It's been said in several other places but this sort of intellectual dishonesty can't be left alone.
There are a plethora of examples currently in place in society that work well where if an uninsured person requires assistance they pay AT COST. If they can't afford out of pocket they set up a payment schedule.
This is a major flaw with our health system (which should be single payer), and is a framing device for a possible policy flaw in Tennessee (to wit: people in the surrounding communities should have been required to pay a substantially higher fire tax to obligate surrounding communities to cover them).
But none of this has anything to do with what the fire department did. The fire happened outside their service area. They simply weren't obligated to respond to it.
I should have said that people are provided services and given a bill. Recouping that cost is, as you point out, difficult or impossible in many cases.
>> But none of this has anything to do with what the fire department did. The fire happened outside their service area. They simply weren't obligated to respond to it.
I can't argue with that. But it's still irksome that there is no other recourse for someone confronting an extremely slow moving fire while people with high pressure hoses look on.
People generally live in double-wide trailers because they can't afford nicer houses. If someone's trailer burns down, that person is out of a house just as much as some guy in a McMansion would be if it burned down. Someone whose double-wide burned down probably has less saved money and fewer resources to take care of emself with than someone who just lost a McMansion.
As to why it might cost that much per fire, it's probably low probability event so you need to pay for all the time, training, and equipment that sit's unused between emergency's. Add in the overhead in showing up to events like this one where they receive zero compensation and you have a major free rider problem.
For that matter, I asked whether it was a case of people not reasonably being able to afford the cost five levels up; I'm asking about a "moral" distinction tptacek sees.
It would be harder to determine the right price to charge people. It's not the water that costs anything, it's the equipment. Remember, this organization is not seeking to make a profit, just cover costs. If people pay in advance, you charge (number of houses / cost of maintenance). Very straightforward. If people pay after the fact, you have to charge (number of houses that will burn down / cost of maintenance). But you don't know in advance how many houses will burn down.
Finally, while letting a house burn down is an ugly business, it's also pretty ugly when you have to send out collections. You already know they were too poor or irresponsible to pay the fee upfront, so it's not like they have a nest egg sitting around.
Would you say this creates an incentive for EMTs and paramedics to break people's legs?
Again, systems are in place to already collect from people who can't afford lump sum payments. Amortized scheduling occurs in pretty much every industry.
Yes, a certain number of people cannot and perhaps will not pay. But the net benefit to society is manifest when your neighbor's house isn't burnt to the ground.
This is not insurance, this is a protection racket.
EDIT: By protection racket I mean this: I think in this scenario there is little distinction in letting something bad happen when it is well within your ability to stop it and making something bad happen.
"If you don't pay up I'm not going to be able to stop Vito over here from breaking your legs if he tries to break your legs..."
Words mean things.
Also, a "protection racket" is when some thugs retaliate against you if you don't pay them, not when people refuse to provide a service you've previously refused to pay for.
I also have a dim view of the laws of the Alaskan city, but there's no call to throw around accusations of "intellectual dishonesty" and such just because you're angry, too.
Insurance does work. It worked in this case: The neighbors houses were saved. But when insurance is the ONLY means by which a burning house can be saved we should rethink how we treat emergencies.
About the most you could change in this scenario would have been for the FD not to have offered the service to residents outside their area, which would have made everybody worse off.
That's clearly not true. For example, he wouldn't have paid his house.
Note that they're not set up to sign a contract at the scene and even if they were, it would be signed under duress, so it would be unenforceable.
The only way "we'll pay" works is if he has the cash on hand. Do you really want to complain that they didn't offer that option?
Here's a recent Ohio case illustrating the principle - first fire-related one I found. Although this is about a bill for boarding up a property after a fire than actual firefighting, it explains the idea very clearly: http://www.supremecourt.ohio.gov/rod/docs/pdf/9/2010/2010-oh...
Exactly. Nobody wants someone stranger's house to burn down, but part of the rules of living there was that you'd pay your portion if you wanted protection.
On another site, I saw someone write a comment like "When my house was robbed, the insurance companies just stood there and did nothing! I offered to pay them afterwards, but they wouldn't agree!" (Obvious sarcasm.) Insurance doesn't work if you only pay it -after- you have a problem.