform/manifest.git ; repo sync ; make"

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by kodablah on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:02PM (#17735497)
To put it simply, Apple's actions would not be tolerated if they were in a dominant position, as defined by market share not revenue or any other metric.

In general, reasonable societies don't want all businesses subjected to fairness rules, only the ones whose unfairness can be harmful. This is because being subjected to some of these fairness rules is a hindrance to small company growth. They have chosen to use volume as a metric to determine the size at which these rules kick in. It would be tough to argue that other metrics, such as revenue, should be used to determine size because volume determines the number of people affected not cost.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by toast0 on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:04PM (#17735509)
Apple isn't absuing its monopoly in one area to force phone manufacturers who license its software to include inessential software that helps increase its market share in others.

In no small part, because Apple doesn't license its software to other manufacturers, and doesn't have a monopoly on mobile devices operating systems in Europe.

The EU sanctioned Microsoft for forcing manfuacturers to include Internet Explorer, even though Windows is an open platform and users could download competing browsers.

Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by izacus on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:09PM (#17735554)
EU's document says that iOS does not compete in the same market as Android, so it was entirely excluded from consideration. Funny isn't it? :)
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by ocdtrekkie on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:29PM (#17735693)
This is because iOS is not an Android competitor. iOS is not licensed to manufacturers, it is not even in the market. Android, on the other hand, is. Licensing to third parties is the key issue at hand. (Windows Mobile was arguably Android's last viable competitor, and it's dead.)
Re:Google will lose $50M or more in 2018 from Fortnite bypas... by PunchTornado on Friday August 10, 2018 @02:00PM (#17735473)
read the law about dominant position in a market