News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by PakG1 on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @10:55AM (#17507416)
This is interesting. By making things more transparent, you have obvious and measurable positive effects. Here's my question. What happens when someone moves up a social class such that they're no longer in poverty? I suppose then that they're no longer eligible for the program. How do you administrate the program so that those people are no longer given rice?

I suppose then that the lists held by the distribution centers need to be regularly updated. But then when someone is on the margin (or perhaps for everyone above the poverty line), they can have incentive to say, "Look, here's my card, I'm eligible!" Then the distribution center says, "Nope, says here that you're not poor anymore." Those disputes would need to get resolved, and I can imagine that they can get bogged down in bureaucracy. Worse still, for cases on the margin, distribution centers may have ability to let corruption decide that recipients should be ineligible when they're eligible.

I think that the idea and results are great. I'm just curious how they deal with the cases on the margin. Or does resolution just wait until the next year's income taxes get filed and everyone gets reprocessed accordingly to check for status changes?

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by dmd on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @12:49PM (#17508343)
A much cheaper way is to not care. If someone wants their Us$0.50 of rice allotment just give it to them.

Universal basic rice.

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by saalweachter on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:19PM (#17509055)
My impression with this sort of thing is that the restrictions aren't because the people administering the program are worried about cheating, but because they're worried about cratering the local agricultural economy.

If everyone is able to buy rice airdropped in by a richer government or charity for a token amount (or free), it becomes very difficult to support yourself as a local rice farmer. If only a subset of the population which was previously unable to buy a significant amount of rice is able to do so, it doesn't affect the local rice market.

The misdistribution mentioned at the beginning of the article is a worst possible case: the poorest people not given their cheap rice are unable to afford enough to eat at all; people who may be hurting but aren't the worst off get cheap or free rice instead of buying rice they might (barely) be able to afford from local rice farmers.

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by AceJohnny2 on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:41PM (#17508763)
No. "Free" has an odd effect on people.

For example they may think the item has less or no value ("Why are they just giving this to us? Are they trying to poison us?"), or think the item is unlimited.

The point isn't to recoup costs, but to make the recipients value the item.

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by Proziam on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:49PM (#17508825)
If you are struggling enough to go through the effort to try and scam the government for a small portion of free rice then I think it's obvious they value the item. Not caring about the edge cases is almost certainly the correct choice here.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by dmd on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:46PM (#17508800)
I don't mean "just give it to them" as in without cost, I mean don't disallow anyone from getting it, regardless of whether they're supposedly eligible or not.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by oh_sigh on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:56PM (#17508896)
Nope, because you will find that people will start using rice for unintended purposes like bean bags, animal food, and smuggling rice into other nations that need to pay money for rice, etc.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by dmd on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:00PM (#17508930)
... so?
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by oh_sigh on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:11PM (#17509001)
Rice isn't unlimited.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by dmd on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:15PM (#17509030)
Oh, sorry. I thought we were discussing this in good faith.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by oh_sigh on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:24PM (#17509080)
Ok, fine, rice is unlimited and your idea is great.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by mark-r on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @03:55PM (#17509825)
Reminds me of a story.

A wise man was called to solve a problem for the Emperor, and he did so. The Emperor asked what he could give him as a reward. The wise man said humbly, "I do not ask for much. I wish for a chess board with one grain of rice on the first square, two grains on the second square, four grains on the third square, and so forth." The Emperor agreed. Any idea on how the story ends?

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by oh_sigh on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @05:15PM (#17510351)
Emperor beheads the wise man for being cheeky.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by boomboomsubban on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:27PM (#17509102)
>Look, here's my card, I'm eligible!

The card doesn't tell a person that they are eligible, the card tells a person what makes them eligible for what.

The problem you're mentioning is an unrelated problem that every income based social program faces.

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by azinman2 on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @11:30AM (#17507678)
Question is, how often does that happen?

You can also send these cards yearly, and mark then as such.

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by 394549 on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @11:46AM (#17507803)
> You can also send these cards yearly, and mark then as such.

And send the village head a paper saying so-and-so is no longer eligible this year, and also post that info in the local newspaper, etc.

The system depends on common, widespread knowledge to prevent people from cheating. If it depends too much on a single proof like the postcard, it's vulnerable to forgery.

Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by frostwhale on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @12:50PM (#17508357)
I think the difference is that there are other safety nets in place to prevent people from taking too much. Those are most likely still in effect with the postcards, the only difference is people now know when they can escalate their issues with not getting rice from a local official and succeed. The local official never wants this since the official knows what the citizen is actually due and escalating the issue will confirm this. If someone is demanding too much from the local official, they will have no worries about the complaint running up the chain because they are doing their job correctly.
Re:How Postcards Solved the Problem of Disappearing Rice by fjsolwmv on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @11:36AM (#17507727)
If there are so many rich people that this becomes a concern, simply *don't worry a out it". A little free rice to a rich person is a "Cadillac problem".