News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by jimnotgym on Saturday August 04, 2018 @08:53AM (#17686674)
It still amazes me the human waste of US prison sentences. Armed robbery in the UK for a 17 year old, from memory, is likely to attract significantly less than 10 years of actual time served.

Yet in the UK we are not overrun with armed robbers. I think the deterrent effect of a long sentence is rather lost on a 17 year-old who is already making bad life decisions.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by betterunix2 on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:04AM (#17686882)
The problem in the US is that there was a period of time, still somewhat ongoing, where politicians could score a few points by promising to be "tough on crime." George H. W. Bush once went on TV to say that if longer sentences and mandatory minimum sentences meant paying for more prisons, we would pay for more prisons. One of the worst things about tough on crime politics is the feedback loop it creates -- if your opponent is tough on crime, you would have to be even more tough on crime, so the concept spread across the political spectrum (Charles Schumer is a proud "law enforcement hawk").
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by aaron-lebo on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:18AM (#17686938)
This is easy to observe in judicial elections where said judges get tough prior to elections.

But there's more to it than that. The US system doesn't rehabilitate prisoners well, so letting a person who was committing armed robbery (this isn't a small offense, it's terrorizing innocent people) at 17 out at 22 isn't much better than letting them out at 27. The chance of recidivism is high, and so letting them out early is likely to backfire.

You'll recall that Bush did successfully use recidivism against Dukakis in 88. He abused that to win politically, but the system failed somewhere.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by martinald on Saturday August 04, 2018 @02:41PM (#17687980)
I think the real problem in the US is the legal discrimination that goes on to people with criminal records. Records don't automatically get 'spent' like most other countries after a period of time so always need to be declared, which makes it hard to impossible to get a job.

You also lose student aid access, landlords can turn you away from housing legally because of it, etc.

So even if you 100% want to be a normal member of society, you will hit so many roadblocks it is very difficult to do so.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by hansthehorse on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @01:06AM (#17713327)
My daughter has a felony record. When she was looking for a job I told her to lie on her applications. If she declared the conviction she wouldn't get the job, if she lied and they checked she wouldn't get the job. If she lied and got the job she wins. There is nothing to lose by lying on your job application if you have a conviction.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by extralego on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:32AM (#17687211)
I think “Rehabilitation” is probably a distraction. A mere chance might be all that they need, and America denies that to even people who have not committed a crime. The lack of social mobility means that regardless of what programs or mindsets one experiences in prison, they are all but forced right back into the same environment that put them there in the first place.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by aaron-lebo on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:57AM (#17687315)
What you're saying is if there's a chance that someone is reformed, they should be given that chance. But the other possibility is that they aren't. If you're wrong on the first and keep them in longer than they need to be, that wastes their time and potential. If you're wrong on the second and they aren't changed you're putting someone else at risk (someone who is innocent).

The probabilities aren't a coin flip. Someone committing armed robbery at 17 had issues. If you know your prison system not only doesn't solve those issues but probably exacerbates them, the odds are you put that person out at 22 (or however early) and not only will they not be changed, but they'll have met real criminals and have few options. That's reckless and people who didn't rob someone at gunpoint shouldn't have to deal with the risk.

That's why if we aren't actually rehabilitating, you're basically playing with a loaded gun, which is why risk averse politicians and judges aren't going anywhere near that and by odds the "correct" choice.

Rehabilitation isn't a distraction. You have an actual problem that you can solve by: locking them away (we do this), helping them to become productive (rehabilitation), or hoping they've changed. The last isn't a solution, it's trusting in human nature, which in this situation has already shown to be faulty.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by seanmcdirmid on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:02AM (#17686712)
Well, to be fair, the UK isn't awash in numerous cheap guns either. I agree with the sentiment, but there are plenty of things that more significantly affect the UK/USA's crime rate than deterrence via incarceration.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by Retric on Saturday August 04, 2018 @08:59AM (#17686699)
The idea is not a deterrent. The idea is if someone spends most of their life in prison they are not going to be able to commit crimes outside.

Effective or not, the reasoning is fairly straightforward.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by albertgoeswoof on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:18AM (#17687149)
But you have to let them out at some point. The longer they’re in the more likely they’re going to be to commit crime when they do leave.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by a1369209993 on Saturday August 04, 2018 @02:49PM (#17688001)
> But you have to let them out at some point.

The idea behind "tough on crime" is that actually, you don't: A nineteen-year-old mugged some people to pay for food/drugs/I'll-ask-my-caddie's-chauffeur-what-else-poor-people-spend-money-on? Great! We can use them as slave labor on and off for the rest of their life, and the less opprotunities for "off", the better.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by themihai on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:33AM (#17687216)
Without some rehabilitation programs chances are that they will get back to prison regardless of how long or short it's their stay. I guess the gov has to decide if it's worth to pay for rehabilitation or just keep them in jails. The latter is easier to implement and to sell.
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by albertgoeswoof on Saturday August 04, 2018 @06:51PM (#17688817)
Re-offending rates are lower in counties that do provide rehabilitation rates, it’s pretty well known. So the US government is wrong on this point if that’s what they’re judging against.

Most people in positions of influence aren’t stupid though- clearly there is something else swaying the decision. I would imagine that for-profit prisons are probably the root cause.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by fwn on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:21AM (#17686758)
A sentence has always a correcting, an deterring, a protecting and a vengeance component. (Not very educated on law though. That's what I learned in my mandatory philosophy of law class as an undergrad long ago.)
Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by dragonwriter on Saturday August 04, 2018 @12:28PM (#17687445)
> A sentence has always a correcting, an deterring, a protecting and a vengeance component.

No, those are among the different theories of the function(s) of criminal punishment. It is not the case that every criminal sentence incorporates all four as elements.

Re:How Companies Make Millions Charging Prisoners to Send an... by maxxxxx on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:11AM (#17686905)
The US is very heavy on protecting and vengeance. There is no interest in correcting and it seems harsh sentences don't deter much either.