News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:41AM (#17715823)
It's people who aren't paying attention to WTF they're doing that cause the danger, not cars or bikes or pedestrians. The rules of the road (including the rules for cyclists and pedestrians) include tons of redundancy so one party not doing what it should almost never causes accidents.

Take for example a pedestrian and a car turning right arrive at an intersection. The pedestrian has a walk signal and the car wants to make a right on red. Both those actions are triggered by the same condition, no cross traffic. In a naive simulation they'd hit each other. In the real world they see each other and one yields to the other in a manner that depends on the situation.

I walk through a "highly walkable" city to/from work every day. As someone who used to have to drive a delivery vehicle I try not to be an idiot pedestrian, when I cross on a don't cross signal I time it with the lights, I don't cross when someone might want to race through the intersection just before the light change, etc.

The behavior I see from other pedestrians and often cyclists is just moronic (and drivers too but there's so much traffic they rarely have opportunity to do stupid things). I don't expect people to wait for the ok to cross every single time but people should at least make sure their actions don't directly conflict with other traffic (like the difference between a car taking a right on red and straight up running a red). Presumably many of these same people who don't pay more than minimal attention to what they're doing when they're on foot or two wheels will continue to not pay attention to what they're doing when they're driving a car (hopefully they at least take their headphones out).

Making a city walkable is just a politically correct way of saying they're gonna make it harder for idiots to meet at high speed.

> If a driver doesn't have time to slow down and stop for a pedestrian, they are going too fast. It's that simple.

Take your circular logic and shove it up a bodily orifice where it doesn't easily or comfortably fit. If I wanted to get hit by a truck at walking speed all I have to do it time my commute to coincide with when the sun will be on the horizon and cross a particular street when all the lights are red but just before all the right turn arrows turn green. After about a week or two doing that I'd probably get hit.

Every two party accident has at least two parties that could have done something different that would have prevented the accident. Accidents are fairly diverse in their circumstances. Just assigning blame to one party by default is an exercise in bad policy.

Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by dang on Saturday August 11, 2018 @01:28AM (#17738507)
> Take your circular logic and shove it up a bodily orifice

> Oh screw off with your edge case

These are bannable offenses on Hacker News. If you post like this again, we will ban you. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and post civilly and substantively, or not at all.

Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by ikawe on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @11:39AM (#17716799)
> Take for example a pedestrian and a car turning right arrive at an intersection. The pedestrian has a walk signal and the car wants to make a right on red. Both those actions are triggered by the same condition, no cross traffic. In a naive simulation they'd hit each other. In the real world they see each other and one yields to the other in a manner that depends on the situation

To be clear, the pedestrian has the right of way in this situation, the car should always yield.

In practice, cars often don’t respect it (happens to me daily). Sometimes because the driver is just rude or ignorant, which is a much harder problem to solve, but often because they simply didn’t see the pedestrian because the driver is looking left while they turn right. Ironically, they’re doing this for their own safety as a driver, because they don’t want to get hit from the left side.

Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by Symbiote on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:28AM (#17716233)
> The rules of the road include tons of redundancy ...

> the car wants to make a right on red

That possibility is almost unique to North America, and is a prime example of cars having priority over people, and damn the consequences.

Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by zajd on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:57AM (#17715986)
> Every two party accident has at least two parties that could have done something different that would have prevented the accident.

Be sure to tell this to the family of someone who died when a drunk driver crossed the lanes and hits them head on

Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by riffic on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @11:29AM (#17716726)
That would be an example of crime, not accident.
[dead]
Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:20AM (#17716164)
Yes but also screw off the deliberate ignoring of the difference in risk and culpability. Its always the pedestrian that dies; its always the driver with the mechanical advantage to put their vehicle where it needs to be quickly.
Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:38AM (#17716310)
>Yes but also screw off the deliberate ignoring of the difference in risk and culpability.

The expectation that big traffic is by default responsible when it crushes small stuff is completely opposite of every other case where different classes of traffic mix (unless the accident is an obvious edge case).

If a semi backs into the guy spotting it the question is why the spotter was there. If heavy equipment hits a service truck the question is why the service truck was in a place to get hit. If a tank hits a humvee the humvee driver is the first person to get yelled at. Even drunk recreational boaters are expected to steer clear of ships.

I'm not saying the bigger class of traffic should be in the right by default but the smaller class of traffic is almost without exception (i.e. I can't think of any exception) the class of traffic that has better visibility as to what's going on in a given situation and can more easily yield.

>Its always the pedestrian that dies

Physics doesn't know right and wrong.

>its always the driver with the mechanical advantage to put their vehicle where it needs to be quickly.

Yes and no. A car can go faster and swerve out of a lane faster. A pedestrian can stop much faster and signal its intentions to others much more obviously (hard to convey body language from within a car and pedestrians can't count on people to use blinkers)

Edit: I'm really interested in why this is down-voted. There's nothing that should be controversial in this comment.

Re:New York’s success provides road map for others taking ai... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday August 09, 2018 @11:10AM (#17724814)
I agree. I didn't do that.