Everyone gets a benefit from the public roads even if they don't use them directly: they feed the high-value trips that make the businesses there possible. But there's still not enough road-capacity for everyone without value-destroying congestion: a massive toll paid by everyone in delays. So, more money should be raised to improve roads and alternatives. And, that money should be raised in a way that shifts those who are most-adaptable into alternatives, in proportion to the congestion they'd cause. Only congestion fees do that.
So: it's highly progressive when you consider all NYC residents, including those who don't drive. And it's maybe a little regressive between the wealthy and the very-wealthy, just on the general pattern that the very-wealthy spend less of their income. So, boo-hoo for the merely wealthy.
Congestion pricing doesn't seem nearly as regressive as gas taxes or sales taxes, narrowly focused as it is on just those driving in an especially wealthy and especially congested area.
And the parent post's idea that it'd hit the "blue collar" especially hard is, without evidence, just hand-waving. Their time is valuable too, and commute/on-the-job-travel time saved, from pushing lower-value travelers to non-road (or on-road-but-shared-vehicle) paths, could be worth more than the congestion fees.
Why would you say that? A rich person would not spend hours every day commuting though rush hour traffic, or spend most of their day inside their work vehicle. They would buy or rent a central home, possibly near the central office building where they work. City driving in itself makes for a very low quality of life and most rational people would minimize it, given the option.
So I would expect there's either no driving-income correlation, or it's inverse. So reducing congestion would make life easier for rich people, who don't care about the money and only care about the time - by pricing out people who are, by definition, poorer and can't afford to buy that convenience. You could say that the resulting post-tax distribution is progressive, the rich paying and driving more; but that's just a way of distorting the initial argument, that introducing a flat congestion tax is strongly recessive - to the point of completely pricing out poorer people.
There's expensive tolls, and limited & expensive parking, but excellent public transportation – the USA's most extensive and most-used subway system. NY state has the nation's highest (regressive!) gas taxes.
New York is far-and-away the US city with the lowest rate of car ownership:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._cities_with_most_...
Manhattan is the most likely place for congestion pricing. But, though rare in the USA, many Manhattanites never learn to drive! And only 8% of Manhattanite workers commute by car to work:
https://www.nycedc.com/blog-entry/new-yorkers-and-their-cars
(I highly doubt that 8% is correlated with the poorest Manhattanites.)
Car-owning households in NYC are significantly richer than zero-car households:
http://blog.tstc.org/2017/04/21/car-free-new-york-city/
So, people who elect to drive in NYC (outside of driving-on-the-job) are richer than the New Yorkers who don't drive. Further, New Yorkers are richer than other Americans. Ergo, a fee that falls on people who choose to drive in NYC is unlikely to be "regressive", barring any actual evidence to the contrary.
I have no doubt that's true, as in most other places on the planet.
The thing is, you are making an absolute argument: those who drive in NY are richer than those who don't. I don't deny that. I'm making a relative argument: within the driving group, the poorer ones will be priced out. You say those are not poor, but "merely wealthy". Our grand-father said they are blue collar workers. You both lack data, and I suspect that we will see a wide, gentle slope, with most rich people driving, but also an important minority of the lower classes, depending on personal circumstances.
The thing is, does the exact composition of the driving public mater for the regressivity to be a political problem? Some will be priced out and they will scream bloody murder, because from their perspective they were sacrificed in favor of the rich. You could go out and say "boo hoo, you are merely rich", but that's a politically imprudent move - a thousand personal stories will pop up about those marginal blue collar workers no longer able to feed their families.
So you could be right that it is not regressive in a broad, social justice sense, but that's not the sense in which the problem will be sliced. Rather, the vast majority of the affected merely rich will invoke the principle of the matter, and in principle it's designed to price out the poorer drivers, there's no doubt about that.
An idea I'm toying with is to distribute "tradable driving coupons" to all people holding a drivers license. A flat tax would develop on the market, so the net effect is similar to congestion charging. But now the tax does not go to the city, but to the poorer residents who opt not to drive. Ideally, fiscal credits should be earned, so as to not reward those who don't pay any tax and thus have no contribution to the infrastructure. This beautifully solves the political problem and makes driving a matter of personal choice: you are now rewarded for preserving the public good.
If the congestion fees go to expenditures that broadly benefit all New Yorkers, it's far a simpler system than "tradable driving coupons" and could wind up highly progressive. (At one extreme, this "broad benefit" could be just a per-capita rebate of fees collected, in cash, to all residents.)
A "coupons" system would trend towards being just like fees: at the margin, every coupon-holder has to decide whether they prefer cash (from selling their coupons) or driving, exactly like someone facing a congestion fee. Roughly the same set of people "priced out" by fees would be eager to sell rather than drive.
A coupon-system might be nastier to the non-conscientious, because there's likely extra budgeting/deadlines/resale-effort involved. And the lost revenues for broad public projects would have to made up through other NY taxes – some regressive, some progressive – so the net effect on household budgets of a big "coupon giveaway" would be unclear.
Thank you for the perspective on the voucher idea. Yeah, in a perfect world, it's equivalent with a congestion tax coupled with a tax deduction of equal amount, I've hinted to that. But you would need to dynamically change the amount of the tax to keep up with road supply and demand, and that will clearly be be an explosive political decision. Also, for cash in hand to be psychologically equivalent to public services, the voters have to have full trust in the public spending process, which seems unlikely. So in practice revenue generating vouchers could be much more palatable. The additional transaction costs and friction could be negligible compared to a traditional congestion tax: to drive more than your allotment, you load your driving wallet with cash that is deducted at prevailing market voucher prices; at the end of the year, if you generally drove less than the allotment, you will find a nice tax credit waiting for you inside the public tax internet gateway.
By the way, I'm a city councilor in my European town and that's why I might show a strong slant towards practical ways to achieve political consensus, as opposed to just going for the superior theoretical solution. Cities rarely move on theoretical optimum paths and recently, of all idiotic policies, I had to struggle for ending the public subsidy of free parking. No-brainer, but wait until a significant part of the public received if for decades and strongly believe it's some sort of natural right.
1. There's no reason we couldn't provide exceptions for the kinds of vans and trucks that blue-collar workers need to drive into the city to make their livings.
2. There's no reason we couldn't offer income-based exceptions to people who absolutely cannot ride transit for this or that reason.
As in all proposals to ration some scarce resource, it's important to understand that we already ration it, even if it's not explicit. Today, we do it by literally clogging the streets so much that nobody else can get through. (And now we've added this new way, too.) Surely nobody thinks that's the smartest way to ration.
Should we charge $500 to get into national parks? Why not? Should we just charge people for the health care they consume a la carte or should we have a national system for that? Why?
As you can see you’re hitting on a general philosophy question here. My argument would be that trying to set shared government services at market rates tends to lead to deeply regressive outcomes.
There certainly are smart arguments on both sides with congestion pricing. Externalities matter. Are cars inefficient? And so on. But my intention is to illuminate the other side of the coin, which seems perpetually unrepresented.
A couple quick ones:
1. Registering the car in your grandparents name, who have no income, to avoid tolls. Or perhaps your stay at home spouse (assuming you file separately).
2. Make your next vehicle a light truck or van to avoid potentially hundreds in monthly congestion tolls. Luxury trucks are very much a thing.
I agree your plan would technically work, but it would be filled with exceptions, loopholes, and political handouts. That is rather fitting for NYC though.
The end result of which would be a whole bunch of people paying a congestion tax who aren't paying one today.
Automobiles are one of the absolute worst quality-of-life-impacting things about living in Manhattan. They're loud, dangerous, and smelly.
I'm not trying to hide my cards; if it were up to me, I'd ban private cars (at the very least) entirely in Midtown (at the very least).
The difference is that you can avoid the driving tax by not driving; unlike the city tax that can only be avoided by not getting born.
So it's less of a tax and more of paying for a public service.
A cap on Ubers/Lyfts + minimum pay will likely increase the price of Ubers/Lyfts. Rich people will be able to afford the new prices, but poor people will not.
Sure, that's not the only effect it will have, it will also cost money for bankers that drive in from Westchester and park underneath their midtown offices. But, as you can imagine, it won't change their behavior much -- by definition the only people that it will affect are people who can't easily afford it.
If you look at it in a different way, congestion pricing takes a public good that everyone paid to create, the roads and streets of the central business district, and reserves them so they can only be used by drivers with lots of money. There are problems with that approach.
Of course there's another side to the argument, obviously. But I feel like many people don't realize this issue cuts in two directions, rather than just being an obvious "good idea".