News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:43AM (#17371379)
Bringing in people's names in order to attack them is a breach of this site's civility rule. You needn't stoop to that in order to discuss issues of substance in this story, so please don't.

All: please keep the internet rage reflex off HN. Same for the online shaming culture.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

(Edit: I didn't mean that you were feeling rage, but that by posting this way you were stirring it up. In any case, thanks for removing the names.)

Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by davedx on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:47AM (#17371663)
So all the constant anti-Tesla articles blaming Musk personally on here are fine, but these guys are somehow above being named despite their names being public record? Why is this different?
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by pvg on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:53AM (#17371687)
You think an article criticizing a company and its executives is the same thing as inciting an online rage mob (along with a posse for some unnamed Twitter evildoer) on a message board? Because they're pretty different.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by mmt on Friday June 22, 2018 @04:37AM (#17372442)
Wasn't the original commentor criticizing, exactly, an (acquired) company and its executives?
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by pvg on Friday June 22, 2018 @04:56AM (#17372520)
No.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by vignesh_m on Friday June 22, 2018 @09:49AM (#17373928)
You are right, but Tesla itself pushes Musk as the face of the company.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:17AM (#17371804)
Personal attacks on anyone aren't fine on HN, but when there's an entire industry of articles about them it gets a lot harder to enforce the rule.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by icelancer on Friday June 22, 2018 @04:50AM (#17372490)
I haven't seen a single anti-Musk personal attack deleted or addressed, yet I saw this. A lot harder != impossible.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by sonnyblarney on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:16AM (#17371523)
"Bringing in people's names in order to attack them is a breach of this site's civility rule"

I think there is an issue of personal integrity here, even legally.

When I worked for a large F50, our CEO's name had to be on every email we sent out from our German staff - though I'm not sure of the specific German regulation, 'his name is on it' because it's a matter of integrity to the organization.

The founders are generally 'Officers of the Company' - and this implies both a legal/fiduciary and moral obligation in America and most jurisdictions of relevance.

I don't believe that the 'limited personal liability' concept abnegates the responsibilities of the Officers of the Company in this specific regard.

I also don't believe this is a matter of arbitrary doxing if the Officers of the Company are making decisions which are considered foul play in terms of reasonable contractual obligations.

Unless there is an issue of national security or likewise, there's simply no excuse for ending service without reasonable notice.

This is not a political, or socially nuanced discussion such as those involving harassment etc. - this is a matter of commercial civility (and legality).

In American law: "In limited circumstances, such as the sale of the small business to a new owner, the business judgment rule does not apply, and it becomes the burden of CEOs and company directors to demonstrate that their actions were in the company's best interests." [1]

(FYI - the 'business judgement rule' protects Officers from liability.)

I guess I understand we don't want to be doxing folks here ... but I do think it's reasonable that individuals should be held publicly accountable for their commercial actions - for example, someone does an ICO and then - legally - walks away with the cash ... we should rightfully be wary of investing in their next ICO or company for that matter.

The inability for executives to be held accountable for actions of the company is a core problem in present day capitalism, in my opinion.

[1] http://smallbusiness.chron.com/legal-relationship-between-sh...

Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:18AM (#17371537)
Internal to a single company is a totally different context than a large internet forum.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by sonnyblarney on Friday June 22, 2018 @03:21PM (#17376614)
Loathe to be technical, but this is HN ... to the best of my 'definitely not a lawyer' knowledge, you are correct that Officers responsibility to shareholders (i.e. 'internal') is greater than it is to their contractual obligations (i.e. 'external') ... but, there definitely is still a legal obligation to contracted customers, of which there are thousands. Ergo - this could very well sit within boundaries for their personal obligations.

I know they're an YC company, so I don't want to ruffle anyone here, but I do think a class action lawsuit against Twitter is warranted, even if it has a shaky legal foundation.

I believe that Twitter's actions - and the response - will be duly noted among M&A camps and the last thing we want is this to become standard practice. This is just 'bad acting' and it will come back to bite everyone here in startup-land.

I risk my erstwhile happy HN account by getting into a fuss with pvg, but he indicated that we want to 'wait to find out what's happening' - I would argue that in light of Twitter's 'total and immediate blackout' the onus is upon them to provide forthright information, and that absent that, we can assume 'bad acting' given a total blackout without any information.

Maybe we can use this as a lesson and the powers-that-be can provide some leadership, and possibly push towards a 'best commercial practice' like '120 days minimum notice' or something like that as a standard.

This is exactly the community to do it in, as I frankly don't see where else anyone has any broad legitimate authority among early stage startups such as it exists here.

Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by jamesmiller5 on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:34AM (#17371607)
Hey dang, that response and edit was pretty civil, since the names are removed could the flagged state on OP's comment be removed as well (edit: please)?
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by jnbiche on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:11AM (#17371775)
Thank you. As far as I can recall, it's my only flagged comment in my ~8 years on HN.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:22AM (#17371820)
Back to zero.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:16AM (#17371799)
Sure - that's a good suggestion. Thanks for looking out for a fellow user.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by icelancer on Friday June 22, 2018 @04:51AM (#17372496)
Strongly disagree with this decision. These are public names and not a personal attack. People made these decisions and were responsible for them.
Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by throwaway4dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:39AM (#17371623)
Bringing in people's names in order to attack them is a breach of this site's civility rule.

Yes, we are aware that Smyte is YC W15. Thanks for the reminder that you protect your own from base accountability at high cost to others.

Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by dang on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:15AM (#17371795)
That had nothing to do with it. I had no idea that Smyte was a YC company (or had forgotten, not sure which). But thanks for letting me know.

Since it sounds like you follow these things closely, I'm surprised you'd be so cynical. If there's literally a single case where someone did that where we haven't chided them, I'd like to know about it. In fact if there are any personal attacks of any kind on HN that we haven't moderated, I'd like to know. The likeliest explanation is that we just didn't see it. In the present case a user (not connected to YC as far as I know) emailed us to complain about the comment, I looked at it, and replied—same as it ever was.

Re:Twitter ‘smytes’ customers by chris_wot on Friday June 22, 2018 @05:39AM (#17372692)
I strongly disagree with this. The founders of a company are public figures, and their actions matter. They should be named, after all they are the ones who sold their company and then immediately pulled the plug.