News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by coldtea on Sunday July 01, 2018 @09:37AM (#17435549)
>Science causes a kind of crisis. ("God is dead.") After millenia of extreme devotion to all manner nonsense (think of the religious wars that plagued Europe) science starts asking some very uncomfortable and very pointed questions.

There was no nonsense. Or far fewer of it than one imagines.

When the "religious wars" weren't using religious directly as a thin pretext for "let's grab their land", they were about ways to live.

Religion in those days was what lifestyle (or national preferences) are today, and it was used a proxy for that and for defining a national/cultural group (the role that later was played by nations), not for mere theological differences.

Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by 101km on Sunday July 01, 2018 @10:06AM (#17435650)
I think a distinction is in order between elites who pretended to be pious and the true believers they ruled over.
Re:Friedrich Nietzsche: The truth is terrible by coldtea on Sunday July 01, 2018 @11:15AM (#17435891)
The population wasn't much more "true believers", in letting religion dictate such things, than the average person today. It was just part of their culture.

The role of the elites is also over-emphasized - such "religious" wars responded to great group enmities and desires for plundering among the peoples, not just some elites manipulating them throu piousness.

In fact tons of similar wars happened in the ancient world between within Greek city states, or between Greece, Persia and other states of the time, where no religion difference was used to justify them (or could be used, as city states had the same religion).

There, in Thucydides for example, the arguments for war are written bare (control of trade routes, plundering, defending their territories, not willing to submit to another ruler, defending their way of life, etc), without needing to resort to any religious causes.

The same things are masked in the lingo of each era -- in late 18-19th centuries it was all about the "glory of the nation", in the 20th century it was all about "promoting communism" or "defending the free world", now it's all about "protecting human rights" etc.