News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:58PM (#17606626)
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by kev009 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:48AM (#17606965)
These seem pretty insane, you'd be better off with two POWER9s in just about any dimension including cost, TDP, thread count, cache, memory bandwidth, I/O bandwidth including PCIe lanes, FLOPS and integer performance.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by mkj on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:54AM (#17607340)
The power9 chips don't have gigs of memory locally attached do they? Knights Mill has 16G/socket it looks like.

Knights Mill without an apostrophe - Mill is a verb?

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by kev009 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @03:02AM (#17607366)
With CAPI (cache coherent interconnect) I don't see why you couldn't do this in a more open way. i.e. optane, HBM2, whatever comes next
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by dragonwriter on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:49PM (#17612684)
> Mill is a verb?

It is, in fact, though that's not where the name comes from. (The verb for the actions a mill performs is also “mill”.)

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by kps on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:17AM (#17609388)
The naming convention came from places, starting with Knights Ferry, CA.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:40PM (#17612602)
> Mill is a verb?

In English, you can verb anything.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:54PM (#17612709)
Not sure about that. The local HBM is pretty cool and these parts are priced in the 3K range. With the added benefit of virtualization in the newest generation, they can be used as a general purpose machine. A 22-core POWER9 costs about 2500, but doesn't come with 16GB of HBM in the package. You get 88 faster threads against 288 slower ones.

I'd love to be able to justify a POWER workstation for me, but the implicit guarantees of a x86-compatible machine is too important to ignore (for my workloads).

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by acqq on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:51AM (#17607140)
Can you please elaborate? How do you come to such a conclusion? I'd like to read some realistic comparison which would demonstrate the results in both cases, compared to the power consumed.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by kev009 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:58AM (#17607358)
You can validate pricing on https://www.raptorcs.com/content/base/products.html. I am one of the first buyers with a dual 22 core system, so I'd be happy to run any numeric benchmarks if people have ideas.

Basically you get 88 threads per socket, generally will have "bonus cache" (this is a 24-core die so you get free cache if the fused off cores are not adjacent) so 120MB per socket, much higher clock speed, rediculous I/O bandwidth to PCIe 4.0, CAPI and NVLink. The speeds and feeds are simply higher than anything intel has been able to muster to market.

If you have enough volume, getting the La Grange POWER9 CPU Google and Rackspace are using would be even better than the Sforza Raptor's Talos II uses -- that gets you 8 DDR4 channels. I know basic pricing rumors and it is good.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by keldaris on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @08:39AM (#17608769)
If you get some free time to run benchmarks, the Phoronix open benchmark suite (OpenBenchmarking.org) or even just basic LINPACK would be a great start. There's such a lack of public hard data on these systems it's hard to evaluate where they stand in terms of cost/performance even for very standard workstation/HPC workloads.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by dragontamer on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:39PM (#17610597)
HPCG seems more realistic than Linpack.

Based on the Phoronix tests I've seen, AMD EPYC or AMD Threadripper is better for cost / performance.

But Xeon Phi is an accelerator over PCIe. Its more comparable to a NVidia Tesla V100. You write specialized software to run on the Xeon Phi (even though it shares the x86 instruction set, its architecture is alien so it requires the programmer to specifically optimize for the Phi platform).

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:42PM (#17612625)
> But Xeon Phi is an accelerator over PCIe.

It used to be that way, but those products were discontinued. Modern Phi's are CPUs that can operate without a host computer.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by imtringued on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:02AM (#17609795)
I'm not sure why you are comparing them on a threads per socket basis.

Each Xeon Phi core has 4 threads which results in 288 threads per socket. [1]

At those core counts you are often no longer limited by the CPU. Memory bandwidth starts playing a more significant role which is why the Xeon Phi also has 16GB of high bandwidth memory with more than 400GB/s. Does the Power9 system use a similar memory technology?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeon_Phi#Knights_Mill

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by dragontamer on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:38PM (#17610584)
Power9 is cool, but its really not comparable. Power9 has a huge L3 cache, 10MB every 2 cores. So a 22-core machine would have 110 MB of L3 cache.

In contrast, Xeon Phi is connected to HBM2 / Stacked Memory. So while it doesn't have as large of an L3 cache, its main-memory is significantly faster.

Finally, you can stick a Xeon Phi into each PCIe x16 slot of your servers. Really, Xeon Phi is a competitor to NVidia's Tesla V100, if anything.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by shaklee3 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:17AM (#17608992)
I'd be curious to see the standard memory bandwidth tests that anandtech does. I can't find anything about that online. They claim to have higher bw than Intel and AMD, but that will depend on how many threads are running.

https://www.cs.virginia.edu/stream/

I'm fairly certain it won't perform very well as-written unless the compiler is mature and translates to simd.

Btw, we met at the dpdk conference.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by ksec on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @05:57AM (#17608085)
Do you know if SuperMicro are going to have any POWER9 systems? ( I think they had announcement but there are no information on their webpages )

Given the insane amount of bandwidth, I wonder if Netflix will use this for their Open Appliance.

If we are sticking to x86 it looks like we have to wait till Zen3 from AMD to get something equivalent, that is 2019 or 2020.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by dragontamer on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:09PM (#17610898)
Wait, what's wrong with EPYC?

EPYC 7601P is 32-cores for roughly $2200 or so. And unlike Power9, the motherboard is "only" $550 or so (Power9's cheapest motherboard is like $1000 from Raptor Talos II Lite).

From what I've seen, EPYC roughly has the same Monero-mining speeds as Power9. All other benchmarks are in favor of EPYC, as x86 optimized code (Z-lib, H264, Apache, Postgres... etc. etc.) doesn't perform as well on Power9.

Power9 scales higher, but that gets cost-prohibitive. I think the typical person will only buy computers that cost less than $15,000 (Dual EPYC 7601 / SuperMicro system / 256GB of RAM)

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @07:51PM (#17613982)
There's nothing wrong with it, as much as there is nothing wrong with plain Xeon. My thing with them is that they are boring - they look too much like the computer I use to work. In order to be inspiring, you don't need only fast. You need different. POWER is different in the sense it has both the fast cores and threads of a Xeon, but coupled to a different ISA and things like NVLink. Phi is different because of the integrated HBM and the crazy number of threads. Both invite us to build applications differently and that's what makes them exciting.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by CyberDildonics on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @09:31AM (#17609076)
Each Phi core can do two 512 bit SIMD operations per cycle.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:08PM (#17606663)
For deep learning applications, not general HPC (at least, from what I understand).

Is anyone actually using these and finding them better than GPUs?

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by desertrider12 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:02AM (#17606820)
NERSC's Cori machine is the biggest machine of Knight's Landing (10,000 nodes), 10th on TOP500. Don't know of any planned Knight's Mill machines.

Generally, Xeon Phis get fewer FLOPs than GPUs but are better at certain tasks, e.g. graph algorithms with lots of divergent control flow. Also it's possible to run pure MPI programs on them and get decent performance, and there's a lot of pure-MPI HPC software out there.

Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by wickberg on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:07AM (#17607178)
In terms of KNL deployments, LANL's Trinity system (#9 on June 2018) is slightly larger. Trinity has 9,984 KNL nodes, vs 9,688 in Cori.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by desertrider12 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:37AM (#17609569)
Yep, I missed that one.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:55PM (#17606803)
Both have AVX512 with, AFAIK, similar performance. The Knights Mill ones may have some extra extensions for lower precision floating point vector ops. The newer ones also have much better IO capabilities and virtualization.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by martinpw on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:09AM (#17606847)
Knights Mill has only half the double precision performance of KNL. So not really a successor, more heading off in a different direction.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by Uberphallus on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:26AM (#17607699)
I hate how the "Deep Learning optimized" actually means "you don't really need all that precision in the activation function of your neurons anyway".
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by jarym on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @08:25AM (#17608691)
Isn't that what all optimisation is about? Making trade-offs of one kind or another - usually ditching stuff you can do without for stuff you'd like more of.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by rbanffy on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:44PM (#17612646)
I'd be perfectly fine with analog operations all the way to the final readout. Neurons are analog after all.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by eksu on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:53AM (#17607142)
Intel has GHC (Haskell) running on these in-house if I recall correctly.
Re:Intel Begins EOL Plan for Xeon Phi 7200-Series ‘Knights L... by wyldfire on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:18AM (#17609919)
I think Phi is targeted at workloads like scientific fortran applications that no one could be bothered to redesign to take advantage of OCL/etc style programming models. They're 'better' than GPUs in that you can still use x86 and you're not stuck between the current choices: abusive-market-leader and low-quality-deliverables.