Conference that wants to be internationally inclusive, which I assume a conference in English held in Germany wants to be, should not ostracize people based on grammar technicalities.
That's just one word, but pronouns in particular differ greatly across languages. Objects can have genders, occupations can have genders, plurals can differ or be the same, etc.. Someone who is not a native speaker can easily make a mistake that is related to gender.
It's always the intent that should be taken into account, not whether someone was offended.
Sexism
Using gendered terms like “dude” or “guys” to address a
mixed-gendered group of people contributes to furthering
exclusion of underrepresented individuals. We strongly
advise avoiding gendered pronouns as well as gendered
terms.
The whole short paragraph is listed in the "please pay a little attention to this" section of the CoC under the following introduction: Inclusive language
In our commitment to a harassment-free and inclusive
environment we strongly believe it’s important to pay
attention to harmful language patterns.
It's a fair assessment. It's certainly not obvious to foreign speakers - it certainly wasn't for me - but isn't it fair to ask people to think about the words they're using? To point out common speech patterns that may make other people unwelcome and ask them to avoid them? Why not use "folks" or "people" instead of "dudes" and "guys" to refer to groups of people of all genders? Would you as a presumably male person feel included if someone refers to your group as "girls" or "ladies"? Would you prefer if people used that in their talks?Now, that this pattern has been pointed out to you, you can still feign ignorance and deliberately still use "guys" and "dudes" to refer to people that do not identify as guys and dudes but that would just make me refer to you as "boneheaded impolite dick" even though you might not identify as such.
Then we thought about what might happen when we have a violation (endless discussions about whether that was actually a real violation and whether our response was justified, maybe even within the team).
So, we sat down and wrote a slightly longer version, which tries to spell out some unwanted behaviour and some guidlines for conference stuff ( http://socrates-conference.at/code-of-conduct/ ).
We also wanted to explain why we have the CoC in the first place and how we'd like people to behave. It surely is not perfect (probably too long and too short at the same time).
But if you think "don't be a dick to other people" would suffice as a CoC, imagine you are the organizer of an event, and then try to list all the things that might go wrong. Be creative - I'm sure you can imagine situations where it does not suffice.
So if I say "well actually..." on your conference I might get escorted out even if nobody took offense, but if I race around on my skates and make people uncomfortable because they are afraid I might run into them, that's fine because it doesn't really fall under any point mentioned in your CoC?
That's obviously nonsense. Just don't be a dick. And if you are, be a dick somewhere else.
- At some point you will have to make a judgement call as a moderator, if you have no written rules every decision is a judgement call
- Someone will not like your judgement call, you then get a discussion
- To make sure you don't waste time having the same conversation again you write it down
- Rinse 'n repeat, you now have a CoC, whether you like it or not
> "Using gendered terms like “dude” or “guys” to address a mixed-gendered group of people contributes to furthering exclusion of underrepresented individuals."
The fact that they included an option to "make an anonymous" report furthers the assumption that you just got under the political wheels of the conference.