News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by ckastner on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:13AM (#17392552)
This is fantastic news!

Based on this information, I conclude that nuclear fusion is probably only about 20 years away.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by adrianN on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:28AM (#17392666)
Can we stop with the "fusion will always be x years away" meme? Fusion is mostly a number of invested dollars away. A big reason why we don't have fusion reactors yet is because nobody invests sufficient amounts into the necessary research. Check this graph http://imgur.com/sjH5r from the old Slashdot interview

https://hardware.slashdot.org/story/12/04/11/0435231/mit-fus...

It's just disrespectful to all the brilliant physicists and engineers who work on the topic to belittle their efforts like that.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by jgh on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:35AM (#17392714)
> You might say that we’re not a certain number of years away from a working fusion power plant, but rather about $80-billion away (in worldwide funding).

That's a surprisingly small number for the impact nuclear fusion could make. I wonder why we haven't seen any billionaires taking up the challenge, even though this might be more impactful than space tourism or people on mars.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by skybrian on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:57AM (#17392883)
For context, that's over twice the size of the Gates Foundation. You have to compare that to all other possible investments, including energy startups that could pay off a lot sooner.

Note that SpaceX is set up as a business, not a charity; Musk may talk a lot about Mars but that's not really where the money goes.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by inteleng on Monday June 25, 2018 @07:58PM (#17396889)
The money funding SpaceX could hardly be allocated towards sustainable colonization of Mars in a more efficient manner. If you can think of one, please email Elon.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by skybrian on Monday June 25, 2018 @11:25PM (#17397653)
Sure, SpaceX has good business plan. That's the point. Building rockets only for a future Mars voyage and not making any money along the way would be a bad way to do it.

By contrast, fusion will only be a scientific research project for many years and many billions.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by inteleng on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @12:39AM (#17397901)
That's just the way it works. It cost a lot of money to develop rockets in the first place. Your comparison is simply not very meaningful.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by skybrian on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @11:03AM (#17401100)
My point is there is a big difference in how much money gets tied up for how long. (Capex.)
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by blauditore on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:43AM (#17392766)
Time/budget predictions are hard, especially for cutting edge research. So predicting required funding until fusion is profitable sounds unreliable too.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by Nokinside on Monday June 25, 2018 @12:10PM (#17393519)
The bottom like is that fusion energy is now engineering problem and not basic science problems. Engineering risks are more manageable and predictable.

It's like Manhattan project, you can do it if you want it bad enough.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by chengiz on Monday June 25, 2018 @01:00PM (#17393875)
This is simply not true. There are unsolved engineering problems and not just risks.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by sanxiyn on Tuesday June 26, 2018 @08:40AM (#17400050)
I think comparison with Manhattan project is appropriate. Manhattan project also had unsolved engineering problems, which they solved.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by pfdietz on Friday June 29, 2018 @01:13AM (#17422559)
Fusion has fundamental engineering obstacles, not just unsolved problems.

The basic problem is that heat transfer limits guarantee that fusion reactors will be big and expensive (meaning: power density an order of magnitude worse than a fission reactor core, and probably worse than that.)

The core of a PWR fission reactor that one can build today has a power density of 100 MW per cubic meter. The power density of ITER (dividing the gross fusion power by the volume inside the cryostat) is 0.05 MW per cubice meter, 2000x worse. Other fusion designs aren't quite as ludicrous, but will still be much worse than fission.

The problem is that heat in the PWR has to get out of fuel rods that are 1 cm in diameter. The heat in a fusion reactor has to get out of a plasma vessel that is meters in diameter. The ratio of surface area/volume is orders of magnitude higher for the fission reactor.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by DesiLurker on Monday June 25, 2018 @03:56PM (#17395301)
that spot on. IMO Its mostly a funding issue. My bold prediction is that we will have net energy from fusion within a decade of the point where market Begins to price in the ultimate demise of fossil fuel based energy. sooner the FF projects start getting counted as stranded resources because of EVs & renewable quicker the money starts to flow into fusion research.

the other rapid development scenario would be some sort of fusion arms race between asia (ch/kr/jp) and the rest of developed world.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by bischofs on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:47AM (#17392803)
You have to admit that there is something to this meme, It seems like Fusion suffers from a lack of focus and direction. Ive heard all sorts of horror stories about physicists and engineers going off on fusion design tangents that pull funding away from more viable designs as far as energy-in/energy-out.

I understand that there is a level of experimentation and R&D that is guaranteed not to generate viable results but at some point you need to trim the fat, get everyone moving in one direction etc. This grand project has been going on for over 50 years at this point, It seems like we should at least have one design that everyone should be focusing on. If they had real, defined commercial goals (even if they miss the goals) it might be easier to secure funding because your average politician would see the benefit to them.

I'm not a nuclear engineer so take that all with a grain of salt.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by alexgmcm on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:49AM (#17392819)
It's hard to know what is a 'tangent' and what is the next breakthrough though.

As they say - if we knew what we were doing it wouldn't be research.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by adrianN on Monday June 25, 2018 @11:01AM (#17392924)
We have a design that everybody is focusing on. That's why they want to build ITER and DEMO.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by lazysheepherd on Monday June 25, 2018 @11:25AM (#17393118)
"You Can Always Get What You Want — But Not What You Need" > https://youtu.be/QCw_D7dr7Rw

If you spare half an hour to Google, you can find out what we want collectively;

1) Find global spending on fusion research and note it down.

2) Pick some other stuff to compare it to. Like global annual military budget. Annual profits of the largest companies and what they sell to make it. Or how much do we spend on 'entertainment'. Or popularity of Kardashians(given even I know that f#cking name...) or whatever.

You'll be quick to realize that the fusion is sitting in the corner, waiting for us to "want to have it".

It makes me feel depressed to see on every fusion article in 2018, there is a paragraph allocated to explain how fusion is different from fission and how it is not... basically not a bomb.

The topic feels home in HN, but I do not know if you ever brought up fusion in a talk with family or even among your young friend circle. I certainly have engaged in that experiment myself. People do not even know what the heck is fusion, let alone lobbying to fund it with tax money. In this state, I say, the advancement on fusion is rather stellar, I congratulate wholeheartedly anyone putting sweat and money in it to bring things to this level.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by pfdietz on Friday June 29, 2018 @01:16AM (#17422565)
Fusion isn't marginal because funding is low.

Rather, funding for fusion is low because fusion is marginal.

The money would be there if the technology warranted it. But examined closely, fusion doesn't appear promising, so people close their checkbooks.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by mabbo on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:18AM (#17392591)
> probably only about 20 years away

Down from the '25 years away' it has been for the last 50. I'm not being facetious, I actually think that's huge win and we should all be happy.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by gmueckl on Monday June 25, 2018 @11:38AM (#17393227)
I've been following fusion research on and off since I've been a little kid. It's always been far in the future. Back then it seemed like I could actually see a fusion reactor when I'm an old man. Now, 25 years later, the rate of progress generally feels like the date has shifted to "not in my lifetime". It's kind of a weird feeling.

Edit: Addendum: I vividly remember images with visualization results for numerical simulations on the reactor vessel shape for Wendelstein 7-X. That was back in 1992 or so. This just shows how long this experiment was in the making.

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by daef on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:16AM (#17392576)
The question is if we'll live long enough to experience the time after those magical 20 years....
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by emeraldd on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:24AM (#17392637)
The obligatory XKCD: https://m.xkcd.com/678/
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by zerostar07 on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:29AM (#17392674)
> 20 years

On which reference frame?

Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by jandrese on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:18AM (#17392594)
It will be the perfect power plant for my flying car.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by juliangoldsmith on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:18AM (#17392593)
And only another 20 after that, of course. We should have strong AI by that time as well.
Re:Wendelstein 7-X achieves world record by Pica_soO on Monday June 25, 2018 @10:50AM (#17392830)
If you could integrate fusion into a human being- that would allow for time travel.