Re:Koko, a gorilla who could do sign language, has died at 46
by drb91 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:13PM
(#17367127)
> Either Koko could communicate complex thoughts, or she was just spamming nonsense and the trainers are deceiving us.
If there is a worldview where it makes sense to structure thinking of communication as a dichotomy between "complex and nonsense", I cannot see it.
Re:Koko, a gorilla who could do sign language, has died at 46
by JackFr on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:51PM
(#17366862)
> Either Koko could communicate complex thoughts, or she was just spamming nonsense and the trainers are deceiving us. That's the binary part.
That's a false dilemma.
"Either Koko could communicate complex thoughts, or she could not."
That is a binary choice. And even that is contingent on precise definitions of complex, communicate and thought.
Surely a lot of what she signed was garbage, and surely she could communicate some of the simplest things regardless (like a dog can). But if she legitimately communicated even one complex thought with signs, that's a binary difference from the rest of the animal kingdom.