News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by kingbirdy on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:18PM (#17342423)
I'm curious why this needs its own definition, rather than being part of a larger "addiction disorder".
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by Mirioron on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:49PM (#17342602)
Because people who don't play games think it's weird that others are interested in things they don't like. So there must be something wrong with them.

There's a good reason why many psychologists and psychiatrists were against the inclusion of this in ICD-11 and why the DSM5 does not list it as an officially recognized disorder either.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by hkmurakami on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:41PM (#17342858)
Isn't it basically analogous to say sex addiction or porn addiction wrt the underlying psychology?
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by noobermin on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @12:29AM (#17343843)
FWIR sex/porn addiction is a suspect concept for many psychologists just like "masturbation addiction" is. One wonders whether such ideas are based in psychology vs. social attitudes of certain people similar to the attitudes those who think "masturbation addiction" is a thing.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by jt2190 on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:46PM (#17342581)
I’m told that the World Health Organization’s International Classification of Diseases (ICD) was created to help epidemiologists in different countries share data. It may be, and I’m speculating here, that it’s rather easy to get something added to it, as long as there are enough researchers somewhere in the world who want it added.

Someone here must know a little more about the process by which new things are added to the ICD.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by dragonwriter on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:38PM (#17342540)
Because there is no larger “addiction disorder”, and trying to create one would have a messy and complex definition compared to distinct definitions that happen to share some features.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by brandonjm on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:51PM (#17342611)
Yet the same organisation that seems to care so much about giving every little addiction it's own name also lumps every variety of autism under the same umbrella term.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by mmirate on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:02PM (#17342673)
Each addiction clearly and openly differs in the object of addiction.

Whereas, with autisms, we don't yet know how to analyze symptoms well enough for there to be a bijection between set-of-symptoms and underlying-autism-variant; indeed, we can barely even separate autism's causes and effects, if at all.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by Semirhage on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:22PM (#17342763)
The activity which is addictive varies, but the underlying physiological mechanism seems to be essentially identical from cocaine abuse to gambling. Defining the disorder by the pathology rather than an obtuse collection of symptoms which have a tendency to overlap and merge might be too much for psychology, but it’s the scientific thing.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by dragonwriter on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:46PM (#17342882)
> The activity which is addictive varies, but the underlying physiological mechanism seems to be essentially identical from cocaine abuse to gambling.

No, it doesn't. There seem to likely be some similar key mechanisms involved, but the shared mechanisms aren't the whole story, otherwise someone addicted to something would be addicted to everything.

We give different diagnoses for different allergies, even though allergies have a common key mechanism.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by mmirate on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:29PM (#17342802)
Well, that says more about the current state of the field of psychology, than about the task at hand. :)
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by toomanybeersies on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:28PM (#17343598)
Is video game addiction fundamentally different from gambling addiction?

Especially when comparing video poker machines, it's just like a video game.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by Raidion on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @10:16AM (#17346817)
I don't think so, gambling is based on the risk/reward thrill, coupled with the fact that "if I just hit the big one, I can do other activity that I want to do, but can't afford". I don't feel like many people go into the casino like, "if I win it big at $5, I'm gonna go play 100 dollar a hand blackjack!"

Video games don't have that risk/reward in as nearly as a tangible sense. Though you could argue that games like EVE Online, where in game resources have a direct comparison to hard cash. Ie, you can grind up a capital ship in game, or you can theoretically purchase enough ISK (in game currency, about $11,000 USD in this case) to buy one outright.

Video games have less risk/reward, are focused internally, and have more greed and achievement. If I'm able to clear this raid, I'm able to get X, which will allow me to do Y in the same game, which will make it easier to attempt Z, etc. No one plans to play 5 dollar blackjack so they can play 100 dollar blackjack.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by dragonwriter on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:44PM (#17342873)
> Yet the same organisation that seems to care so much about giving every little addiction it's own name

Because diagbostic criteria need to be different for different subject matter, and no suitable generalization had been identified.

> also lumps every variety of autism under the same umbrella term.

Because there is a continuum of manifestations and not clear differentiated kinds with crisp, clinically meaningful boundaries or subject matter.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by creep on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:53PM (#17342626)
This is the same with schizophrenia as well-- which is also a spectrum.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by gaius on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:22AM (#17344984)
A Skinner box is a Skinner box. Whether that’s a pokie (FOBT), a free-to-play game, a social network or anything else.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operant_conditioning_chamber#C...

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by contravariant on Monday June 18, 2018 @09:13PM (#17343017)
For what it's worth "Gaming" is broad enough to capture pretty much any 'non-chemical' activity that can be addicting.

There's a somewhat grey area between "Gaming" and "Gambling", but I think it's fair to consider "Gambling" a subset of "Gaming" where the games actually pay out money (or something of monetary value). This probably doesn't match the WHO definition though.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by gehwartzen on Monday June 18, 2018 @11:13PM (#17343534)
There are people that spend most of their available hours staring at screens of graphs while trading various tokens in order to achieve the highest score... but of course we call them professionals not addicts.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by sdiepend on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @07:47AM (#17345682)
There are people that spend most of their available hours playing video games against other players to get the most kills, wins, ... but of course we call them esports athletes.

For some people it's a job that generates income for others it's an addiction that impairs proper functioning.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by cabaalis on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @08:43AM (#17346019)
This seems to be the point of the issue.

What I heard on the radio was "do you lose your job, lose your wife/family, yet continue to play?"

So what about the case where playing the game IS your job (which is a growing field?) What about the case where your wife/family is playing it with you?

I'm not denying there might be some underlying destructive problem, but to my layman ears it sounds more like something someone is interested in that contradicts what another believes to be "properly functional."

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by mrguyorama on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @03:03PM (#17349402)
It should be: "do you lose your job, lose your wife/family, BECAUSE YOU continue to play?"

IE, instead of helping your wife do important things, you play a game. Instead of going to bed so you can wake up for work, you play another round, and as a result of not getting enough sleep, your performance suffers. Addiction is basically a mis-prioritization of resources due to abuse of brain chemistry. Worse, it is typically a feedback loop: "She left me, now I am sad, but the game activates my dopamine response, providing some semblance of happiness"

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by imtringued on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @06:33AM (#17345342)
Trading on an exchange is zero sum for the active participants and has secondary benefits like increased liquidity and less volatility for the passive participants.

Gambling is negative sum for all participants. The house is always going to win. The jackpots are just a user acquisition expense to trick even more participants into playing.

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by glastra on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @07:17AM (#17345532)
What about commissions on traded volume?
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by cbm-vic-20 on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @07:40AM (#17345649)
Hey, leave Eve Online out of this.
Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by berthe on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @12:27AM (#17343839)
> There are people that spend most of their available hours staring at screens of graphs while trading various tokens in order to achieve the highest score... but of course we call them professionals not addicts.

Not really, we call them workaholics (e.g. work-addicts) if they're so compelled to work that they can establish boundaries between it and the rest of their lives.

http://www.dictionary.com/browse/workaholic

Re:‘Gaming disorder’ is officially recognized by the World H... by nostrademons on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @05:44AM (#17345084)
Do we? In some professions (eg. investment banking, medicine, corporate law, fashion, entertainment) long hours are so ingrained in the culture that the rest of the world doesn't even bother to call them workaholics, because it's exceptionally unlikely that anyone from the rest of the world knows them on a personal level.