News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by dnomad on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:14AM (#17435478)
Leiter tends to take Nietzsche very literally.

Yes, Nietzsche grasped quite clearly that exceedingly few people have the courage to endure the world "in itself." Most people persist their whole lives trapped in elaborate fantasies. This is something that, Nietszche suspects, has been true since the dawn of time and recognizes it as an essential human characteristic (herd instinct).

Science causes a kind of crisis. ("God is dead.") After millenia of extreme devotion to all manner nonsense (think of the religious wars that plagued Europe) science starts asking some very uncomfortable and very pointed questions. But people will not abandon their fantasies, even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Instead they will cling to their fantasies that much harder often with full knowledge that what they "believe" are lies. This metastasizes into fascism [1]. When Trump says climate change is a Chinese hoax he knows he's lying, and you know he's lying, and accusing him of lying would be pointless and that's the point. Nietzsche foresaw quite clearly that this would be the crisis of the 20th century and beyong: in the face of science people would become more willing to deceive themselves.

What Nietzsche proposes against this isn't some tired paean to "human excellence." Leiter here gets very literal and selective here. Nietzsche does not think that art or philosophy or dance can stand against the ever rising tide of fascism. It is what motivates these things -- the will to power -- that is the only defense against self-deception. All fantasies are born of fear, a fear of change and growth and death. But there also exists in some men a desire for change and growth and death. (Indeed Nietzsche will come to believe that the will to power is a kind of cosmic necessity.) The only hope that societies have against falling to fascism is cultivating precisely this opposing force which Nietzsche understands not as some mere "will to truth" or "will to excellence" but a far more primal "will to power" that motivates men to plunge into the unknown and confront their own mortality.

[1] "In an ever-changing, incomprehensible world the masses had reached the point where they would, at the same time, believe everything and nothing, think that everything was possible and that nothing was true. ... Mass propaganda discovered that its audience was ready at all times to believe the worst, no matter how absurd, and did not particularly object to being deceived because it held every statement to be a lie anyhow. The totalitarian mass leaders based their propaganda on the correct psychological assumption that, under such conditions, one could make people believe the most fantastic statements one day, and trust that if the next day they were given irrefutable proof of their falsehood, they would take refuge in cynicism; instead of deserting the leaders who had lied to them, they would protest that they had known all along that the statement was a lie and would admire the leaders for their superior tactical cleverness.”

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by coldtea on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:37AM (#17435549)
>Science causes a kind of crisis. ("God is dead.") After millenia of extreme devotion to all manner nonsense (think of the religious wars that plagued Europe) science starts asking some very uncomfortable and very pointed questions.

There was no nonsense. Or far fewer of it than one imagines.

When the "religious wars" weren't using religious directly as a thin pretext for "let's grab their land", they were about ways to live.

Religion in those days was what lifestyle (or national preferences) are today, and it was used a proxy for that and for defining a national/cultural group (the role that later was played by nations), not for mere theological differences.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by 101km on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:06AM (#17435650)
I think a distinction is in order between elites who pretended to be pious and the true believers they ruled over.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by coldtea on Sunday July 01, 2018 @11:15AM (#17435891)
The population wasn't much more "true believers", in letting religion dictate such things, than the average person today. It was just part of their culture.

The role of the elites is also over-emphasized - such "religious" wars responded to great group enmities and desires for plundering among the peoples, not just some elites manipulating them throu piousness.

In fact tons of similar wars happened in the ancient world between within Greek city states, or between Greece, Persia and other states of the time, where no religion difference was used to justify them (or could be used, as city states had the same religion).

There, in Thucydides for example, the arguments for war are written bare (control of trade routes, plundering, defending their territories, not willing to submit to another ruler, defending their way of life, etc), without needing to resort to any religious causes.

The same things are masked in the lingo of each era -- in late 18-19th centuries it was all about the "glory of the nation", in the 20th century it was all about "promoting communism" or "defending the free world", now it's all about "protecting human rights" etc.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by Negative1 on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:41PM (#17436282)
Where is that quote from? I've read Thus spoke Zarathustra and am considering which of his texts I should read next.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by glial on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:48PM (#17436593)
Hannah Arendt, The Origins of Totalitarianism (pt 3)
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by StevenRayOrr on Monday July 02, 2018 @12:03PM (#17442794)
I find Origins can be a shaky entry point for folks trying Arendt for the first time. Especially for someone coming from Zarathustra. My vote here would be to try out Eichmann in Jerusalem as a good bridge into Arendt's thought, before making one's way to what I would call harder texts.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by yonoataraxia on Sunday July 01, 2018 @02:38PM (#17436865)
Nice, very good recommendation. Would love to add Erich Fromm ("The Art of Listening", but I can recommend all of them), although his works are a bit OT in this conversation.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by pmoriarty on Sunday July 01, 2018 @04:21PM (#17437357)
Leiter is a poster child for how Analytic philosophers bastardize and misinterpret the Continentals.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by yonoataraxia on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:18AM (#17435689)
This is a great analysis of Nietzsche. It's rare to find people who really understand what he's trying to say. Many people interpret him in inaccurate ways.

Essentially, Nietzsche is a person who touches very sensitive parts of being human after he analyzed society. He is a person who asked uncomfortable questions about existence in his quest to describe nihilism. Nihilism is the consequence of the loss of morality and the total annihilation of ones values and belief system - and the loss of morality stems from the "death of god" which means that we got to the point (in science) where there were exceedingly small areas of unknowns. Many questions - also about right and wrong - were suddenly more informed due to increasing knowledge.

What makes Nietzsche great is his ability to foresee what this leads to. It's like he knew what will happen in the future. And he tried to give us a solution using "will to power". I'm not necessarily a fan of his solution, but I appreciate it. He's a man who had a positive attitude towards people and society. He wanted to help society. This deep empathy based on insane levels of self-awareness and profundity is what I like about him. Unfortunately, his ideas were not understood properly and used by fascists (the "master race" of the Nazis is built on the definition of ubermensch a.k.a. superman). Which is the reason I really appreciate your comment.

I think that "will to power" is one of many possible solutions. But everyone has to find a solution for the big deep hole of emptiness in their existence. Failing to find a solution leads to nihilism which is a very painful and unpleasant place to be (although it has the advantage that you don't have to take responsibilities - for some people this can feel better than dealing with their emptiness). If we as a society fail to help to give people different solutions for this emptiness, it will lead to a society full of unhappy people who are in quiet despair. We can see that this is already happening.

So Nietzsche talked about a question that hit us hard 100 years after his death. Sometimes we acknowledge when sci-fi authors were able to predict the future. I would like to acknowledge that Nietzsche was able to anticipate our reality based on his knowledge of human nature. In the same realm I would like to thank Sigmund Freud - both shared similar thoughts about the human nature which shows that Nietzsche was also a type of psychologist (before it was a distinct research field). Sigmund Freud once articulated his admiration for Nietzsches work and said that Nietzsches thoughts were amazing in that they captured many thoughts that Freud thought to be true due to his works in psychoanalysis.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by bsenftner on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:34AM (#17435731)
When the emotional reasoning of Nietzsche is removed, what is left is very close to Zen Buddhism. In fact, there is a large informal philosophy group that self identifies with "Zen Nihilism". I'm one.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by mindgam3 on Sunday July 01, 2018 @04:11PM (#17437310)
Nihilism is not at all aligned with Buddhism. This is a common misperception due to a misunderstanding of so-called emptiness practice. The point of emptiness teachings (that nothing has inherent meaning in and of itself) isn’t that everything is meaningless and we should all stop caring. I won’t argue about the pros and cons of nihilism - if it’s working for you, great, but please don’t spread misconceptions about Buddhism in order to justify or support these views.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by armitron on Sunday July 01, 2018 @08:52PM (#17438622)
Nihilism is exactly what Buddhism represents, in its passive form (rather than the active form of nihilism that Nietzsche offers as a solution) which is why the term "passive nihilism" is used by Nietzsche and Schopenhauer to describe it.

In other words, the key word for Buddhism is detachment (passive).

The key word for active forms of nihilism is destruction. The tearing down of established symbols in order to make way for each person to create his own.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by mindgam3 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @11:53PM (#17455167)
You seem to be making a common mistake about Buddhist detachment. It may be helpful to refer to a simplified version of Buddhism's 4 Noble Truths:

1. Suffering exists.

2. Suffering arises from attachment to desires.

3. Suffering ceases when attachment to desire ceases.

4. Freedom from suffering is possible by practicing the Eightfold Path.

A few points:

- Buddhist detachment isn't detachment from everything — it's detachment from desires, which becomes possible when you recognize that suffering underlies all desirable things.

- The point of detachment, and of buddhism at its core, is to reduce suffering. As opposed to passive nihilism, which is "epitomized by resignation" (at least according to google, I had to look it up https://antimodernist.wordpress.com/2012/09/06/active-vs-pas...)

- The next step after detachment is a set of practices to reduce suffering. Some of the most powerful are the compassion (metta) meditations, i.e. "May I be free from suffering, may those near to me be free from suffering, may all beings be free from suffering". Working to reduce the suffering of all beings is the opposite of resignation.

As my own buddhist teacher (Dan Brown, www.pointingoutway.org) explained it to me, many beginning buddhists get stuck on the detachment part, which leads to nihilism, which leads to resignation, which leads to more suffering. In contrast, "properly executed" buddhist detachment leads to practices that reduce suffering (the Eightfold Path).

Hope that helps.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by misja111 on Monday July 02, 2018 @03:55AM (#17439968)
I have no idea why this was downvoted.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by yonoataraxia on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:46AM (#17435783)
I think that the emotional aspect is really important. If you just remove it, you might miss something that is fundamental to human nature. And just removing it is almost certainly a type of self-delusion because the emotional aspect is very hard to remove from human existence.

But yes, if you achieve a level of self-awareness where you're able to live in a near-nihilistic state and be content with it, it can be quite pleasant, although it's very hard to achieve.

Pure nihilism would lead to beings who don't want anything and therefore don't do anything - but even if you want to pee or "achieve nihilism" you stop being a complete nihilist because you start to want something. So it's a catch-22 here. As long as those Zen Nihilists know that they can't achieve pure nihilism and treat it as a goal which can't be reached (like wisdom), I think it can be a good solution (otherwise it could lead to a silly competition where all followers just try to tell everybody how "nihilistic" they are). Not for most of us, but I'm glad you found something.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by armitron on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:06PM (#17438674)
The poster to whom you replied has missed the essence of Nietzsche's writings. There is no such thing as "pure nihilism". Rather, Nietzsche talks of passive and active forms of nihilism with passive leading towards detachment and the abandonment of self (eastern mysticism, Schopenhauer favorite) and active being what Nietzsche espouses and offers up as a solution.

Active nihilism is all about "praxis" rather than detachment. The quote from Blade Runner comes to mind:

"The light that burns twice as bright burns half as long - and you have burned so very, very brightly, Roy."

Nietzsche would like every human being to burn like Roy Batty. Humanity performing a wild leap into the unknown trying to manifest its evolutionary potential, free from the straightjacket of religion and inherited morality.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by bsenftner on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:12PM (#17436150)
Don't forget the essential absurdist humor perspective, which is another common misunderstanding by young "existentialists": self-awareness in a nihilistic frame of reference has a strong undercurrent of jovial humor, as in "well, ain't this just grande".
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by yonoataraxia on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:30PM (#17436232)
I like this perspective very much. George Carlin in his later years has a lot of it in his shows.

And of course the great humor of SMBC: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/2011-10-10

Share some comedians, would love to see some new stuff.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by bsenftner on Sunday July 01, 2018 @04:52PM (#17437497)
Not necessarily a comedian, here's an existential absurdist comic along these lines that I read nearly 40 years ago you might enjoy: http://forbiddenplanet.blog/2014/nemo-nemo-nemo/ I remember visiting an art gallery of the original art for "Spice Of Death" around the same time period.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by jeremyt on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:41AM (#17435764)
I’m flogging Ken Wilber these days. Perhaps take a look at “The Religion of Tomorrow”
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by bsenftner on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:23PM (#17436195)
Looks quite worthwhile, thanks! Found this discussing him: https://markmanson.net/ken-wilber ("The rise and fall of...")
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by jancsika on Sunday July 01, 2018 @05:16PM (#17437646)
> When Trump says climate change is a Chinese hoax he knows he's lying, and you know he's lying, and accusing him of lying would be pointless and that's the point.

That's hilarious-- you left out the one person who matters in your anecdote: the person who voted for Trump. I see no evidence that could lead you to assert that a Trump voter picked at random would know that Trump was lying about climate change being a hoax.

On the flip side, I've seen a lot of Republican politicians, pundits, and op-ed writers for years repeat the assertion that climate change is a hoax. So many, in fact, that we're now calling it "climate change" instead of "global warming." Why? Because those same demagogues preyed on the layperson's confusion of weather and climate, repeatedly pointing out cold weather days as some kind of refutation of "global warming."

Plus-- fucking climategate! What could possibly be the point of all the money and rhetoric poured into that phony controversy if not to actually convince people climate change is a hoax by muddying the waters?

By positing this broad-- and frankly, untestable-- theory that a metaphysical Nietzshean breakdown is causing Trumpism you actually make it impossible to address the problem. And the problem is that millions of people really do believe something that isn't supported by the broad, overwhelming scientific evidence. That's a tractable-- if depressing-- problem which lies mainly in the disconnect between the primary research and the current portals through which laypeople attempt to learn what the primary research says (if at all). (Also in the low quality of U.S. public education.)

> instead of deserting the leaders who had lied to them, they would protest that they had known all along that the statement was a lie and would admire the leaders for their superior tactical cleverness.

That way of thinking turns every single case of non-trivial politicking into a form of fascism.

For example: was Jill Stein acting as a fascist when she quite shamelessly hedged on vaccination in order to pander to her anti-vaxxer base?

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by DanBC on Sunday July 01, 2018 @05:19PM (#17437665)
> that we're now calling it "climate change" instead of "global warming." Why?

https://climate.nasa.gov/resources/global-warming/

> Global warming

> Global warming refers to the upward temperature trend across the entire Earth since the early 20th century, and most notably since the late 1970s, due to the increase in fossil fuel emissions since the industrial revolution. Worldwide since 1880, the average surface temperature has gone up by about 0.8 °C (1.4 °F), relative to the mid-20th-century baseline (of 1951-1980).

> Climate change

> Climate change refers to a broad range of global phenomena created predominantly by burning fossil fuels, which add heat-trapping gases to Earth’s atmosphere. These phenomena include the increased temperature trends described by global warming, but also encompass changes such as sea level rise; ice mass loss in Greenland, Antarctica, the Arctic and mountain glaciers worldwide; shifts in flower/plant blooming; and extreme weather events.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by dnomad on Sunday July 01, 2018 @06:35PM (#17438074)
> I see no evidence that could lead you to assert that a Trump voter picked at random would know that Trump was lying about climate change being a hoax.

Trump supporters know perfectly well that he's lying. There is clear evidence of this [1] if you're willing to look. If you want to see an even more banal example of this dynamic (though there are many) take a look at Hungary today where the most absurd pronouncements are made concerning "Soros" (read: the Jews) and then "clarified" sometimes just a few hours later.

> And the problem is that millions of people really do believe something that isn't supported by the broad, overwhelming scientific evidence.

The problem is impossible to address if you're willing to understand it. It is not the case that these people have been fooled by nefarious industrialists and politicians. The issue here is never about one or two erroneous beliefs that might be corrected with a bit more education. The problem is a culture that deliberately embraces fantasy and self-deception. All the evidence in the world will be dismissed and denied. If it becomes truly impossible to deny it they will turn and instantly settle on some new deception. The result of this process isn't confusion about a single issue but rather a whole imaginary world that is knowingly embraced. It's for this reason that one fantasy about the climate is always accompanied by a whole host of fantasies about everything from immigration to fluoride.

> For example: was Jill Stein acting as a fascist when she quite shamelessly hedged on vaccination in order to pander to her anti-vaxxer base?

As Nietzsche understood it individuals don't "act fascist" rather it's a sickness that attacks culture. A culture where politicians have to bend the knee to such nonsense is not healthy. I would hope this is obvious.

[1] https://www.vox.com/2017/7/10/15928438/fact-checks-political...

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by dionian on Sunday July 01, 2018 @02:28PM (#17436826)
How does "science" cause a crisis? Are you arguing that Nietzche was saying that "God is a bad concept and proven wrong by science"? That was never my reading.

Can you provide evidence for your claims regarding what "we know [Trump] is lying" about regarding climate science?

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by sunir on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:59PM (#17438851)
The actual real crisis was WW2 which proved so many grand ideas to be wrong or terrifying if right.

The atom bomb and the slaughter proved science is powerful, god nonpresent, and that in either case society had no grand narrative to believe in any longer that wouldn’t be horrifying in the end.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by Amezarak on Sunday July 01, 2018 @06:37PM (#17438076)
> Science causes a kind of crisis. ("God is dead.") After millenia of extreme devotion to all manner nonsense (think of the religious wars that plagued Europe) science starts asking some very uncomfortable and very pointed questions. But people will not abandon their fantasies, even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary. Instead they will cling to their fantasies that much harder often with full knowledge that what they "believe" are lies. This metastasizes into fascism [1]. When Trump says climate change is a Chinese hoax he knows he's lying, and you know he's lying, and accusing him of lying would be pointless and that's the point. Nietzsche foresaw quite clearly that this would be the crisis of the 20th century and beyong: in the face of science people would become more willing to deceive themselves.

I think your comment is not exactly incorrect, but misleading in terms of what Nietzsche meant. Most of Nietzsche's commentary about the death of God is not about what we would call the religious aspect (in fact, Nietzsche praised religious wars as demonstrating that the masses had 'advanced'), but the fact that the death of God undermined the entire Western system of thought, including and particularly that of atheists. The famous "God is dead" passage is targeted at atheists - it is the atheists who do not understand what they've done!

And, rather than being opposed to "self-deception", Nietzsche says that it is likely necessary for life. He does not call for a defense against self-deception (and in fact, what he does call for on many occasions, he often points out is for the exception, and not the rule.)

> Consequently, “will to truth” does not mean “I will not let myself be deceived” but—there is no choice—“I will not deceive, not even myself”: and with this we are on the ground of morality. For one should ask oneself carefully: “Why don’t you want to deceive?” especially if it should appear—and it certainly does appear—that life depends on appearance; I mean, on error, simulation, deception, self-deception; and when life has, as a matter of fact, always shown itself to be on the side of the most unscrupulous polytropoi .Such an intent, charitably interpreted, could perhaps be quixotism, a little enthusiastic impudence; but it could also be something worse, namely, a destructive principle, hostile to life. “Will to truth”—that might be concealed will to death.

> Thus the question “Why science?” leads back to the moral problem, “For what end any morality at all” if life, nature, and history are “not moral”? No doubt, those who are truthful in that audacious and ultimate sense that is presupposed by the faith in science thus affirm another world than the world of life, nature, and history; and insofar as they affirm this "other world" - look, must they not by the same token negate its counterpart, this world, our world? - But one will have gathered what I am driving at, namely, that it always remains a metaphysical faith upon which our faith in science rests—that even we devotees of knowledge today, we godless ones and anti-metaphysicians, still take our fire too from the flame which the faith thousands of years old has kindled: that Christian faith, which was also Plato’s faith, that God is truth, that truth is divine.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by jeremyt on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:39AM (#17435756)
In this, I think Nietzsche was dangerously wrong. I don’t have the time to go into detail at the moment, but the better prescription is outlined in Ken Wilber’s “A theory of everything” or if you have lots of intestinal fortitude “The religion of tomorrow”.

Nietzsche is dead.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by jeremyt on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:48AM (#17442074)
I have no idea why I was downvoted. To even touch the surface of Ken Wilber’s critique of Nietzche would require on the order of 10 pages, and I know that because I’m writing it right now.

I also find it extremely ironic that a person in a different comment is criticizing me for not being able to quickly boil a philosopher’s entire approach down to a few sentences, in a comment where we are arguing about people wrongly boiling Nietzsche down into a few sentences

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by hashkb on Sunday July 01, 2018 @12:02PM (#17436098)
> . I don’t have the time to go into detail at the moment

Maybe stay out of philosophy then?

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by dang on Sunday July 01, 2018 @01:28PM (#17436522)
Acerbic swipes are not ok here. Please don't do this on HN, regardless of how bad another comment is.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html