News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by jordigh on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:06AM (#17408697)
It would and it has. In Mastodon-speak, this is called an "extinction event", and I have seen a few of those. Mastodon, however, has already implemented take-out feature where you can download all of your data at any time, including your friend list. It's not perfect, because although you can keep your followee list, your followers don't have an automatic way of knowing where your new presence may have moved to.

Also, the stuff that has already been tooted lives on in the fediverse in other servers, so it's not like the toots also disappear from other servers after an extinction event, just like an email server going down doesn't delete the email from everyone else's inbox.

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by stcredzero on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:50PM (#17409714)
It would and it has. In Mastodon-speak, this is called an "extinction event", and I have seen a few of those. Mastodon, however, has already implemented take-out feature where you can download all of your data at any time, including your friend list.

How about backing up accounts in other servers? These could be encrypted with a key which only the user controls. Or perhaps the backup could be done encrypted in cloud storage like S3 (this would involve a paid account, obviously) so the user's presence could be resurrected in a different server?

It might also be dandy to have "failover" agreements, where one server can agree ahead of time to failover users for another server, in case of failure.

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by alex_duf on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @03:32PM (#17411074)
Yes I think the next step to avoid that is to own your own domain name.

If you own your domain name you can have a provider die, and you'll still be able to re import your data on a new provider, assuming you're able to set up a DNS

And that's where you lose most non technical users I guess?

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by phyzome on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @04:50PM (#17411745)
Mastodon (and I suppose ActivityPub in general) conflates hosting location with username. If I have a username like @[email protected], then my stuff has to be accessible at mastodon.social's IP address (the A record).

Compare to email, where the MX record provides a layer of indirection. ActivityPub technically has a feature like this using a .well-known file, but it leaks into the user interface n unpleasant ways.

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by PKop on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:53AM (#17409162)
I was thinking that federation still leaves unsolved the issue of knowing the single source of truth for identities, and when instances go down, you can't reference anything to know who/where people are.

Couldn't Keybase.io solve this? It could track your identities on these servers, and it would exist outside of any instances or federation, but be the source of identity that would go along with any federated instances you are a part of

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by skywhopper on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:36PM (#17409564)
What will we do when keybase goes away?
Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by archgoon on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:58PM (#17409801)
Isn't keybase.io just a way of storing public keys? If they go down, and you still have the private key, you can just sign a message saying "No, really! It's me!"

The issue with distributed systems that rely on public keys is the lack of options to turn to if the keys are lost or compromised. And yes, people will lose keys. Systems that rely on keys for identity need to figure out what options people have at that point to re-establish their identity.

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by wmf on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @12:24PM (#17409443)
Or DNS.
Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by s73v3r_ on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:50AM (#17409137)
Unfortunately, it's out there, but you can't associate those previous messages with your new account.
Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by PKop on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:55AM (#17409195)
Keybase.io could be a part of solving this I think:

https://keybase.io/docs/sigchain

Re:Why ActivityPub is the future by xez on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @11:10AM (#17408727)
right, there's that at least, and that's probably better than the alternatives. It just didn't sound like a good analogy. A bit deceiving even.