Re:The Rise of Edible Insect Farming
by MrBuddyCasino on Thursday July 05, 2018 @02:49PM
(#17465772)
The whole idea of directly eating insects is stupid. They can be fed to animals we normally eat (e.g. fish). The advantage is that insects can process stuff that we would otherwise throw away, and are very efficient.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I do not understand how the first sentence was supported by the next two sentences. Hundreds of millions of people eat insects daily, and it seems way more efficient than using them as an intermediary food source.
I don't think that your conclusion follows from your argument. You could say the same thing about directly eating vegetables -- they can be fed to animals we normally eat (e.g., cattle).
More directly to your point, isn't there significant energy inefficiency from eating higher on the food chain?
Re:The Rise of Edible Insect Farming
by privacypoller on Thursday July 05, 2018 @03:45PM
(#17466209)
I agree with your points - each step of processing feed material leaks some of the efficiencies gained by harvesting at lower levels. Generally the benefits from chaining production come from the lower level consuming the waste products of the higher level, like fertilizing aquatic plants with fish waste.
Where insects could make a big difference is replacing more expensive or less effective inputs into higher-level products, ideally commodities. For example, if we could produce breads using crickets that have higher caloric densities for the same price that would be a huge global win. We're not there yet though.
It’s less efficient higher up the food chain. I think the point being made is a grasshopper, goats or cows can digest plants a human could never and get sustenance out of. They have different food processing stomachs
Every step up on the food chain loses roughly 90% of the energy.
If it keeps cows alive it should be good enough for humans too.
I wondering how switching to a diet of grass would work out for the average human...
As we have only one stomach and lack symbiotic bacteria that allow ruminants to digest cellulose the average human would quickly starve.