Re:Dear Mom and Dad: Thanks for Teaching Me Unix
by yummyfajitas on Tuesday October 05, 2010 @10:58AM
(#1759969)
No one is paying attention anymore, but I'll try to state my reasoning one more time as clearly as possible.
Divide people into two groups, X and Y.
Group X: people with no quantitative skills. Career choices are [herstory prof, barista, teacher, HR drone].
Group Y: people with quantitative skills. Career choices are [math prof, hedge fund quant, big bank analyst, actuary, RoR Ninja].
People in category X don't make a choice between herstory prof and math prof. Math prof and quant are already excluded since person X failed Calc 2. Women in category X may choose herstory prof relatively frequently since it's not much worse than HR drone.
People in category Y do make a choice between math prof and quant. Women in category Y choose actuary relatively often, since actuary is actually a plausible career choice.
To evaluate Greenspun's argument (the argument you think I am undermining), you need to restrict consideration to category Y.
Divide people into two groups, X and Y.
Group X: people with no quantitative skills. Career choices are [herstory prof, barista, teacher, HR drone].
Group Y: people with quantitative skills. Career choices are [math prof, hedge fund quant, big bank analyst, actuary, RoR Ninja].
People in category X don't make a choice between herstory prof and math prof. Math prof and quant are already excluded since person X failed Calc 2. Women in category X may choose herstory prof relatively frequently since it's not much worse than HR drone.
People in category Y do make a choice between math prof and quant. Women in category Y choose actuary relatively often, since actuary is actually a plausible career choice.
To evaluate Greenspun's argument (the argument you think I am undermining), you need to restrict consideration to category Y.