About the most you could change in this scenario would have been for the FD not to have offered the service to residents outside their area, which would have made everybody worse off.
That's clearly not true. For example, he wouldn't have paid his house.
Note that they're not set up to sign a contract at the scene and even if they were, it would be signed under duress, so it would be unenforceable.
The only way "we'll pay" works is if he has the cash on hand. Do you really want to complain that they didn't offer that option?
Here's a recent Ohio case illustrating the principle - first fire-related one I found. Although this is about a bill for boarding up a property after a fire than actual firefighting, it explains the idea very clearly: http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/9/2010/2010-oh...