News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:51PM (#17603883)
Chang seems to be conflating two visions of economics: one vision of economics that says how things are, and one vision that says how things should be. There's a lot of overlap, of course, but one is economic theory and one is political theory. In the former, there are well studied areas of economics where we have consensus for cause and effect[0][1][2][3]. To just point to areas of disagreement and say the whole field is bad reminds of those who point to disagreement on abiogenesis and say evolution is wrong. Not to say that agreement indicates correctness, but disagreement doesn't indicate that everyone doing research is wrong.

The article's other problem with economics seems to be that it assumes people are unfeeling, which is a fair criticism but not one that is particularly new. There is a field called Behavioral Economics which tries to address this and is on the radar of pretty much every economist[4].

The problem I think is more that economics never reaches people directly but is filtered through politics. I was reading on Bradford DeLong's blog the story of Mankiw, who is a respected economist but worked for the Bush administration, where he felt he had to be silent about incorrect economic theory but he could influence them in small ways to be better on economics, effectively trading truth and reputation for a small amount of power[5].

[0]: http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/steel-and-aluminum-tariffs

[1]: http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/supplemental-nutritional-a...

[2]: http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/missing-productivity-growt...

[3]: http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/immigration

[4]: http://www.igmchicago.org/surveys/behavioral-economics-2

[5]: http://www.bradford-delong.com/2018/07/hoisted-from-the-2007...

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by emodendroket on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:00PM (#17604888)
Doesn't it seem like a problem that all your sources for broad consensus are from the same outfit?

I'm also not sure how closely you read the review if you don't think Chang talks about behavioral economics: "Those nine schools are Austrian, Behaviourist, Classical, Developmentalist, Institutionalist, Keynesian, Marxist, Neoclassical and Schumpeterian."

One also wonders how likely it is that Ha-Joon Chang, who has a pretty solid list of mainstream credentials (c.f. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ha-Joon_Chang), is really as confused about the claims of mainstream economics as you seem to imply.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:19PM (#17605030)
No, it doesn't seem like a problem, because I was only pointing out that consensus exists, which is an obvious statement. You can google any of these and confirm that economists agree on effectiveness of tariffs, but none of the other sources I've seen are as mainstream or as accessible as IGM.

He doesn't talk about behavioral economics, he talks about a behaviourist school of thought, which I think is a concept only he believes in. That's like describing plant biology as a plantist school of thought separate from the animist school of thought. As I've already shown, behavioral economics as a general concept has nearly universal buy-in from economists, so it makes no sense to describe it as a school of thought.

This also marks him as solidly heterodox if he uses language that nobody else uses.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by f00_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:04PM (#17605337)
the consensus is "uncertain" for [2], some of the questions don't make sense or are really vague. Behavioral economics is all about critique of the rational actor in rational expectations theory, I think that fits in with critique of neoclassical theory as too mathematized and unrealistic

the categorization is arbitary, even if you think it's heterodox. he's communicating to a general audience

have you read chang's kicking away the ladder? much more specialized if that's you're thing, with historical data

>In this provocative study, Ha-Joon Chang examines the great pressure on developing countries from the developed world to adopt certain 'good policies' and 'good institutions', seen today as necessary for economic development. His conclusions are compelling and disturbing: that developed countries are attempting to 'kick away the ladder' with which they have climbed to the top, thereby preventing developing countries from adopting policies and institutions that they themselves have used.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:30PM (#17605470)
You seem adamant to discredit specific examples of consensus when there are plenty of examples. Go down the list on IGM and find another one if you wish.

I'm not here to criticize Chang's works, I'm here to criticize the article, which focuses on critiques of economics in general. Those critiques seem to fall into two categories:

1. economists have political schools of thought and disagree on many things

2. economists assume that people are rational

I do not think that these are valid reasons to disregard economics as an area of research and I have responded to these points as much I am willing to do so. I am concerned that many people (such as those that you can see all over in this comment section) have an agenda of discrediting economics in order to support their own political agenda when the facts disagree with their agenda. An example of this when people advocate that lowering taxes will raise revenues. This is not a political difference, this is a disagreement with well researched observations about the world.

I am here to point out that there are factual sides of economics where we have high consensus, and discussions around economics should take this into account, just like when any other area of research is discussed. There is a point to observing the world, discussions can be grounded in evidence, and wrong opinions exist.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by oh_sigh on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:37AM (#17606934)
Why kicking away the ladder and not pulling the ladder up? If you kick away the ladder, the lower people can just put it right back up.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by emodendroket on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @06:33AM (#17608213)
I guess in this metaphor somebody is trying to climb the ladder.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by neilwilson on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:11PM (#17604505)
We don't have consensus for cause and effect at all. What we have is a well established groupthink trying desperately to maintain its view and its power. The 2008 crash threw all of it up in the air. I'd recommend reading debunking economics to see the heterodox viewpoint. Essentially there is no value free economics. That a marketing pitch for a set of values. There is only political economy.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:53PM (#17605872)
Clarifying, Debunking Economics is a book by economist Steve Keen.

Excellent and highly recommended.

https://www.worldcat.org/title/debunking-economics-the-naked...

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by astine on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:19PM (#17605038)
Economics is an evolving field of study like any other. There are many different schools of thought even within the 'mainstream' position. Using disagreements and changes within the field as an argument that the entire field is flawed is what climate change deniers use when they want to dismiss evidence of climate change. There is room for disagreement on policy without dismissal of the entire field.

Besides, which heterodox viewpoint are you going to argue for? The Marxist? Austrian? Both of these are more clearly 'marketing pitches for a set values' than 'mainstream' economics. If an excessive emphasis on the free market is a pet-peeve of yours then you certainly don't want the latter.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by f00_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:09PM (#17605361)
it's not an exact science in the same way physics or chemistry were. by the arguments of market fundamentalists/etc you'd think they think economics is a deductive science

part of his whole thing is that economics isn't something too complicated for the average person to understand. too much mathiness and touted as an absolute certain science

>The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed, the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influences, are usually slaves of some defunct economist.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by j88439h84 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:42PM (#17606106)
> it's not an exact science in the same way physics or chemistry were

Can you explain the difference between an "exact science" and the other thing?

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:36AM (#17607276)
I think sciences should really be classified on degree of complexity of the phenomena they're dealing with.

Physics is a simple science. It studies the most basic of phenomena, and can isolate them pretty well for experiments. Chemistry is a more difficult science, biology even more so - at each step the phenomena get an order of magnitude more complex (in computational sense), and thus more difficult to study. Then there's psychology, social sciences and economics - all of which are even more complex, as they no longer deal with lots of simple machines, but results of sentient minds interacting in the complex world.

Point being, the "softer" a science is, the more difficult it is. That the "hard" sciences spawn so clear predictions and mathematical models is a consequence of their simplicity. The proper approach here is humility - economics and social sciences are so difficult that we barely begun to figure anything out. That's also why there's so much bullshit in "soft" sciences - they're so difficult that you can plausibly say almost anything, and it's hard to tell if you're wrong, or how much.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @10:20AM (#17609426)
I don't think that's true at all. Pharmacology is a very difficult science that we get wrong all the time, yet we still have medicine because we are able to test our medicines by trying them on animals and people. Likewise in economics and sociology and astrophysics we are able to test through natural experiments. A test of a model is its ability to predict. We don't accept untested models just because they're "complicated".

And sure, maybe you believe that economics has more untested models, but that doesn't mean there aren't many tested models in economics.

Edit: reply button is locked out for some reason so replying here.

>And look at how much it costs, how unreliable the results are, and how even after full batch of successful trials, we have no clue why a drug works.

And yet we still do solid pharmacology that results in reliable medicine, just like we can do solid economics that results in models with high predictive power.

>If you take a large enough sample and apply enough statistics to it, you can see something that looks sort of like evidence to your hypothesis. In the end, you're not much closer to knowing why it happens (and why it happens only some percentage of the time). Compare that to hard sciences, where most of the time, you can design experiments based on first principles, and you can connect the results back to fundamental theories through a string of formal math.

The idea of statistical approximation does not distinguish between controlled experiments and observational study at all. We were able to statistically model the relationship between speed and energy before we could explain gravity, i.e. we were able to figure something out before we could explain why. And most experiments in physics resulted in approximation, such as newtonian physics, that works well enough at low speeds but breaks down at high speeds. Our current model of gravity was made in the 1970s, yet before 1970 we could explain that when you jump you fall to the earth. The fact that approximation is used is not remarkable in the slightest. That's what modeling is. A model that is too complicated is useless, a model that is too simple is inaccurate. All models are approximations to some level.

>Again, "tested" in physics vs. "tested" in economics are apples-to-oranges.

Yeah, that's why newton discovered relativity, right? No, we have areas of clear evidence and areas outside of our ability to measure for every field. Just becomes some areas of a field are difficult doesn't mean every area is difficult. Just because we couldn't model what happens to a ball thrown at 0.9c in the 1700s, doesn't mean we couldn't model a ball thrown at 0.9 m/s.

>Ultimately, my main point is that economics is so hard that even our best results are pretty bad, and marginally useful.

Look on the IGM site for policy recommendations that we have clear economic consensus on. ]If a country chooses to ignore economics, e.g. zimbabwe and greece, the results are very predictable.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:37AM (#17610070)
> Pharmacology is a very difficult science that we get wrong all the time, yet we still have medicine because we are able to test our medicines by trying them on animals and people.

And look at how much it costs, how unreliable the results are, and how even after full batch of successful trials, we have no clue why a drug works. This is because medicine, as a practical ofshoot of biology, is a field so complex, it defies reasoning from first principles. We don't have a full model of how things work, so we rely on the "shotgun approach" - statistics.

Same thing happens in psychology, sociology and economics. If you take a large enough sample and apply enough statistics to it, you can see something that looks sort of like evidence to your hypothesis. In the end, you're not much closer to knowing why it happens (and why it happens only some percentage of the time).

Compare that to hard sciences, where most of the time, you can design experiments based on first principles, and you can connect the results back to fundamental theories through a string of formal math.

> A test of a model is its ability to predict.

That I 100% agree with. And it reinforces my point. Hard sciences gives you models you can rely on. Soft sciences don't. Not because they are full of dumb people, but because the problem domains of soft sciences are orders of magnitude more complex than those of hard sciences, and all your models end up being crude approximations.

> And sure, maybe you believe that economics has more untested models, but that doesn't mean there aren't many tested models in economics.

Again, "tested" in physics vs. "tested" in economics are apples-to-oranges.

Ultimately, my main point is that economics is so hard that even our best results are pretty bad, and marginally useful.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:29PM (#17610493)
Reply button has reappeared so copying my response here for proper flow, but now I can't remove it from my other comment because the edit button disappeared.

>And look at how much it costs, how unreliable the results are, and how even after full batch of successful trials, we have no clue why a drug works.

And yet we still do solid pharmacology that results in reliable medicine, just like we can do solid economics that results in models with high predictive power.

>If you take a large enough sample and apply enough statistics to it, you can see something that looks sort of like evidence to your hypothesis. In the end, you're not much closer to knowing why it happens (and why it happens only some percentage of the time). Compare that to hard sciences, where most of the time, you can design experiments based on first principles, and you can connect the results back to fundamental theories through a string of formal math.

The idea of statistical approximation does not distinguish between controlled experiments and observational study at all. We were able to statistically model the relationship between speed and energy before we could explain gravity, i.e. we were able to figure something out before we could explain why. And most experiments in physics resulted in approximation, such as newtonian physics, that works well enough at low speeds but breaks down at high speeds. Our current model of gravity was made in the 1970s, yet before 1970 we could explain that when you jump you fall to the earth. The fact that approximation is used is not remarkable in the slightest. That's what modeling is. A model that is too complicated is useless, a model that is too simple is inaccurate. All models are approximations to some level.

>Again, "tested" in physics vs. "tested" in economics are apples-to-oranges.

Yeah, that's why newton discovered relativity, right? No, we have areas of clear evidence and areas outside of our ability to measure for every field. Just becomes some areas of a field are difficult doesn't mean every area is difficult. Just because we couldn't model what happens to a ball thrown at 0.9c in the 1700s, doesn't mean we couldn't model a ball thrown at 0.9 m/s.

>Ultimately, my main point is that economics is so hard that even our best results are pretty bad, and marginally useful.

Look on the IGM site for policy recommendations that we have clear economic consensus on. ]If a country chooses to ignore economics, e.g. zimbabwe and greece, the results are very predictable.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by mcrad on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:40PM (#17611158)
> Ultimately, my main point is that economics is so hard that even our best results are pretty bad, and marginally useful.

That’s a very interesting point. Most would consider Econ a “soft science” because it is less like physical science e.g. Chemistry. Weird how people like to flip the script for some sorta political gain. Yes, in the soft sciences it is more difficult to reach conclusions as compared to fields like biology, but should we say that makes them more harder?

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:07PM (#17611395)
Ooops, I tried so much to avoid using word "hard" for multiple meanings, and I failed.

What I wanted to say is that economics is a "soft science", in the same sense physics is "hard science". Also, that economics is a difficult science dealing with complex phenomena, in the same sense that physics is an easy science dealing with simple phenomena.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by mcrad on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:02PM (#17606204)
Real science involves experiments and therefore proof of causality.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:26PM (#17606293)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experimental_economics

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Econometrics

Which is a moot point because science is done without controlled experiments all of the time, e.g. astrophysics, epidemiology, sociology. One of the most famous cases in medicine is the connection of drinking water to cholera discovered using observation to connect deaths to a nearby well.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by mcrad on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:25PM (#17611042)
Well it’s great that they do more than just design experiments and hack p-vales all day;) Geez, had no idea it was such a controversial statement. What do you want to say, every application of math or coding counts as science? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_and_soft_science
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by koube on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:43PM (#17611183)
Whether something is a "real science" is based on whether or not science is done, not the difficulty of the subject matter. Spending so much time trying to narrowly semanticize science in a way that specifically excludes economics is navel gazing. The purpose of these discussions seems to be to discredit economics and discount it's predictive power by defining it as not-science, but predictive power doesn't come from the definition of the word science, it comes from the statistical methods that science uses.

Does it involve research? Does the research produce models with predictive power? Ok, let's use it, just like every policy maker in the world pre-2016.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by barry-cotter on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:46PM (#17606582)
Epidemiology, ecology, astronomy, cosmology, botany, zoology and geology obviously don’t count as sciences then.

And you have no idea how much effort goes into randomised controlled trials and the search for good natural experiments and instrumental variables to answer economic questions, to say nothing of the actual experiments in economics done every time a price is changed or a new product appears. There is a ton of data in microeconomics. It may be hard to use and, ill fitted to the question you want to answer and difficult to get but there’s lots of data.

Macroeconomics has many fewer data points and you can’t really perform experiments but even macro, for all the pointless math worship has made progress.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by mcrad on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @01:15PM (#17610947)
Counterpoints notwithstanding, Economics and other social sciences should be considered distinct from the more traditional fields of science that are rooted in clear cause-and-effect as demonstrated by controlled experts. You have no idea lol, obviously.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by dang on Friday July 27, 2018 @03:38AM (#17624181)
Personal swipes will get you banned here. Please don't post like this again.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by imbokodo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:36PM (#17604693)
> one is economic theory and one is political theory

It is an absurd notion that there are two manners of discussing how the pie should be divided up - one objective, scientific, fair-minded etc., and one "political". Obviously it is all political.

As it was originally called - political economy. The term economics was promoted by Alfred Marshall, one of the most political of those focused on the economy.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by astine on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:45PM (#17604766)
"It is an absurd notion that there are two manners of discussing how the pie should be divided up"

There is absolutely a difference between normative and positive statements about the world. Arguing whether raising taxes will lower middle class wages is a different question from whether one should raise taxes.One is a question of facts and the other is a questions of values. This distinction holds no matter what field you are discussing; it's just the field of economics where people seem to insist on blurring the two.

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by emodendroket on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:05PM (#17604927)
I think it is worth pointing out that often we don't actually know the answer, or are getting results interpreted through politically motivated lenses, and so even seemingly descriptive statements about the economy are often secretly normative ones.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by f00_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:15PM (#17605392)
I don't think there is such a clear distinction between fact and values ala Hume’s conception of a "matter of fact" or Kant’s distinction between analytic and synthetic judgments.

economics isn't a deductive science. i prefer Keynes' irreducable uncertainty as a principle of policy. we can't predict the future, we don't how policy is going to act out. the future won't look like the past. the chicago school's knightian uncertainty is the supply side of the same coin

there are flaws in the logical positive approach, see pragmatists like john dewey, hilary putnam, or richard rorty: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLJfEVu3kbY

Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by astine on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:03PM (#17606408)
Dewey's objection to the fact/value dichotomy is more against the notion that facts cannot be used to drive value judgments, not to the notion that value judgments should not be used to derive facts, which is mainly what I'm referring to here.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by sjg007 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @02:31AM (#17607254)
Economics is the study of what governments should do. Like all opinions, some are more true than others.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by pg_bot on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @03:22AM (#17607454)
Economics is the study of how individuals, firms, and society make decisions to allocate limited resources to many competing wants.
Re:Economics: The User's Guide by Ha-Joon Chang by nerdponx on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:42PM (#17604266)
Chang seems to be conflating two visions of economics: one vision of economics that says how things are, and one vision that says how things should be.

This unfortunately is what a lot of people learn in economics courses and pop economics books.