News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @03:55PM (#17287942)
This is something that has been on my mind a lot over the past few years, having gone through an ugly, costly divorce and having watched friends stay in rotten marriages. Relationships come in a lot of forms, and we lack vocabulary, laws, and social acceptance for many of them. My mother's partner of more than ten years is still legally married to someone else, because to divorce would set off financial destruction for both parties. My "partpanion" and I call each other that because partner is so clinical, companion so incomplete, other terms like "significant other" a strange twist of the language. Can a seventy-year old really be a "girlfriend / boyfriend"? We will likely never marry, and to make things odder, "domestic partnership" can now only be made legally binding here for older people, presumably for the purpose of making it easier to deal with things like medical-power-of-attorney in the event of poor health. And then there are all the people I know who stay in terrible marriages either because of kids, money, religion... I kinda like some of these examples from the article that are so "live and let live" accepting of humanity, so long as we are good to each other and providing nurture to any children produced. Until that time, the lawyers sure make out like bandits.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by patmcc on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:13PM (#17289085)
>> My mother's partner of more than ten years is still legally married to someone else, because to divorce would set off financial destruction for both parties.

This is something I really don't understand. If both parties want the divorce and can agree on any asset splits, a divorce costs whatever the filing fee is. A few hundred dollars and you're done.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:39PM (#17289249)
Wouldn't that be nice? No - marriage over 20 years, spousal support for life. Money came from an inheritance? Not part of the so-called 50/50 split. Kids involved? Are you male? Get ready to get screwed - either you go bankrupt to get your kids or you lose your kids. Are the significant assets at stake? Then these things are never simple, and if they are the lawyers are going to make sure that they aren't because they want their share of the action.

I am in full agreement with you - the majority of divorces should be simple. They should be a form you complete in a clerks office. But that's not how it actually goes, unless both parties are very, very agreeable, and even then you'd better hope the judge is in a good mood and doesn't overrule what you've both agreed to (no I'm not kidding).

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by gamblor956 on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:49PM (#17289300)
Inheritance isn't considered community property. It is the sole property of the heir spouse except to the extent explicitly gifted to the union.

That aside, assets can be divided up without involving lawyers. Indeed, hiring lawyers is the pretty much the one thing you can do to guarantee that the divorce will be acrimonious, because the lawyers could care less about your (or your soon-to-be-ex spouse's) feelings.

I've never seen a judge throw out an amicable divorce settlement drawn up by parties without their own lawyers. At most, they required the divorcing parties to have the agreement looked over by a lawyer to make sure it satisfied necessary legal requirements.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:35PM (#17289541)
>I've never seen a judge throw out an amicable divorce settlement drawn up by parties without their own lawyers.

And I had three lawyers warn me of exactly this scenario. I'm not saying you are wrong, I'm saying as a lay-person that the law is very frustrating.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by dsnuh on Monday June 11, 2018 @08:32PM (#17289806)
>I'm saying as a lay-person that the law is very frustrating.

This was my experience as well. I've been wondering if there is an audience for tools to help people going through a divorce, especially for those in the tech industry, since there are often complicated concerns over stock options, RSUs, 401k, bonus plans, etc. that are included in most tech worker's total compensation (btw - this is what you use to calculate support, not salary) that can. I had a very hard time finding help during my divorce for complicated topics such as these, and had to turn to many costly specialists to apply their formulas to determine community property.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by gamblor956 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @02:08AM (#17291062)
If you have complicated assets prior to the marriage, like RSUs, you may want to hire a lawyer simply because RSUs are tricky beasts even if you're not getting married.

But otherwise, the Nolo Prenuptial guide is sufficient for most marriages and is in fact the guide that judges in SoCal will recommend.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by patmcc on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:37PM (#17289546)
>>unless both parties are very, very agreeable

This is the real problem, I think - people can't seem to split agreeably. If you have a good solution for that I'm sure we can clean up all the messy divorces. Until then though...not sure what options we have.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by dsnuh on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:51PM (#17289313)
Let them downvote you. You're absolutely spot on.

I suspect the downvote is because you brought up gender. You aren't supposed to point out that there are differences in the way men and women are treated upon leaving a marriage.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by lazyasciiart on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:20PM (#17289465)
Well, that and because he appears to be saying "this happened to me and therefore it happens 100% of the time to everyone", which isn't true.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:32PM (#17289522)
Did I anywhere use the words "this happens 100% of the time"? No, I shared a personal reflection, plus would be happy to rattle off about ten more examples if you'd like. Once I get my life back in order, I intend to petition the Washington State Legislature, because I am not happy about laws that enabled my nut-job ex to use the legal system to her whims while leaving me on the edge of bankruptcy. I would like to believe this was not the legislature or courts intents, yet I have at this point read many accounts of exactly this scenario. So quit putting words in my mouth that I didn't use and cite some of your own counter-facts if you feel otherwise.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by dsnuh on Monday June 11, 2018 @08:00PM (#17289666)
I'm in California, but facing much the same situation. I've said it before and I will say it again... I think people are ignorant of divorce laws and simply do not realize how much financial damage a motivated (i.e. nut-job) ex can get cause if they decide they want to.

To give an example, I have my 2 kids almost 50/50 split custody (I have them 6pm Thursday to 6pm Sunday) and had my child support set at $1700 per month. This was on top of an additional $1800 per month of spousal support, which I had to give up my 401k to pay off because I couldn't afford that much monthly expense). My ex makes variable income of $3,500 to $5000 per month working part time as a wedding photographer. My wages are garnished, and if I ever have a change in circumstances, I will have to go through a lengthy court process just for a shot at that. In the meantime, I would be responsible for the original amount plus interest until such time as the court saw fit to change it.

I'm a good father. I love my kids and want to support them. The way the system is currently structured, if you made more money than your spouse during the marriage, you have to provide the same "lifestyle" as you had during the marriage to your children, regardless if they are in your care or not. I struggle to make ends meet, while my ex is able to live comfortably, take them on numerous expensive vacations, etc. because so much of my income is given to the other party as child support, but can spent as they see fit.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:45PM (#17289282)
A downvote, really? Must be a lawyer in the crowd. Having just finished spending $15,000 and two years of my life on this, I'm not exactly happy with our legal system.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by pm24601 on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:38PM (#17289553)
Hmmm try again.

Here are some more common barriers. Notice that these are 'assets' that are not controlled by the couple:

* Social Security with survivor benefits * Pension payouts * Health Insurance coverage (1 person's job has HC, the other doesn't)

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by Thlom on Monday June 11, 2018 @04:51PM (#17288474)
In Scandinavia we have the term "kjæreste" which roughly translates to "most beloved". When I think about I believe it's only in Norway and Sweden we have that word. In Sweden they have the word ælskling which means much the same thing. Both used in much the same way as boyfriend/girlfriend, but without the gender and without the implied youth so can be used by both young and old.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by hikarudo on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:27PM (#17289163)
Would "dearest" be close to "kjæreste"?
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by simongr3dal on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:38PM (#17289241)
Spot on.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by implying on Monday June 11, 2018 @05:00PM (#17288547)
The Danes have this word too, I found it missing from English vocabulary while learning the language.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @04:56PM (#17288508)
Love it! I think this moment is the birth of a new English loanword.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by therein on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:49PM (#17289297)
It would be if `kjæreste` didn't have `æ` in it and were easy to pronounce for an English speaker.
Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by cat199 on Monday June 11, 2018 @07:45PM (#17289583)
The glyph `æ` is part of the english language.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%86#English

generally it is not used in the us, as we have dropped it.

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by 0x00000000 on Monday June 11, 2018 @04:56PM (#17288516)
>"domestic partnership" can now only be made legally binding here for older people

In some places it can be made legally binding against your will https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palimony_in_the_United_States

Re:I Now Pronounce You Legally Null and Void by poulsbohemian on Monday June 11, 2018 @05:14PM (#17288656)
Yes! That's why I think our legal situation in Washington state is such a mess. I found at least 8 cases in my own divorce where the law was just plain stupid and harmful. I'm glad that homosexuals can now marry, but when that law went into effect, it also broke the existing domestic partnership laws and created a huge grey area. My lady friend and I are forming an implicit partnership, but we have no legal way to formalize it - and as you point out, if something were to go sideways in the future, you can be held accountable as though it were "legal" but without there being codified law making the rules-of-the-game clear.