News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by thisgoodlife on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:30AM (#17714298)
Or maybe just revenue from eu < cost to comply
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by pmlnr on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:34AM (#17714320)
cost to comply is not to log data of the same users they are showing the blockade right now. I fail to see how that's so expensive to do.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by steventhedev on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:43AM (#17714381)
Or perhaps they've been advised that because they have an email subscription, they'd need to hire a full time DPO, and their outside counsel quoted them several thousand dollars a year.

It's simple arithmetic to decide it's cheaper to block all EU visitors.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by oblio on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:46AM (#17714398)
> they'd need to hire a full time DPO

They don't. They need to designate someone as the DPO, it doesn't have to be full time.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:16AM (#17714563)
That's technically true but practically untrue.

The DPO is a major imposition and simply being required to comply with the DPO parts alone is sufficient to make the EU not worthwhile for many businesses.

1. Whilst a DPO can theoretically be part time, a DPO is not allowed to have other roles in the firm that could create a "conflict of interest". This is so vague that in a company that works with data, almost any other role could be argued to create such a conflict of interest.

2. The DPO position has a list of mandatory responsibilities and even qualifications that will be accepted. For example the EU has advised DPOs need "expertise in EU data protection law". Where will foreign websites find such a person?

3. The DPO works for the firm but cannot be told how to do their job. They also cannot be fired or penalised for anything related to their job responsibilities.

In practice these rules mean it's very likely everyone will outsource the DPO role to third parties.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by pimterry on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:46AM (#17714714)
You need a DPO if one of the following apply:

* you are a public authority or body (except for courts acting in their judicial capacity)

* your core activities require large scale, regular and systematic monitoring of individuals (for example, online behaviour tracking)

* your core activities consist of large scale processing of special categories of data or data relating to criminal convictions and offences.

That's from https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da..., which is a pretty good summary generally, from the UK Information Commissioner's Office.

If you're running an ad network building profiles of millions of users, then yes, you need a DPO. If you're storing extremely personal medical data, then yes, you need a DPO. If you're running an email newsletter, you 100% do not.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by seszett on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:00AM (#17714477)
> they've been advised that because they have an email subscription, they'd need to hire a full time DPO, and their outside counsel quoted them several thousand dollars a year.

I think a large part of the scare that can be observed among American companies is due to legal advisers jumping on the opportunity to make big money by misleading their customers into thinking there are enormous, complicated and unlikely requirements for compliance, and huge risks to making any mistake.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:18AM (#17714571)
There are in fact enormous, complicated and unlikely requirements for compliance and huge risks to making any mistake.

The risk to making mistakes: fines of up to 4% of your turnover, in the worst case. As many companies have margins below this, it means losing all your profit for a year or more.

As for the rest, the vastness and vagueness of the GDPR has been extensively documented elsewhere. Bear in mind the EU Commission itself was immediately found in repeated violation of the GDPR just via their own website once the law activated. Their answer was that they themselves didn't have to comply with it.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by nextlevelwizard on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:46AM (#17714397)
Nothing of value was lost. Good riddance!
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by chrismeller on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:40AM (#17714363)
No, that's not the only requirement. At the very least there are additional record keeping steps, policies and procedures to draft, the appointment of a DPO that responds to requests for access or erasure, and the development of the features to fulfill both of those requests. Not to mention the potential risk of doing any of that wrong and dealing with the fallout if you get called on it.

One of the sites on this list is the Aiken Standard. We're talking a local newspaper serving Aiken, SC - a city of less than 30,000 people. Even if an EU citizen (or someone traveling in the EU) cared about their local news, it's simply not worth it - that's not their audience.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by Drakim on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:44AM (#17714387)
Wait, hold on, do you really need to do any of that if you are keeping zero data on people? I assume that kinda organization is only relevant if you are keeping data.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by seszett on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:53AM (#17714443)
No, you don't have to.

> At the very least there are additional record keeping steps, policies and procedures to draft, the appointment of a DPO that responds to requests for access or erasure, and the development of the features to fulfill both of those requests.

* "Record keeping steps" are not needed if you don't keep records (which is what you should do);

* "Policies and procedures" are what you should already have, of course, and GDPR didn't change that in any way;

* A DPO must be appointed only if processing the personal data of your customers is your core activity;

* Developing features to fulfill requests for access or erasure isn't necessary if you don't keep records.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by chrismeller on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:13AM (#17714546)
Even writing an IP address in a web server log is considered "keeping data". Most of these news sites also have some form of "create an account to get updates / comment / vote" system, which would absolutely count as "keeping data".

At the very least you still need a policy to give people telling them what data you keep and who you share it with. Even if that is nothing and no one, you need to be able to tell them that and you need someone who is responsible for handling those requests when they come in.

"Just don't keep anything" is not a sufficient answer.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by josteink on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:45AM (#17714709)
> Even writing an IP address in a web server log is considered "keeping data"

No it's not. Stop spreading FUD.

If so, every part of every Internet-connected system on earth would be required to be completely redesigned to be GDPR-compliant. Demanding anything like that is not only unreasonable, it's 100% unrealistic.

The GDPR is perfectly reasonable legislation and has legroom for obvious operational requirements, like access logs.

(If you however mine the access log to derive or track users, that is another matter completely.)

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by yc-kraln on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:04AM (#17716044)
Yes, it is. You need to put into your privacy policy what you log (and yes, IP addresses are personal data) and how long your retention policy is. However, it's pretty easy to argue that IP addresses in logs are required (for a reasonable time, like a week) to provide the service.

Might want to talk to a data protection officer before you go around swinging terms like FUD.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by oytis on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:51AM (#17715055)
> (If you however mine the access log to derive or track users, that is another matter completely.)

So under GDPR you're not allowed to process data you've already got? I wouldn't call this reasonable legislation.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by marksomnian on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @08:14AM (#17715215)
If the data was obtained in violation, it follows that any processing, while not technically in violation, wouldn't be looked upon favourably.

Furthermore, although IANAL, I suspect that certain classes of processing fall under different rules, therefore the processing could potentially be in violation even if the collection wasn't.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by Drakim on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:08AM (#17715573)
That seems like some twisted logic.

"I was just dumping data in logs, I don't have to care about privacy concerns. Oh, and now I have all this data on my server, since it's already here I surely deserve to process it without caring about privacy concerns!"

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by oytis on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:34AM (#17715773)
I mean if we can derive enough information about the user from the data that is strictly necessary otherwise, then the privacy is already doomed, and all efforts to protect it with some legislation will be inevitably in contradiction just with how technology works.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by adventured on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:01AM (#17714485)
A newspaper from Aiken, South Carolina doesn't need to worry about complying with GDPR in any regard what-so-ever, not under any realistic circumstance. It can safely entirely disregard it.

The Aiken Standard doesn't have to worry about GDPR just like a small town newspaper in Spain doesn't need to worry about complying with every privacy law that every US state decides to implement in the coming years (following in California's footsteps).

There is a vast misunderstanding of how jurisdiction works and how it's going to play out in the near future. The vast majority of the world will disregard GDPR and comply with their own local laws instead. Small and mid size sites from any given country are not going to attempt to comply with 407 different privacy laws from every country/city/state/region/zone/province/whatever around the world.

There is no alternative to this future. The sole, sane approach is to disregard Internet privacy laws if they do not apply to you in terms of jurisdiction. You will not be able to comply with the zillions of Internet-focused laws that are going to get created across the globe in the coming decade. GDPR should act as the training wheels for people building online sites/services/businesses to understand jurisdiction.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by chrismeller on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:18AM (#17714576)
I don't disagree with your point that nothing is ever going to come of it. In the case of an independently-owned local newspaper the EU can "huff and puff" as much as they want and there's not going to realistically be any impact to them. A lot of these "local" papers are owned by large parent companies though, and that becomes a different story all together.

Even if you are independent and there's nothing the EU can realistically do to you, it's just one more thing you have to deal with. Figuring out WTF is going on, getting a lawyer to verify that there's nothing they can do to you, etc. etc. There are still some hard costs associated and it's going to distract you from what your company actually does for a while.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by IanCal on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:51AM (#17714427)
I'm pretty sure the answer here is "no".
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by josteink on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:58AM (#17714470)
> No, that's not the only requirement. At the very least there are additional record keeping steps, policies and procedures to draft, the appointment of a DPO that responds to requests for access or erasure

That only applies if you illegally track users.

You know what a simple solution to that is? Yup: Don't illegally track users. Pure magic, I know!

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by IanCal on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:50AM (#17714424)
I'm very sure that you do not need to appoint a DPO unless you're over a certain size.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:21AM (#17714586)
Can you back that up? This site claims otherwise:

https://www.itgovernance.co.uk/data-protection-officer-dpo-u...

There is no exemption for small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which has been reaffirmed by the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO): "I've heard plenty of people talking about there being a DPO exemption for SMEs - this is absolutely not the case." Peter Brown, Senior Technology Officer, Information Commissioner's Office (ICO)

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by pimterry on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:51AM (#17714743)
https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da... is a good summary from the UK gov authority. It's not based on size, but it isn't applicable to most businesses anyway.

You need a DPO if:

* you are a public authority or body (except for courts acting in their judicial capacity)

* your core activities require large scale, regular and systematic monitoring of individuals (for example, online behaviour tracking)

* your core activities consist of large scale processing of special categories of data or data relating to criminal convictions and offences.

Imo, those are all pretty reasonable cases where you should have somebody responsible managing your data privacy. DPOs are for people managing very private data, or profiling people at very large scales. For most businesses, DPOs aren't relevant.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by chrismeller on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:23AM (#17714599)
I'm honestly not sure about the specifics on who legally has to have a DPO, just that it's a thing and a lot of people do. There's also the weird requirement that there be some EU-resident "responsible person" if your organization is not based in the EU that I'm fuzzy on the details of.

Even if you can avoid both of those you still need a point person who answers GDPR-related requests. Whether you end up calling that person the DPO (with the legal responsibilities and consequences that comes with) or just the "GDPR Guy" (also known as Ted from Accounting...) it's still something new you have to deal with, train for, etc.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by seszett on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:56AM (#17714463)
It's not a question of size, it's only needed if processing your customers' private data is your core activity, ie. if you operate an ad network that builds personal profiles of people.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by oytis on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:47AM (#17714402)
A news website won't build a tracking system themselves, they would rather use ready-made analytics plugins. Making them selective might be a pain (I'm not a web developer, just guessing). Even after that you need a lawyer with some technical knowledge to assess that you've done everything right. And also a lawyer that would deal with some random complaints that will still land in your message box. Can be pretty expensive.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by alerighi on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:54AM (#17714447)
Not logging data means no revenue from ads, or smaller revenue, and thus it's not convenient to comply.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by starquake on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:35AM (#17714339)
Maybe even because they would make less money if they can't sell your data anymore.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by AmericanChopper on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:42AM (#17714374)
Maybe they just don’t do any business or have any audience in Europe and are faced with cost of compliance (more than $0) vs block Europe ($0).
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by adventured on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:07AM (#17714515)
If they're doing no business in Europe, they do not need to worry about complying with GDPR at all and can freely track European users any way they see fit.

The EU has no jurisdiction over newspapers in South Carolina. It is that simple legally.

If I visit a random popular Chinese site, landing on a Chinese mainland server in the process, the US Government is not going to get to tell that Chinese site how it can legally use my data in their country. Shouting that I'm an American citizen and that they must comply with US privacy laws, will do no good: the US Government has no jurisdiction over the matter. It works exactly the same way for the US-EU-GDPR as it pertains to a newspaper from South Carolina.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:22AM (#17714594)
The EU has asserted it does have such jurisdiction.

The risk to local newspapers is low for now, but comes from the possibility of future agreements by the USA to cooperate with the EU on GDPR enforcement (e.g. as part of some trade deal), or their executives going to the EU for a business trip or holiday and coming under jurisdiction that way, or selling or wanting to be sold to a firm with EU presence, etc etc. Lots of ways the EU can end up with leverage over an apparently small and local firm.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by adventured on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:32AM (#17714647)
It doesn't matter what the EU asserts. They do not have that jurisdiction, unless they're planning a military invasion of the US and plan to rob it of its sovereignty.

Just like the US does not have the ability to dictate to China what privacy laws look like in that country or how US citizen data is managed within that country (eg when I visit a Chinese site).

How could any this possibly be difficult to understand?

If South Dakota comes up with its own crazy privacy laws, that doesn't mean it gets to actually "assert" how EU sites must manage data for people from South Dakota. It doesn't matter how much South Dakota screams about it, that state has no power to dictate anything to the EU. You would only have to particularly worry about it, as an EU site, if you were eg hosting a server in South Dakota, or doing business there.

edit: replying to your comment below, because my replies are throttled

It is in fact how jurisdiction works today and yesterday and always. The exceptions require agreed upon, established laws between the parties that say otherwise, which you just admitted is the case by referencing FATCA as an example.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:39AM (#17714680)
That's not how jurisdiction works these days.

Look at FATCA. A US law that every financial institution in Europe has to comply with whether they like it or not.

The EU knows it isn't going to invade the USA. Nonetheless, it has explicitly asserted many times that everyone, globally, is expected to comply, regardless of whether they have any EU corporate presence or not. Why do you think they would do that, if they aren't intending to find ways to make it enforceable? And there are certainly many tools available to do that with that aren't military in nature.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by jacobgreenleaf on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:46AM (#17715029)
FATCA “applies” to foreign corporations because bilateral treaties were signed, and a lot of the agreements were reciprocal.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Thursday August 09, 2018 @05:35AM (#17722755)
No it doesn't. FATCA applies to foreign corporations because otherwise the US financial system will freeze them out, moreover FATCA requires recursive application of this rule, that is part of FATCA compliance involves determining if your counterparties are FATCA compliant and freezing them out. It has nothing to do with bilateral treaties.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by AmericanChopper on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:22AM (#17714593)
Can you point to some case law that says EU data subjects consuming US based services will not protected by GDPR? Because one of the main points of the legislation is that the EU will use it to protect their data subjects in every jurisdiction. You’re probably right, but you won’t be able to direct me to a lawyer who would be willing to evaluate a business and determine its GDPR exposure for $0.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by adventured on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:30AM (#17714633)
You're asking me to argue or prove a negative.

You might as well apply the same premise to US vs EU vs Chinese (vs any other country) freedom of speech laws.

It's the exact same jurisdiction premise on how rights are governed, whether we're talking about privacy or otherwise.

Just because I'm an American, that doesn't give me US freedom of speech protections when I step foot into EU countries or Brazil or China or North Korea. I'm bound by the local laws on most things, with few exceptions.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by AmericanChopper on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:45AM (#17714703)
I’m asking you to prove a negative to demonstrate that no US company could adequately assess their exposure at present, and they certainly couldn’t do it for free.

You seem to not understand that one of the core principles of the GDPR is that the EU intend to enforce it in all jurisdictions. Which they can do without an armed invasion using trade treaties, and instruments such as the New York Convention. For any entity anywhere in the world that doesn’t do business in the EU, blocking the entire union is the most risk averse and cost sensitive option.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by mcroft on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:35AM (#17714336)
Skimming the list, it does seem very heavily dominated by US local news sources.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by mrweasel on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:54AM (#17714446)
Instapaper is sort of the only site where it's an actual problem. I get the feeling that the rest are just running on some common platform, which have the feature of being able to block the EU after some US corporate lawyer overreacted.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by josteink on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:01AM (#17714488)
> after some US corporate lawyer overreacted

Given how US techies here on HN seems to constantly overreact and loudly proclaims how the GDPR means they need to hire 20 new employees and how they all will be suited into bankruptcy anyway...

If they are now stuck in a needlessly rigid legal regime, it's hard NOT to say they brought it on themselves.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by raynr on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:57AM (#17714466)
So much this. You have a business with an online B2C component and your contract with your suppliers and/or service providers requires you to comply with the GDPR. You are in no position to comply because your primary area of business isn't the EU, sure your website is accessible but no one is realistically going to engage your services from Germany. Meanwhile the GDPR has extra territorial reach and is so broadly worded that you don't know the ways in which you will be impacted. Your legal counsel is telling you "they ain't budging, why not manage it practically, by explicitly not target the EU?"

So you block access to your goods/services/website to EU IP addresses. Your suppliers and service providers are happy, your legal counsel is happy, and your business is not impacted in any meaningful way at all.

I haven't looked at the sites on the list, which may well contain "shady" websites, but bear in mind that these are the entities who have looked at the GDPR and concluded it was somehow or other better to expressly tell visitors that they do not comply with the GDPR.

A shady business wouldn't even bother putting a notice up on their website!