I don't see how telling Google not to force itself as the default preinstalled option on phones is an "assault on open source".
> the fact the linux didn't attaint mainstream appeal on the desktop was largely due to the lack of condition and harmonization across distros
Not sure what "condition and harmonization is", but if you mean the poor UI for normal people, then yes. I don't see the relevance of this to Google forcing itself onto people's phones.
> and the EU wants to doom android to the same fate.
It was literally a few days ago when I was wondering to myself how people were cool with Google search etc. coming preinstalled. I had no idea the EU was looking into this. As a result I don't have any reason to believe their goal is anything but fair competition.
Considering the cause of the fine is all of the non-open source bits Google adds on, I don't see how one can make a statement like that with a straight face.
"In any other context fining an open source project for antitrust violations is absurd."
They didn't fine the Android Open Source Project. They fined Google.
Or sell a device using only some of the things Google wants to make mandatory, but replacing others with their own.
That way they keep AOSP-based products on the fringe, since only niche manufacturers can afford to make them, and stop manufacturers trying to make/integrate better replacements for Google services. That's anti-competitive, that's the problem.
Probably what Pichai is talking about is charging a fee for Google Play Services, not AOSP. Although if they did decide to proprietize all future development work on AOSP, it would be interesting to see how the community would respond. It's possible we'd see a major fork and a revitalization of community work a la Linux, instead of the little garage forks we mostly have today.
The core of Android may be open source, but between so many API's being shoved into Google Play Services and AOSP apps being all but abandoned the writing is on the wall.
Hah! You basically want to destroy the blogosphere (oh, how I detest that term).
They're not fining ASOP, and Android is a nonfree OS.
And if we were to take the existence of AOSP into consideration then this fine seems even more ridicules and unwarranted.
Charging manufacturers for using the operating system you built is a healthy business practice. "Giving it away" and building in dozens of tracking mechanisms is hardly ethical.
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2013/10/googles-iron-grip-on...
I wish these bloggers would keep their biases and unsubstantiated commentary to themselves.
This fine is an assault on open source, the fact linux didn't attain mainstream appeal on the desktop was largely due to the lack of condition and harmonization across distros.
In any other context fining an open source project for antitrust violations is absurd.