News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by ghaff on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:36AM (#17365519)
I find it hard to argue with from a fairness perspective. Clearly, retail is in a much different place from when Quill was decided. My concern is more in how a mom & pop online shop operating independently complies as a practical matter, which means not only collecting the right amount for different types of items but presumably remitting and filing with a huge number of different tax jurisdictions.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Nasrudith on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:04AM (#17365793)
There are two against it on fairness grounds I can see but your mileage may vary on practically and definitions of fairness.

One is that they don't use the infrastructure in the state. Shippers are either already taxed for their use if private or self funding government in the case of UPS.

The second is a more slippery taxation without representation which also gets into all sorts of semantic issues with who is really being taxed the in state residents or the out of state residents.

Really the tax infrastructure is in drastic need of modernization and streamlining. It may step on a lot of toes but I could see forcing online sales tax into a federal fixed rate with redistributed fixed percentages as worth it. Say 5% rate nationally and of that 1/3rd each to the buyer's state and the seller's state and 1/6th to each municipality respectively with it defaulting to the state if it is unincorporated. It would even actually fit in interstate commerce domain nicely.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Eridrus on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:01PM (#17366335)
> One is that they don't use the infrastructure in the state.

This is one way of looking at things, but I think sales tax is much closer to a tax on consumers than on businesses. Or at least is intended as a tax on consumers to fund their state infrastructure, often because imposing an income tax is impossible (e.g. Washington State constitution) or just politically unpalatable.

Normalising taxes is basically impossible in an environment where sales taxes are a meaningful part of a government's budget.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by shkkmo on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:54PM (#17367607)
Do the consumers pay the tax to the federal government? No? Then it's not a tax on them, but on the businesses that pay the tax. Business's can choose to charge consumers directly for this, but for online retailers that means additional complexity in the checkout and billing process.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by ghaff on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:15AM (#17365883)
On the other hand, local businesses are paying other types of taxes anyway (such as property taxes) and they're actually employing local people--so there's almost an argument that local businesses should be paying less sales tax rather than more. And then you're almost in why have a sales tax at all territory given that they're mostly regressive.

There's certainly a good argument for a flat national sales tax but that doesn't really fit with federalism and, anyway, good luck getting New Hampshire and New York to agree on a number.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by n_o_u on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:32AM (#17366064)
On the other hand, having local businesses pay less sales tax would be dangerously close to interstate tariffs.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jxcl on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:41AM (#17365568)
In Colorado you're already asked when filing state taxes what the value of the goods you bought online that haven't been taxed yet, so the onus is on the filer to look up receipts from the year for tax purposes.

Amazon already collects tax in Colorado, but a few smaller retailers will send you a letter at the end of the year totaling up your untaxed purchases. Since different counties and localities collect different rates, it's hard to get the total tax right at the time of sale.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by ghaff on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:48AM (#17365640)
>In Colorado you're already asked when filing state taxes what the value of the goods you bought online that haven't been taxed yet

Many states do this. I imagine that relatively few individuals (as opposed to businesses) actually comply.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by blang on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:25PM (#17367257)
People rarely comply, unless they are tax lawyers that fear the IRS wants to put them up as a trophy:

https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/04/16/177384487/most...

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by macintux on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:52AM (#17366238)
I assumed all of them do it, but maybe not. I’ve been complying with this in Indiana for years, but I agree that I’m almost certainly unusual in that regard.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by planteen on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:56AM (#17365715)
I also live in Colorado and only got one such letter last year after a lot of online shopping. It was from B&H and was wrong, though the dollar amount wasn't very high. I placed an order where one item was back ordered, so separate shipments came. They said tax was owed on the back ordered item twice.

But, as you said, Amazon already collects tax at time of sale which was the bulk of my purchases.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by s73v3r_ on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:23PM (#17366543)
Just about every state requires this. No one does it, and it's simply not feasible for any state to go after taxpayers for this.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by paulie_a on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:04AM (#17365784)
Wisconsin does the same and I will be honest have simply lied and put an insignificant random number.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by himom on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:57AM (#17365726)
It’s called an use tax. It’s equivalent to a sales tax, reporting is required but voluntary. Not paying use taxes on internet purchases is tax evasion. Here’s what CA’s state tax collectors have to say:

https://www.ftb.ca.gov/individuals/use-tax.shtml

https://www.cdtfa.ca.gov/taxes-and-fees/use-tax.htm

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by anonymous5133 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:35AM (#17366095)
It is not hard to get the right rates. All you need to do is have a master file with all zip codes with the corresponding rate to charge. The difficult part is filing out the returns and dealing with potential audits.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by tzs on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:07PM (#17366390)
> It is not hard to get the right rates. All you need to do is have a master file with all zip codes with the corresponding rate to charge.

If you are specifically talking about Colorado, you may be right. I'm not familiar with how Colorado does sales tax.

In general, though, zip code is not sufficient. Even if use zip+4 it might not be sufficient. For example, in Washington, people who live in zip 98027-5444 on Renton Issaquah RD SE in the address range 9100-9199 pay 8.6% if their address is even, and 10% if their address is odd. A tax district boundary runs right down the middle of their road.

See this comment from a few months ago explaining in detail how you find the sales tax on a sale in Washington: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16196591

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mgkimsal on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:47AM (#17366202)
ZIP codes don't align with taxing authorities 100%. You also have different types of products that have different rates - no standard "master file with all the zip codes" is going to express all that other stuff.

Yes, it is hard to 'get the right rates' 100% of the time.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by chasil on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:53AM (#17365690)
I live in an Illinois border community, and work in Iowa. I wonder what tax would be collected if I close an Ebay transaction in Iowa, but have the products shipped to my address in Illinois.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by honest_george on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:56AM (#17365722)
While I can't speak for US law, most of the time it's the delivery address that matters - if the location you're at when purchasing matters, you could do all of your expensive on-line shopping when on holiday in some place with low taxes (or using a VPN...).
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by BorgHunter on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:20AM (#17365936)
This is one of those "it depends on the state" questions. In general, a seller is going to calculate and remit tax based on the delivery address, but the laws are actually a bit more complicated than that. chasil, who lives in Illinois but is close to Iowa, might start having packages delivered to a P.O. Box in Iowa, for example. However, legally speaking, s/he must still pay Illinois use tax on that item provided it is "for use or consumption in Illinois" and less than the current Illinois use tax rate of 6.25% was collected originally. See http://www.revenue.state.il.us/Individuals/FAQs-Use-Tax.htm

Practically speaking, of course, few people keep detailed enough records to even calculate the correct use tax owed at the end of the year, and any tax that might have been owed goes uncollected and unnoticed. Which is the problem that led to this Supreme Court case in the first place.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by chasil on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:34AM (#17366087)
One particular question is my use of Page Plus, my phone carrier. It was the first Verizon MVNO to get 4g.

I was on an automatic payment with them, and they announced that they were adding 911 taxes.

I canceled the automatic payment and started getting refills at pincheap.com (a dealer with no presence in either Iowa or Illinois), avoiding both sales tax and the 911 tax.

There is no "delivery" of any physical product, so I wonder if the tax status of that arrangement changes.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by vanadium on Thursday June 21, 2018 @04:30PM (#17369028)
It's for this reason Illinois residents don't buy a car in Wisconsin or another neighboring state with a more advantageous tax structure; you'll get nailed post-haste.

But if you're driving up to buy a few cases of New Glarus beer, chances are you're vastly unlikely (at or nearing 0%) that you'd be held to account for that purchase for Illinois tax purposes.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jethro_tell on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:25PM (#17367250)
Soon:

AWS launches new 'Guaranteed to be in Oregon' VPN endpoints! Free for use while shopping on Amazon.com.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by xienze on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:54AM (#17366255)
Technically you're supposed to pay your state's tax, even for a purchase where you were physically in another state. Even if that other state actually charges its own sales tax!
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by RightMillennial on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:28PM (#17366599)
I thought with use taxes you owed the remaining difference in tax. Say I purchase a $100 widget in Kenosha, WI with a sales tax of 5.5%, and I live in MI with a sales and use tax of 6%. I would owe MI the 0.5% difference on the $100 which would be $0.50.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by xienze on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:43PM (#17366774)
No my understanding is that the state wants their full X% -- the whole point of the use tax is "you paid that guy but you're supposed to pay me." If you paid a higher tax rate in another state do you think your home state would be happy with 0% or even reimburse you the difference?

IIRC you're expected to get the out of state retailer to reimburse you at a later time and then when you're paying your income taxes you include any purchases subject to use tax.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by RightMillennial on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:09PM (#17367076)
I think it depends on the state. At least in MI, you only have to pay the difference [1] [2]:

> Use Tax on the Difference

> If you paid at least 6 percent to another state on your purchase, you do not owe use tax to Michigan. If you paid less than 6 percent, you owe the difference.

> NOTE: The full 6 percent use tax is also owed on purchases made in a foreign country.

[1]: https://www.taxslayer.com/support/1153/michigan-use-tax

[2]: https://www.michigan.gov/documents/taxes/MI_1040_Instruction...

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by ghaff on Thursday June 21, 2018 @01:04PM (#17367007)
It probably depends on the state.

In Massachusetts, oddly, if you paid less than the Mass sales tax rate of 6.25%, you owe 6.25% use tax. It's not the delta you owe, it's the full amount. But you don't owe it at all if you paid more than the Mass rate.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by pishpash on Thursday June 21, 2018 @06:42PM (#17369860)
It's never going to be fair, since online shops don't have physical plant costs (as an example). Are you going to penalize them for that too and make them pay a phantom imputed presence tax? That's why fairness is the wrong path to go down.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by omfg on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:38AM (#17365541)
We’ve been looking at tech solutions for calculation / remittance. So far only found Avalara. I’d be surprised if PayPal, Stripe, and others won’t step into this now that it’ll be fairly profitable.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by tzs on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:28PM (#17366597)
Besides Avalara, I'm aware of taxjar.com, taxify.co, taxamo.com.

Avalara and Taxamo don't list prices on their sites as far as I managed to find. Googling turns up comments saying that Avalara is expensive.

TaxJar and Taxify do list prices.

For a small business (up to 1k transactions/month) is $17/month if you pay for a year up front ($19/month on month-to-month). A transaction is either giving them an order and having them figure the tax, or looking up a rate with their API.

That will get you reports for each state, ready to file. If you want them to actually file for you, that costs more. If you have to file in all 45 states that have sales/use tax, with a monthly filing in each, it would come to $5000/year at TaxJar.

Taxify is $47/month for up to 1k transactions, and it would be $14580 to have them handle filing under the same 45 state/monthly filing assumption.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by zzzmarcus on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:37PM (#17368043)
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by tzs on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:05PM (#17368311)
That looks like their tax filing product for ecommerce. The prices look pretty good, actually, at least compared to other others. A single filing seems to be about the same price as the others, but they have good discounts if you are filing in a lot of states which looks like Avalara might be a winner if you are dealing with many states.

I don't see any pricing for their services for their services for determining how much tax you need to collect for a given transaction.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jakejohnson on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:23PM (#17368448)
Correct, that pricing is specific to TrustFile for reporting and filing. They have a separate product called AvaTax [1] for calculating sales tax. If you decide to speak with a sales rep for an all-inclusive package, be mindful of setup fees, cancellation fees, and annual contracts.

[1] https://www.avalara.com/us/en/products/sales-and-use-tax/ava...

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mgkimsal on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:53AM (#17365691)
have been using taxjar.com with... ok results so far - they seem to only provide a sandbox/playground for 'pro' accounts ("call for pricing" - ugh).
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jakejohnson on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:28PM (#17366594)
You can sign up for a free trial with TaxJar right away without calling a sales rep, no CC required. Sandbox API environment is included for all plans, but marketed toward Plus plans. Once you log in, generate prod / sandbox keys from the account page.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mgkimsal on Thursday June 28, 2018 @11:46PM (#17422254)
Nope. I've logged in. Registered. I'm a paying customer, using it in production, and there's no visible way to generate a sandbox key, except 'go to plus'.

From their docs: https://developers.taxjar.com/api/reference/#sandbox-environ...

* Sandbox Environment

TaxJar provides a sandbox environment for automated testing and development on all TaxJar Plus plans. After generating a sandbox API token, point your API client to the sandbox environment...

There is no sandbox API available without 'plus'. Perhaps you had an earlier version and are grandfathered in?

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by homero on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:27AM (#17366016)
Yeah I've never used a service that made me call or email and never will
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by ghaff on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:42AM (#17365588)
Yeah, it seems like something the payment processors have to handle automagically in some manner. Otherwise, small online merchants are going to have no practical choice other than 1.) Selling through e.g. Amazon or 2.) Just ignoring the law.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jeffmould on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:44AM (#17365604)
Stripe already recommends Avalara and a couple others:

https://stripe.com/docs/orders/tax-integration

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by ghaff on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:50AM (#17365658)
That seems to only address calculating the tax however. Presumably the business is still expected to remit the tax collected to each tax jurisdiction as required plus whatever necessary paperwork.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jeffmould on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:23AM (#17365978)
Most of these services handle the filings and paperwork for you as well.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Androider on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:11PM (#17368368)
It doesn't really work very well together at all unless you're using Stripe Orders for physical products. You can't make the Stripe checkout.js show taxes, and it's just a big pain to integrate the API. There's a big opportunity for Stripe here to make it really simple, I would be happy to pay extra to have them completely deal with it.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by jakejohnson on Thursday June 21, 2018 @12:24PM (#17366553)
Keep in mind that Stripe only provides automated tax calculations for their Orders API (previously Relay) at this time. You'll have to use a sales tax API to handle calculations for subscriptions and one-off charges.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by rstupek on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:59AM (#17366307)
We have used TaxCloud which handles paying each jurisdiction
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by test6554 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:04PM (#17368301)
Avalara provides this service to mom and pops for $50 per year.