News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by sakarisson on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:10AM (#17292504)
So let me get this straight.

For the low price of $39 I will get the full book in ebook and HTML formats when it is done.

But for the price of $89 I will get extra chapters on Server-side rendering, Offline data and mutations, Serverless and Stripe integration.

So I am clearly not getting the full book for $39.

I just recently refused to buy a game for employing the same dishonest sales tactics, so this is an easy no thanks from me.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dlisboa on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:57AM (#17292766)
Honestly, I think people will disagree with me on this (due to some vague "you don't have to buy it" argument), but it's just too dishonest to me. This is possibly the biggest rip-off in pricing of any technical book I've ever seen.

If you pay $39 you get 8 fewer chapters than the actual full book. And it's online only, so no paper printing or publisher overhead. For $89 you get a video and some extra chapters (that really should be in the book you paid for in the first place). If you pay $289 (which is an absolute absurd price for any book) you get exactly what you used to get with books 10 years ago: a book with all its intended chapters, a mailing list, a glorified IRC channel and a code repo. Except, again, it's still not even a physical book (so why so expensive?).

If you pay the "Training" package ($749) you supposedly get superior in-person mentoring. Except it's not really done by the authors. It all sounds like some Tai Lopez scam.

I don't want to diminish the amount of work it took to make this book, or the quality of the authors. I'm sure it's incredible and it seems a pretty massive book. But I just don't understand these sort of things when it comes to professional programmers who write books. Supposedly they want to spread this technology they care about and want people to use it. We as programmers get paid very well, we're not in need of money. Book revenue is probably not their main source of income. So why price it out of everyone's range? You're not gonna reach nearly as many people as just selling it at a reasonable price.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by epicide on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:13AM (#17292867)
I'll preface this with the fact that I completely agree with your sentiment.

> it's still not even a physical book (so why so expensive?)

I have never written or published a book, but my understanding is that the cost of writing the book far outweighs the cost of actually printing it. Human time and knowledge is way more costly than some paper and the effort of a machine that spits out books by the second.

> If you pay $289 (which is an absolute absurd price for any book)

This offer and especially the in-person one seem like they are targeting businesses. A lot of places will pay orders of magnitude more to have someone work directly with their employees.

Honestly, about $93/hour is on the cheap side for in-person training. (I'm not saying it's good training or even close to worth it, just what the landscape looks like)

Edit: actually, it would be cheaper than $93/hour since I'm not taking the other things into account. Let's say the book and all the other stuff realistically make up about $150 of the price (I am guessing the $289 is just trying to get you to buy one of the surrounding tiers). That's actually $75/hour for the training.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dlisboa on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:34AM (#17293064)
> I have never written or published a book, but my understanding is that the cost of writing the book far outweighs the cost of actually printing it. Human time and knowledge is way more costly than some paper and the effort of a machine that spits out books by the second.

Usually physical books are said to be expensive because publishers are the ones holding the rights to them. They pay the authors in advance and try to recoup the cost later, with prices as high as the market will bear. The publishers have some fixed overhead in payroll (for editing, typography, art), printing, marketing, etc. Add to that the risk of the book not being finished by the author and the publisher's profit margin and it goes some ways to justify their pricing (or at least it makes it understandable). The authors then get only a slim percentage of the sales (if at all).

In this case the book isn't even finished, the full proceeds go to the authors (or so it seems) and the readers are expected to advance the money themselves to offset the costs of writing it. The overhead is vastly diminished, there's no publisher, the authors incur no risk, and yet the price is much higher. Makes no sense.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dean on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @11:18AM (#17294068)
> We as programmers get paid very well, we're not in need of money.

Speak for yourself.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by gowld on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:57PM (#17296699)
Would you feel better if they wrote 2 smaller books instead of 1 whole book, and the premium package included 2 books? WTF is "book" anyway? It's a web publication.

The cost of a book is in the IP, not the printing costs.

What is the maximum non-absurd price for a book?

Why do you think the authors are the only experts who can lead a useful training?

Which cost-effective GraphQL book should we buy instead?

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by workinthehead on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:43PM (#17298326)
You know, HN could really do without the person who constantly tells everyone how well-off we all are. Learn economics. And then hold your tongue next time.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by tgtweak on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:15AM (#17292521)
Day-0 DLC has arrived to technical literature. John really is ahead of the curve.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by btown on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:15AM (#17292881)
Errata can only be accessed via microtransactions. And loot boxes have a chance to drop full code samples... the F2P version leaves everything as an exercise for the reader.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by ygjb on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @12:47PM (#17295092)
Oh, oh no. There is a missed opportunity here. Common lootboxes drop a line of code, uncommon an entire method, rare, a full object, and legendary are working samples.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by btown on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:28PM (#17295590)
Hmm, you know, people want to forge their own legendary objects. Double the drop rate on working samples, but they’re obfuscated until you collect 3 of each code block. And you can sacrifice 10 useless one liners to be able to discover a block of your choice.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by rapfaria on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:30AM (#17293011)
And if he takes as much time as he took with "Secrets of the JavaScript Ninja", we may never even see DLC
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dominotw on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:01AM (#17293290)
I remember waiting like 2 years for manning 'javascript ninja' book that he never finished. I think someone else took over and finished that book.

https://www.manning.com/books/secrets-of-the-javascript-ninj...

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dsissitka on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:07PM (#17295336)
Some people had to wait four years.

The MEAP was released in 2008. Three years later Manning brought in a second author to finish the book. It was released in 2012.

A couple of quotes from https://johnresig.com/blog/secret-omens/:

> ...I got caught up in coding and stopped focusing on writing. I had to prioritize my time and I chose to prioritize doing more development and focusing on my personal life.

> ...I would absolutely not write a technical book again.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by pixel67 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:37PM (#17295696)
I remember this and I have both books which are excellent. Well, here I am again, contemplating getting which version of the book???
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by chaostheory on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:59PM (#17296712)
Maybe this is why he has a co-author this time around?
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dominotw on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @12:07PM (#17294644)
I bought that book solely based on author's fame. I got the book written by someone else. He offered no explantion as to why he stopped writing that book.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by jimmy1 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:08PM (#17295346)
And in the end, it ended up being an excellent book. I don't think this complaint fits here.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dominotw on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:20PM (#17295494)
It fits because I moved on from doing javascript, it was no use to me when all the chapters were finished. There was no compalint about the quality, yes it was excellent for the chapters i read.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by jimmy1 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:21PM (#17295499)
But you knew you were paying for an unfinished book ahead of time, so why did you base your decision to "do javascript" on unfinished work?
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by dominotw on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @01:27PM (#17295566)
Yes I knew but I wasn't expecting to wait 4 yrs and receive a book written by a completely different person.

He is offering people to buy another unfinished book so my comment is relevant in this context.

I didn't base by decision to write javascript on book, merely pointing out that book was no use for me after 4 yrs.

Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by castis on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:41AM (#17292672)
You're not even getting the full book for $89, the extra chapters stop at $289.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by sgdesign on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:16AM (#17292887)
So would you be happier if only the $39 price point was available, without any of the extra chapters? Then you wouldn't have the other price point to make you feel like you're missing out on something?
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by jhall1468 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @11:05AM (#17293903)
How about he releases the entire book at a reasonable price point that isn't $250. It's unfortunate that John is playing games with pricing. This entire pricing scheme feels like something EA would cook up and that is NOT good optics.
Re:John Resig: Introducing the GraphQL Guide by sakarisson on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:56AM (#17293810)
I would be happier if they didn't lie to me and claim that $39 will get me the full book. I would be even happier if they didn't go the video game route and add several purchase tiers including day-0 DLC. It's manipulative and will make me feel like I missed out if I opt for one of the cheaper options.