News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by Retric on Saturday August 04, 2018 @08:59AM (#17686699)
The idea is not a deterrent. The idea is if someone spends most of their life in prison they are not going to be able to commit crimes outside.

Effective or not, the reasoning is fairly straightforward.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by albertgoeswoof on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:18AM (#17687149)
But you have to let them out at some point. The longer they’re in the more likely they’re going to be to commit crime when they do leave.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by a1369209993 on Saturday August 04, 2018 @02:49PM (#17688001)
> But you have to let them out at some point.

The idea behind "tough on crime" is that actually, you don't: A nineteen-year-old mugged some people to pay for food/drugs/I'll-ask-my-caddie's-chauffeur-what-else-poor-people-spend-money-on? Great! We can use them as slave labor on and off for the rest of their life, and the less opprotunities for "off", the better.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by themihai on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:33AM (#17687216)
Without some rehabilitation programs chances are that they will get back to prison regardless of how long or short it's their stay. I guess the gov has to decide if it's worth to pay for rehabilitation or just keep them in jails. The latter is easier to implement and to sell.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by albertgoeswoof on Saturday August 04, 2018 @06:51PM (#17688817)
Re-offending rates are lower in counties that do provide rehabilitation rates, it’s pretty well known. So the US government is wrong on this point if that’s what they’re judging against.

Most people in positions of influence aren’t stupid though- clearly there is something else swaying the decision. I would imagine that for-profit prisons are probably the root cause.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by fwn on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:21AM (#17686758)
A sentence has always a correcting, an deterring, a protecting and a vengeance component. (Not very educated on law though. That's what I learned in my mandatory philosophy of law class as an undergrad long ago.)
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by dragonwriter on Saturday August 04, 2018 @12:28PM (#17687445)
> A sentence has always a correcting, an deterring, a protecting and a vengeance component.

No, those are among the different theories of the function(s) of criminal punishment. It is not the case that every criminal sentence incorporates all four as elements.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by maxxxxx on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:11AM (#17686905)
The US is very heavy on protecting and vengeance. There is no interest in correcting and it seems harsh sentences don't deter much either.