The next best alternative to a PhD in physics is job as a quant at a hedge fund, a programmer, an engineer, or something of that nature.
The next best alternative to a PhD in english lit is proofreader, copy editor or barista.
Although this is a popular idea on Hacker News, it isn't really true: there are loads of people with English degrees in law, consulting, teaching, and business.
Still, even the third choice -- teaching -- will probably pay more over a lifetime than someone who takes eight or more years to get through grad school but fails to find a tenure track job.
Disclosure: I work in tech now but have an English Lit. education.
Similarly, my ranking of jobs is Rock Star > Trader > Professor. ("Rock star" = http://www.nin.com/ , not http://imarockstarninja.com/ .) My preference for a job as a rock star is irrelevant due to my lack of skills, so I'm forced to choose between trader and professor.
A: women are excluded from science.
B: no, women choose not to enter science because they are smart enough to realise there are better paid jobs in law and medicine
C: but women enter fields (like your example of "Womens Herstory") which clearly aren't moneyspinners, so you could ask why do they enter those unprofitable fields rather than unprofitable science?
You: Because women make stupid educational and career choices that limits their money making potential.
Me: The original argument advanced by B, is that the lack of women in science is explained by their smart educational and career choices. If you posit that many of them make stupid educational and career choices, you still haven't explained why they don't end up in underpaid science/technology roles.
Divide people into two groups, X and Y.
Group X: people with no quantitative skills. Career choices are [herstory prof, barista, teacher, HR drone].
Group Y: people with quantitative skills. Career choices are [math prof, hedge fund quant, big bank analyst, actuary, RoR Ninja].
People in category X don't make a choice between herstory prof and math prof. Math prof and quant are already excluded since person X failed Calc 2. Women in category X may choose herstory prof relatively frequently since it's not much worse than HR drone.
People in category Y do make a choice between math prof and quant. Women in category Y choose actuary relatively often, since actuary is actually a plausible career choice.
To evaluate Greenspun's argument (the argument you think I am undermining), you need to restrict consideration to category Y.
Having been both a student and teacher at MIT, my personal explanation for men going into science is the following:
1. young men strive to achieve high status among their peer group
2. men tend to lack perspective and are unable to step back and ask the question "is this peer group worth impressing?"
I'm reminded of Philip Greenspun's _Women in Science_, in which he says that smart women don't go into science because "Adjusted for IQ, quantitative skills, and working hours, jobs in science are the lowest paid in the United States." I think his analysis of problems in the structure of science as a profession is accurate but that his sex-based commentary is wrong: for one thing, women now outnumber men in liberal arts PhDs, where the job market isn't just worse for most science PhDs -- it's _way_ worse.