News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by mehrdadn on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:18AM (#17263799)
Dumb question: What is the difference (implication-wise) between being overclocked at 5GHz and not-being-overclocked but still at 5GHz? My CPU (just like any other modern CPU) limits its clock speed to regulate its own temperature despite the fact that it's not even unlocked to let me overclock it, so it's not the difference is throttling. So what's the difference?
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by pdpi on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:37AM (#17263879)
When you say “here’s a 5GHz CPU” you expect it to fit with the current product lineup and to have thermal and power requirements within certain parameters that would allow you to run the thing at 5GHz without much effort.

“We overclocked this CPU to 5GHz” means all bets are off. You often have some headroom to overclock on stock voltage/cooling but always need to go above and beyond for more extreme overclocking. This particular setup apparently was using a very fancy 1700ish W chiller, and a 1300W PSU for the chassis itself.

Also, this is a Xeon part, so one you’d expect to see in servers or workstations. You don’t want that sort of thermals anywhere close to a data centre rack, and the sort of business with the budget to give you this sort of CPU wouldn’t want to have their IT department assembling custom coolers like this.

All of this assumes, of course, you can run the chip stably. That's more or less a given at stock speeds, operating within the vendor's operational specs. Once you start overclocking, all bets are off. Extreme overclocking (the sort that uses liquid nitrogen or this sort of chiller) never lasts long. Again, something an enthusiast overclocking for a few FPS on a gaming rig might be willing to live with, but a problem that's seriously disruptive in the sort of environment a Xeon is likely to be deployed.

(EDIT: Fixed chiller power and added stability concerns)

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by NullPrefix on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:14AM (#17264040)
>fancy 1kW chiller

It was 1770W, not 1000W

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by dingo_bat on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:36AM (#17264122)
The mobo had a 16 phase power delivery system designed to pump 1kw into the CPU itself. Kind of mindblowing actually.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by parimm on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:24AM (#17264283)
The chiller unit consumes 1kW of power

and produces 1.7kW of cooling

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by yyx on Saturday June 09, 2018 @08:03AM (#17272612)
Can you get 1kW of power from 1.7kW of cooling to power chiller unit?
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by jboles on Sunday June 10, 2018 @07:30PM (#17280715)
Yes. The chiller unit consumes 1kW to move 1.7kW of heat off the CPU. It then has to dissipate 2.7kW.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by tutanchamun on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:49AM (#17263961)
The guarantee to get a CPU which can run stable 5ghz on all cores within the TDP limit and only requiring a cooling solution which can handle the TDP.

If you need to overclock you don't get this and have to buy more expensive cooling and probably need to de-lit (remove the heatspreader) of your above 2000 dollar CPU (which can permanently damage it) to improve the thermals because Intel - unlike AMD - didn't solder their heatspreader. Even then, you're not guaranteed to get a chip which can run 5 ghz on all cores 24/7. The best 18 core HEDT from Intel I have seen to date was running 4.5ghz on all cores 24/7 with delidding and a custom loop.

The 28 core Xeon which this probably is based upon runs 2.5 ghz stock and can boost to 3.8 ghz on a single core (3 or 3.2 ghz on all cores I believe).

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by gaius on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:04AM (#17264009)
What is the difference (implication-wise) between being overclocked at 5GHz and not-being-overclocked but still at 5GHz

It’s like extrapolating from an athletes 100m sprint time to their Marathon time. In other words, taking peak performance and presenting it as something that can be sustained for long periods.

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by floatboth on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:45AM (#17265266)
This analogy is not about overclocking in general: if you OC for daily use you run stress tests and make sure it's stable.

But yeah, this is absolutely the case with the Intel demo. Their demo proved that the chip can run Cinebench at 5GHz.

Cinebench is not the heaviest load and it finishes very, very quickly. If they showed Prime95 AVX with small FFTs running for a couple hours, that would count as stable :D

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by geezerjay on Friday June 08, 2018 @08:12AM (#17264517)
That's a great analogy.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by captainbland on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:22AM (#17263822)
I guess they're just trying to say it won't be released as a 5GHz stock clockspeed - it probably goes over their TDP limits.

Edit: And here I learn to read the article first: It's almost definitely that they couldn't achieve it with stock air cooling based on the setup described in the article.

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by zaarn on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:31AM (#17263864)
I think going over the TDP limits is putting it lightly considering it was outputting 2 watts per square millimeter.

For comparison, a Ryzen 1800X does 0.49 watts per square millimeter and has a lot less square millimeters (probably less than half)

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by tutanchamun on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:53AM (#17263978)
The Xeon 28 core part seems to be 698mm² [0] while the AMD Ryzen 1800X is 213mm²

[0] https://www.anandtech.com/show/11839/intel-core-i9-7980xe-an...

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by cjslep on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:23AM (#17263824)
"Not being overclocked" at 5GHz means the system is designed to run at that speed off the shelf without becoming molten slag and without aftermarket industrial grade cooling systems.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by mehrdadn on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:31AM (#17263865)
So it's not the fact that it was overclocked that matters, but the fact that it required aftermarket cooling, right? Like my current CPU cannot get within 100MHz of its supposed max TurboBoost frequency due to (I presume) cooling limits, despite the fact that I haven't overclocked it, so for me to even get the frequency it is marketed as I would need aftermarket cooling... which seems like the same problem despite the lack of overclocking, right?
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by zaarn on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:38AM (#17263892)
Well, the aftermarket cooling in the presentation was a 1HP sub-ambient cooling solution (though one image shows the system with a rating of 1.7kW)

The entire system pulled over 2kW of power, a lot of that dedicated to cooling.

This isn't merely "you need aftermarket cooling" but rather "you need to dedicated serious resources to cooling this".

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by fian on Friday June 08, 2018 @08:52AM (#17264779)
2kW is right about the wattage of a small electric fan heater for comparison. So regardless of how they made it look, anyone standing near it should have felt warmer.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by simion314 on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:54AM (#17263983)
People are overclocking using liquid Nitrogen for getting records but that is not something you can use practically, the backlash against what Intel did is that this overclock was hard to pull for regular use, it used so much power for cooling that some people on reddit suggested that you can't pull it from a regular power wall socket in some countries, also the demo was run for a few seconds that implies that if you would run it for a few minutes you may lose the ability to cool it enough and you will get less frequency.

A really cool feature the new AMD CPUs have is that they have a very well implemented turbo, if you give it good cooling it will know how to exploit it and give you more power.

As a side note, is a weird feeling running a 4 core/4 threads CPU when now workstation CPUs could reach up to 64 threads

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by montalbano on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:37AM (#17263886)
Overclocking sometimes invalides warantee.

Overclocking almost always shortens life expectancy of the CPU.

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by mehrdadn on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:41AM (#17263914)
Ahh, so the difference is the voiding of the warranty? If so then this seems to explain why it would be more than a naming issue.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by floofyreal on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:28AM (#17264089)
He didn't mean it like that (or at least I think he didn't). Imagine it like person walking/running - When you are expect to walk at some pace (5GHz) you can do it proficiently for long time, considering you get your regular inputs and outputs taken care of (basic cooling, regular power drain), when you overclock - run, you need much more care to be able to run for a long time (stronger cooling, more power headroom, overclocking motherboard).

What Intel in this demo did is strapped you behind the car and drove a 100 meters dash proclaiming - look he survived, he 'ran' that 100 meters run like a champ, it's possible to run this fast.

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by NullPrefix on Friday June 08, 2018 @06:16AM (#17264050)
It's in the category of "It may or may not work, YMMV, don't call us if you mess up".
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by JustSomeNobody on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:35AM (#17264328)
It is the fact that it was overclocked because not every part can be overclocked the same.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by syrgian on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:37AM (#17263881)
Many times the announced max frequency is for single-core usage. If you're using all the cores they all have to slow down collectively so the whole CPU doesn't overheat.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by mehrdadn on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:37AM (#17263885)
Everything I'm talking about is single-threaded use only.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by buserror on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:24AM (#17263833)
It changes the maximum speed attainable by that CPU, and allows to maintain it for longer.

You can change pretty easily the maximum clock multiplier the CPU is allowed to use (on K CPUs at least) -- but doing so without proper cooling and proper power supply will just crash.

SOME 'good' bin CPU can be overclocked a fair amount without extra power/cooling, but it's always touch an go.

My workstation still has a 4600K i7 that has been running at 5ghz for probably 5 years, without even pushing the voltage. It's in fact a lot quicker (single thread) than a more modern system I built since. That was a "good bin"! the 4500 and 4600 were known for their overclock potential.

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by Sohcahtoa82 on Friday June 08, 2018 @03:25PM (#17268874)
If you buy a car that has an engine that produces 400 horsepower, you can reasonably expect it to run reliably. Every part will have been designed to handle the power output of that engine.

On the flip side, if you buy a car that has an engine that produces only 200 horsepower, but then add a large turbocharger that boosts the output to 400 horsepower, you're likely to run into problems. The cooling system might not keep up. The engine block internals might not be able to handle the extra pressure. The transmission or differential might not be able to survive the excess torque. Your clutch might slip.

Similar idea to a CPU. Transistors can only switch so fast. If you buy a CPU that Intel labels as a 5 Ghz CPU, Intel is guaranteeing those transistors can switch fast enough to maintain that clock speed. If you buy one that's only 4 Ghz and try to overclock it, there might be some transistors in that chip that can't switch that fast. Increasing voltage can help, but now you're creating more heat.

Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by Symmetry on Friday June 08, 2018 @07:52AM (#17264414)
For extreme overclocking like this I'd expect the voltages and temperatures involved to result in a lot of electromigration inside the chip, wearing it out and causing it to stop functioning eventually.
Re:Intel: We 'Forgot' to Mention 28-Core, 5-GHz CPU Demo Was... by dreta on Friday June 08, 2018 @05:29AM (#17263855)
The CPU requiring a massive cooling system to run at the advertised frequency is an important information to share with the consumer.