News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by thrownblown on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:20AM (#17645009)
I love the stuff!Improves caffeine absorption and is great for performance anxiety. I use it before bike racing or public speaking. The mental state I would describe as clear, calm, present and focused.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by PascLeRasc on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:09PM (#17646049)
L-Theanine fixed my mild stutter and has helped me tremendously in the gym with focusing on every rep. It's a wonderful supplement.

I especially love biking after having some, I get into a great flow state and can go much longer.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by polskibus on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:26AM (#17645063)
What dosage do you use( coffee and l-theanine), how do you take them (regularly, at standard times or occasionally)? Do you use any other nootropics?
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by amelius on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:31AM (#17645126)
I tried it, several times and at different dosages, but it doesn't work for me. No effect whatsoever. I wonder why ...
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by akiselev on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:39AM (#17645196)
L-theanine is a structural analog of L-glutamate and L-glutamine, amino acids that are common in neurotransmitters, so the effects of taking it will be highly variable by person just like any psychiatric drug - although the effects are far less pronounced so it's much safer (liver toxicity aside). Chances are, your diet already has plenty of those building blocks for your unique brain chemistry so you're at an equilibrium where adding more L-* just gets balanced out by the body or it could be that it's saturated so you have to try other levers (although that is much harder since metabolic pathways are nonlinear and incredibly complicated).
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by pasbesoin on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:16PM (#17645569)
Thank you for this explanation.

liver toxicity aside

That's what I was looking for. I recall a burst of interest/hype (choose your word), several years ago, about L-theanine. One company/salesman (the very prominent-looking, TV type, although I think this may have been via one of those suspicious-looking PBS specials [1]), was promoting it in a topical cream. Apparently, it would pass from that into the bloodstream.

There was little if any discussion in that... "pitch" about dosage limits. 'It sooths you. Rub it on. Rub on some more...'

I wondered. And more recently, I finally started seeing reporting of downsides -- although I didn't see much. Liver toxicity.

Like so many other drugs/supplements (choose your word), a lot of harm to reputation and perhaps also people is done, when no work or discussion is included about effective and safe dosage.

Like the "self-taught" herbalist my acupuncture friend had a (non-romantic) "thing" for, years ago. "Intuitively" brewing up pots of herbal tea for people, in his home. Not wanting to disappoint her, nor offend him, I drank some. And felt like crap for two days. Thank goodness my liver made it through unscathed.

I don't want the FDA shutting down everything on behalf of the pharmaceutical companies (who've played their significant roles in side-lining a lot of effective but unprofitable -- for them -- treatment). But I would welcome more intelligent conversation about and thoughtful approach to these things.

--

1. PBS == Public Broadcasting System, i.e. publicly funded television, in the U.S. That's been taking on more and more commercial tinges, in return for corporate sponsorships, as the public money has fallen short.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by Portlande on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:42PM (#17646354)
Just FYI Herbal teas generally don't contain tea (camellia sinensis) and likely don't contain L-theanine as a result.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by pasbesoin on Monday July 30, 2018 @03:09PM (#17647080)
Thank you. No, I wasn't thinking of "herbal tea" in that sense. Not of L-theanine.

Rather, of people promoting [product] without having real knowledge of it, including appropriate application and dosage.

This would be more in the vein of traditional Chinese medicine. Only, "intuitively", without the normal training and basis in extensive empirical observation condensed into an effective curriculum, apprenticeship, or similar proven method of conveyance.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by pmoriarty on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:25PM (#17645638)
"L-theanine is a structural analog of L-glutamate and L-glutamine"

Does that mean that you could get the same effect from consuming MSG?

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by dp-tyvek on Monday July 30, 2018 @03:01PM (#17647021)
Glutamate doesn't have any psychoactive effects because it doesn't cross the blood-brain barrier (to a significant extent). You are correct that theanine and glutamate in theory should have a similar effect on receptors, but receptor activity is only half the story. Other factors like transport and metabolism are important too. For example amphetamine and phenethylamine are structurally very similar, but will have a vastly different effect on your body.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by amelius on Monday July 30, 2018 @03:05PM (#17647046)
> L-theanine is a structural analog of L-glutamate and L-glutamine

Interesting. I've tried L-glutamine, also several times at common dosages, and it makes me feel strange, like calm on the one hand, while edgy on the other hand. It's difficult to explain, but my voice felt calmer and my ears felt more anxious. I first thought the product I bought was contaminated, so I tried two more brands, with the same effect.

One thing is for sure: L-glutamine has much more effect on me than L-theanine (which basically does nothing).

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by chillingeffect on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:03PM (#17645441)
interesting. theanine makes me very frustrated when i take it. ive dialed down the dose a few times, but stil get irritated. your explanation if helpful.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by pasbesoin on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:20PM (#17645604)
And this reminds me of trying Zoloft and a couple of other things.

15 - 30 minutes into one starter dose, and I felt terribly worse.

No professional explanation. It was only years later, when I ran across reporting about serotonin poisoning, that I had a possible explanation. The symptoms certainly fit.

A friend has used Zoloft for years, to what she feels is positive effect. And in many ways, we are fairly similar -- certainly, our psychological profiles align substantially.

Nonetheless, what works for her, does not for me at all.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by bloopernova on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:36PM (#17646312)
Serotonin syndrome is nasty, nasty, and more nasty.

I've experienced it once, after a particularly incompetent new pain management doctor made me try a cocktail of anti-depressants for pain relief. (their reasoning being that "it's all in your head"). I felt utterly awful, pulse racing, severe anxiety and horrible mixing of panic and terror.

It's imperative that people on multiple medications take Serotonin Syndrome very, very seriously. I'm very sorry you experienced it, I wouldn't wish it upon anyone.

(The pain management doctor was fired a couple of months later by the university hospital. Complaints from patients, nurses, pharmacists and insurers had been mounting.)

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by ceedan on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:48PM (#17646924)
I occasionally have the same experience when taking melatonin. It's bizarre.

I'd say 10-20% of the time that I take it, I am unable to fall asleep and don't become tired. The longer I stay away, I feel incredibly restless and twitchy to the point of actual anger. I'll lie awake in bed until 5 or 6 AM (after taking melatonin at 11pm or midnight). It gets to the point where I feel like I need to do some kind of physical activity in order to relax. My eyes and chest often feel heavy but my legs are tense, restless and twitch.

Sure seems like Restless Leg Syndrome just from proof reading this. Based on my first look into RLS just now, there could be a link to low Vitamin B, which could be triggered from a Saturday of drinking and then expecting melatonin on Sunday to set me up for a productive Monday.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by godelski on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:35PM (#17649221)
How much are you taking? Melatonin actually is better in small dosages, at least for sleep. I get the 5mg tablets and then nibble on them. I don't take it every night, but one of those tablets will last me like 4 or 5 nights. High dosages (like 2+mg) are supposed to have nootropic effects that don't make you tired. I know I've never fallen asleep with a 5mg dose. Also, light really kills the effectiveness too. If you need to watch TV or be on your computer then turn all your other lights off and turn the brightness way down.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by tempestn on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:26AM (#17650535)
See if you can get it in liquid form. I have a bottle with a dropper; each drop contains 120 micrograms. (So 8.5 drops is 1mg.) I don't use it very often, but if I have to wake up unusually early I'll take 2-3 drops around 20 minutes before bed, and it definitely helps make me sleepy when I'd normally still be awake.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by godelski on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:18PM (#17655626)
That sounds great. I usually use it when my sleeping schedule gets messed up, either from travel or my natural drift. So that sounds perfect. Thanks!
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by ceedan on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @09:14AM (#17652846)
Didn't know it came in liquid & at doses that low, thanks
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by ceedan on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @09:12AM (#17652834)
5mg, sometimes I take a whole one, break in half or nibble. I'm not sure which amount I've taken when I get restless. That could play into it
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by PascLeRasc on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @10:24AM (#17653366)
This happens to me if I take my melatonin gummies and then try to do something like laundry or dishes, instead of going right to bed after. It's a lot harder to get to sleep so I just take them right before I know I'm going to bed and that helps my sleep quality quite a bit.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by mirimir on Monday July 30, 2018 @05:05PM (#17648020)
I'm not sure that "frustrated" is quite it for me. But I much prefer coffee to tea. After enough sleep, I feel sharp and energetic after coffee. However, with too much coffee, or after poor sleep, I get nervous and unproductive.

But with tea, I just get nervous and irritable. Maybe weaker tea would be better. Or green tea, rather than fermented. Yes?

For what it's worth, I've been diagnosed bipolar, and take modafinil. So perhaps I respond atypically to caffeine vs L-theanine.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by polskibus on Monday July 30, 2018 @03:20PM (#17647172)
what do you mean about liver toxicity? Is L-theanine toxic to the liver?
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by akiselev on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:26AM (#17653930)
Yes, in large enough quantities over a long enough time period. The chances of "overdosing" on it are almost zero but the long term stress on your liver can contribute to liver disease. Your liver is basically the toxic chemical treatment plant for your body, taking care of all the things that are too small for the immune system. This includes storing excess amino acids and filtering out poison like alcohol. All that bad (and excess good) stuff, takes work to clear out and the more work your liver does, the higher the risks of cancer and other diseases because more work means more chemical activity, cellular regeneration, and so on.

I wouldn't worry about it unless you're taking tons of supplements every day by the handful or if you're a heavy drinker. However, do get physicals at least once a year with a liver panel that can track if your liver starts to degrade. Liver disease is generally a slowly developing chronic condition tied to lifestyle so you can usually right the ship if you're mindful of the risks.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by com2kid on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:57AM (#17645377)
Did you take it on its own? Almost no effect for many people if taken solo.

Take it with a cup of coffee and the caffeine boost lasts longer and is much smoother.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by nkozyra on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:28PM (#17645658)
Anecdotally, I noticed a super mild effect. I drink between 8-10 cups of coffee a day and if I hit that upper limit it dulls the anxiety but not in any pronounced way.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by komali2 on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:47PM (#17645834)
>8-10 cups of coffee a day

Is this... Safe? I mean, if I told me dentist this she would slap me, let alone my cardiologist.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by kpil on Monday July 30, 2018 @04:36PM (#17647788)
Yes probably. I think the warning against coffee haven't really been based on anything else than "common sense" and possibly that it's a recreational drug.

Maybe it's border line if you already have arrhythmia, but recent studies seems to show positive effects up to that limit, and it doesn't seem to cause arrhythmia.

Might upset your stomach though, but I'm pretty sure your dentist will be happy to polish your teeth for a modest price...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26394673?otool=karolib&t...

There seems to be several positive effects on breast cancer , diabetes, Parkinsons, ms, and stroke.

https://breast-cancer-research.biomedcentral.com/articles/10...

Etc...

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by X6S1x6Okd1st on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:42PM (#17646878)
In the metaanalysises that I've glanced over 8 cups is on the high end, but doesn't seem to negatively affect mortality.

One of them: https://academic.oup.com/aje/article/180/8/763/2739131

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by nkozyra on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:12PM (#17646082)
Probably not, frankly. That said, the body will acclimate.

I'm past the "beneficial" range of caffeine consumption, though.

Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by cryoshon on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:48PM (#17645843)
from one caffieneist to another, you may want to cut your consumption in half. at minimum, it saves on bean costs.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by muterad_murilax on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:49PM (#17646426)
Are those ~2.5 dl cups?
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by kup0 on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:41PM (#17646864)
I've used it before job interviews and it kept me much less anxious throughout.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by colecut on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:25AM (#17645056)
Out of curiosity, do you ever take it on its own, or always with caffeine?
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by thrownblown on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:26PM (#17646218)
i'm almost always drinking coffee. so probably not.
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by gameswithgo on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:25AM (#17645061)
how many watts/kg though?
Re:L-theanine, a constituent in tea, and its effect on menta... by thrownblown on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:29PM (#17646243)
i do track sprinting, so like 7-20 depending on the event