News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @09:08AM (#17497686)
Meanwhile, Elon Musk is jumping up and down saying "pay attention to me! Pay attention to me!"
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by the_spacebyte on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @09:19AM (#17497779)
And what did you do to help? He was asked if he could do anything and tried.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @09:44AM (#17497985)
I didn't do anything to help- I don't think saving 12 people in a Thailand cave means a lot, globally speaking. Why do you say he was asked to do something? He offered to help. More realistically, however, he should have chosen to stay out of the way- he didn't get his device to the site until the rescue operation was already half completed. It wouldn't have worked anyway- it wasn't fit for the purpose. Getting a bunch of PR for somethign that wasn't really asked for and doesn't work seems pointless attention getting.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by codeulike on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:14AM (#17498786)
Tweet from Elon Musk in response to BBC article:

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1016684366083190785

It shows correspondance with one of the dive team, urging Musk to continue with the sub.

Other teams from other organisations were also working on similar things: https://twitter.com/Jiradett/status/1016690284619599873

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:20AM (#17498846)
wow, he really is a jerk on twitter.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by sabertoothed on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:27AM (#17498910)
Why? I found his answer appropriate.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by kadenshep on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @07:40PM (#17503175)
You think it's okay to debase the chief of the rescue operation, ignore the advice he took from multiple teams, and cherry pick a personal email correspondence with one guy that basically just says "keep trying" just so Musk can dance around, yet again, people pointing out a potential PR stunt?

I don't know what level of social ineptness is required to ignore not only the blatant insult against the chief, but Musk's presumably unintentional insult to the rest of the team that informed the chief what they thought about Musk's idea to carry a 300lb tube through volatile currents in a tight, murky cave system.

Talk about domain specialization.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dang on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @02:46AM (#17504922)
This flamewar was ridiculous all around, but your account stands out as among the worst that made it so bad. This is the kind of thing HN exists to avoid, not perpetuate, so would you please not use HN this way in the future?

As I posted elsewhere, all this angry arguing about Musk, pro or con, is as meaningful as angry arguing about Spider-Man. Since you're on the con side, I'll add that all you're doing by venting like this is feeding the very PR you deplore, by giving it your attention and attracting others into doing the same. Go for it if that's what you want—but please not here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by kadenshep on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @08:24AM (#17506291)
Please elaborate? I presented an actual perspective. You have gone around these threads and insulted and demeaned people with a different opinion than the majority and then even equivocated these criticisms to a debate about a fictional character ("You guys might as well be bickering about Spider-Man."). That's not only incredibly dishonest, you really should be ashamed to stoop to such a level publicly. Intentionally framing a debate as not important or just a "flame war" is exactly how you get mindless echo chambers. Musk is a public figure who has had substantial investment in his companies via U.S. tax dollars. He's not a Marvel character, you doughnut.

Not once have you called out people hurling personal insults towards people that have a minority opinion on this board, you've done the exact opposite.

You have implied my statements violate some aspect of HN, but you're going to need to specifically point out which statements do that. Dissent is not violation. You might not be interested in the dissent or critique but you can't use your position as moderator to quell it.

And if you're actually willing to be honest with yourself, or even devote some amount of diligent effort to pretend you're here to upload intellectual standards (despite discouraging dissenting opinions), you need to explain why blatant personal attacks are being allowed in threads you are most definitely reading.

> I'll add that all you're doing by venting like this is feeding the very PR you deplore,

Dang, that's a unsubstantiated view point and you know it. I'm honestly in shock you think that's a valid point to make (I'm not). Please explain how someone who gets public attention as a status quo is somehow actually being fueled by his critics. This talking point comes in up various contexts and is always meant to dismiss critique or even worse, victim blame. What the actual fuck are you on?

To recap since you most definitely again will side step any critique of moderating actions:

* What rules am I violating and where. A simple quote of my statement and the rule will suffice.

* Why are you framing the debate as if it's about a fictional character, when it's the CEO of a company who receives significant funding from U.S. tax payer dollars.

* How does critiquing a public figure's positive media coverage in a small thread somehow get the news to continue positive coverage?

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dang on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @01:23PM (#17508624)
It's simple: all this fever about GoodMusk vs. BadMusk has become bone-crushingly tedious. When that happens with anything, nothing can redeem it and it's off topic on Hacker News.

I definitely don't mean to pick on you personally. Dozens of HN users have been filling the threads with this lately and it needs to stop. We literally can't moderate it all, and the Elonian Provocation is large enough to be capable of swamping this site entirely.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Thursday July 12, 2018 @06:42PM (#17519231)
Hmm. I don't agree. I think we're on the turn of the tide where the hacker community and the media will stop fawning over him if we repeatedly and politely point out that he's an attention-seeking person but that doesn't mean he needs to have news coverage.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dang on Friday July 13, 2018 @01:06AM (#17520647)
I can think of at least two problems with that. One is that people don't really change their minds this way; all they do is dig their heels in and object harder. The other is that HN could be smothered under the weight of this material even while opinion is working itself to convergence. The Muskian Market can stay wrong longer than this site can stay solvent.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by kadenshep on Wednesday July 11, 2018 @10:48PM (#17511814)
>nothing can redeem it and it's off topic on Hacker News.

That seems largely contradictory to the hacker ethos, no?

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dang on Friday July 13, 2018 @01:01AM (#17520631)
It's a fair question, but the answer is no, because of the tragedy of the commons. That is, you may be right at the individual level, but it's unfortunately common for the sum total of individual effects to become something completely contrary to what any of the individuals would want. We have to manage the site at that sum-total level. This means telling people "don't do the things that produce lousy systemic effects", even though any one of those things might be fine when considered independently.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by kadenshep on Saturday July 14, 2018 @08:27PM (#17533092)
Wouldn't the correct thing to do in that case then would be to wholesale delete pro/anti musk threads that specifically revolve around him as a CEO?

Right now it seems like current moderation tactics are encouraging a "lie hard and fast" mode, so the truth can't catch up -- so to speak. Essentially the moderation policy is acting as a floodgate that only closes when perspectives that negate the "pro" side of things are brought into play.

This is apparent in what was allowed to be posted without question and in how you, intentionally or not, only replied to anti-musk threads. There were at least 4 threads, that I just looked at now at the time of this post, that were both not flagged by the community nor set straight from a moderator that were purely composed of vague personal attacks (it would have been better if they had just been forthright with it).

I understand that HN has limited resources and you clearly value the integrity of this forum, I just think certain perspectives unfairly caught your attention more than they should have.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by astine on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @10:24AM (#17498347)
"Why do you say he was asked to do something?"

The question was put to him by random people on Twitter, not by the Thai government. His initial response that he thought the Thai government had it in hand.

[dead]
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by nAwYz on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @10:31AM (#17498411)
The difference between the divers and Musk is that the divers did it without announcing their plans on Twitter. They just when there and helped. I think it's good that Musk tried to help, but the publicity he got with it makes me question his motivations. There is also no need for personal attacks
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by the_spacebyte on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @10:46AM (#17498522)
"think it's good that Musk tried to help, but the publicity he got..." If he got all that publicity, then hate the newspapers who kept giving it to him, not the guy who was just happy to help. He probably kept tweeting because that's where he first was "contacted" about the subject and had some cool photos and videos to show.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by sabertoothed on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @10:59AM (#17498642)
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by compcoffee on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:10AM (#17498739)
Is that the official Thai government, or some random person on Twitter? Just wondering.

Have you looked at Tweets directed at him? People ask him for all kinds of things.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by sabertoothed on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:13AM (#17498778)
How does it matter who the first person to ask for help is?

The later stages were coordinated with the local Thai rescue team. As proven by email exchange Elon published.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:15AM (#17498804)
The divers were highly qualified in ways the Thai military was not. That's why they were there.

BTW, I'm not a neckbeard since I shaved this morning, but really, if you resort to attacks like that, it makes you look like a jerk

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by the_spacebyte on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:45AM (#17499090)
And Musk and his team (and I believe many others) are qualified enough to present other, engineering, alternatives parallel to the main one. Why shouldn't they? Why is that seen as attention-grabbing?
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by compcoffee on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:07AM (#17498717)
>yes that's the thing you're just a neckbeard who cares shit about others and feels smug about pointing fingers on the internet

Not a hint of irony, huh?

There it is, the crazy Musk fans going full out ad-hominem, just like they did on the BI journalist. Careful OP, these people are nuts.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dang on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @05:12PM (#17502225)
Would you please stop posting obsessively about Musk? You're hardly the only one doing it, but you've been doing virtually nothing else. Single-purpose accounts aren't allowed on HN and we ban them, so please don't use the site this way.

These pro-and-anti-Musk flamewars are extremely low-quality discussion. You guys might as well be bickering about Spider-Man.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by the_spacebyte on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @11:18AM (#17498833)
Nop, not because of Elon Musk per se. I would have lost my judgment and go "ad-hominem" if it was another person as well. I just hate the argument "He's just helping for PR, while I seat my ass doing nothing"

You conveniently cut short my phrase, when quoting, just to push the argument that I'm a Musk fanboy...

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @12:15PM (#17499432)
So, this is the second time you've said I don't do anything. There is no reason to be rude. My work is in scientific reesarch, and I've worked on projects that made significant improvements to drug discovery, possibly saving millions of lives.
Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by the_spacebyte on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @01:54PM (#17500543)
"My work is in scientific reesarch..."

Good for you, but that wasn't what I meant. "Do nothing" in regards with the current situation, not in general.

Re:Thailand cave rescue: all 12 boys and coach successfully ... by dekhn on Tuesday July 10, 2018 @02:29PM (#17500876)
I said above I didn't think this was a situation where anybody should do anything. It's 12 people in a cave. In the global context, that's noise. this is just classic news turning minor events into global news.