I'm seriously baffled here as to who is supposed to benefit from this. The only possibility is some kind of misguided attempt at forestalling the draw down of fossil fuels, which is inevitable.
The whole reason that these tariffs came in to effect was that some failed manufacturers brought the issue. My understanding is that the manufacturers failed not because it's impossible to do in the US, but simply because of poor management decisions or betting on the wrong technology.
The real question is whether the tariffs will be around long enough to incentivize any new manufacturing capacity in the US. They will almost certainly be slapped down by the WTO in a short amount of time, as previous tariffs like this have been. So by the time anybody could make more manufacturing capacity, it seems likely that the tariffs will no longer be around to support the facility. So new facilities must be planned on the basis of profitability without the tariffs.
Even in this environment, there is new production being planned. However, the jobs associated with this are dwarfed by the number of jobs related to installation of panels. So while this will certainly be a net negative to the US economy in the short term, without much opportunity to provide positive impact.
Basically, just a meaningless PR move by a politician. I don't think it will cause hugely detrimental effects either, it's just stupid.
The US manufacturers couldn't compete on cost because critical materials were either solely available or so low cost, from China, that it drove competition out of the material markets in the US. This is one of those, ask any manufacturer, rather than a guess. Then factor in labor costs and you ended up with yet-another-chinese-dominant market where improvements were done in China snowballing the situation to today.
Panels themselves are only about a third in the cost; therefore it rarely makes sense to go with the cheapest panels. Higher quality, longer life span, higher cost panels tend to win out because higher efficiency means more energy per panel and those other costs are often per panel.
This is more extreme in the residential market where the panel costs are an even smaller fraction of the cost.
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/17/business/energy-environme...
http://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/261363-us-hits-...
Obama doing something bad does not justify current bad actions. It does not make complaining about the current tariffs hypocritical. I would agree 100% with Jigar Shah's opinion about the prior tariffs:
>“Taxing solar trade undermines both the spirit and efficacy of pledges made by the U.S. and China to work together in the battle against global warming,” Jigar Shah, president of the Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy, said in a statement.
But those prior tariffs were not identical in their form. The Obama tariffs were on a single country, China, for specific actions. The current tariffs are almost worldwide, for no clear reason at all. They benefit few jobs, and the investors that benefit are not from the US. Obama's actions were less than ideal, but at least they made a tiny bit of sense.
True, except those operations are owned by foreign companies, right? Particularly... Germany and China.
Keep in mind it's not just being used for transportation and heating it's being used for more or less everything. Your computer, your raincoat, your tires, your trashcan, all the products you buy at amazon, in hospital equipment, your furniture etc.
It's hard to find anything that is as flexible as fossil fuel, unfortunately.
https://www.openaccessgovernment.org/lets-honest-gas-oil-not...
All the more reason to stop _literally setting it on fire_ when avoidable.
It's not as simple as many would like to believe.
Fuels' primary advantage are their density of storage. But as the cheapness of renewables comes to dominate energy production--i.e. the cost of intermittent renewable will soon be cheaper than even just the fossil fuel cost of energy--we'll see price swings based on the variability of renewable production, and the mismatch between the time of supply and demand.
With electric cars, every home will have ~2-4 days worth of storage in their garage. Charging the cars will present one area of time-flexible demand, to suck up the variable production.
For the seasonal variability of renewable energy, it might make sense to store energy from the more productive season for use in the less productive season. However, synthetic fuels are quite inefficient, round trip, if you're making them from scratch, lets say 50% at best.
If the seasonal price swings are greater than 2x, then I think we'll see some synthetic fuels made as long term storage, as long as synthetic fuels can be made cheaply enough. See for example this other front page post for current best-case estimates:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17257291
However, in the long term (50 years?), there's no room for fossil fuels. They will just be too expensive compared to renewable energy to make economic sense. Synthetic fuels, perhaps, but not fossil fuels.
It's not just a matter of the market and political will, there are some fundamental limits on how much energy we can get from solar and wind.
They are linear solutions to exponential problems so to speak.
I have yet to see any calculation based in realistic metrics (not just wishful thinking) that outphases oil. I hope for it as much as everyone else but I am not prepared to do it at any price.
> It's not just a matter of the market and political will,
That's absolutely untrue, nuclear is waaaaaaay too expensive and old-fashioned to compete in the modern world.
Take a few seconds to look at any of the attempts at construction in the Western world. Nuclear is super expensive, and not nearly scalable enough. In the US, Vogtle and VC Summer have been nuclear disasters, but economic disasters. They had a super-supportive regulatory environment and neighbors around the construction sites, but it's just not feasible to build at a reasonable cost.
Nuclear is such a terrible idea that there's no way to get private funding for it; it has to have huge amounts of government level backing for it to become even vaguely economic feasible. Look at the UK's attempts to sell their nuclear generation capacity, all of a sudden when they were writing financial documents they had to not lie, and they couldn't get anybody to buy them. And now the UK has the economic disaster of the new Hinkley construction.
There's a batch of small-moduler reactor (SMR) startups that may improve the cost and scalability of nuclear, but I'm extremely skeptical. Such SMRs have long been rejected as too costly, it's not at all clear what would make them competitive now. It may happen, but it's further out than the massive scale-back of fossil fuels.
> there are some fundamental limits on how much energy we can get from solar and wind.
These "fundamental" limits are not in the realm of possibility of limiting our current use.
>They are linear solutions to exponential problems so to speak.
I'm not sure what part could be exponential. Our energy use is nothing like exponential, and in developed countries it is increasingly decoupled from GDP and other exponential things. Most of our "energy" use is actually wasted energy due to the inherent inefficiency of thermal electricity generation, or, god forbid, the pathetic efficiency of combustion engines in vehicles.
We don't yet have applications for energy that could come close to any "fundamental limit" from solar. If we do, then perhaps fusion or something will be useful, but fusion is even more of a pipedream than trying to construct
Solar and wind would also be expensive if they hadn't been subsidized.
Nuclear has killed fewer people than coal, fossil fuel, wind and solar. Plus once built it last for a very very long time.
Perhaps you should take a few seconds to look at the actual data. There is nothing old-fashioned about nuclear especially not the new types of reactors and there is certainly no other form of energy besides fusion which can provide the amount of energy nuclear can.
So no nuclear is the idea you should support if you actually care about the environment. Solar is toxic to the environment and requires quite a lot to keep functioning wind is the same.
To get wind and solar to work consistently and reliably through some sort of grid system is going to be a project many many times bigger than nuclear and it's not going to be the increasing demand from the developing countries where more and more people get into the middle class.
So you are from my perspective completely wrong about your idea of solar and wind as being the future of energy for the world. They are not and will not be. They simply aren't reliable and scaleable enough sources fuell cells or not.
It's all a fantasy. The only reason that nuclear gets built is so that a country can support their nuclear submarines/aircraft carriers.
Nuclear energy is not a realistic solution to anything, because building it is not realistic.
>Solar and wind would also be expensive if they hadn't been subsidized.
The entirety of nuclear has been subsidized as the technology has been created, just as solar and wind have.
What matters now is what can be built. Nuclear can not be built without spending 3x-5x what we'd spend for equivalent wind or solar. And that's ignoring the cases where billions of dollars have been spent and then completely abandoned.
Your doubt of solar and wind are at least 10 years out of date. As are your nuclear ideas, because they were the same things being said in 2008 during the "nuclear renaissance." It all proved to be completely false. Westinghouse was given a shot, and it continues to end up blowing up Westinghouse's parent company, Toshiba.
If you can not address the specifics of Westinghouse, Toshiba, VC Summer, Vogtle, or Hinckley, then you are just spreading outdated propaganda.
And you could get those hydrocarbon from renewable sources. They just happen to be practically free when we’re extracting and burning such massive amounts of fossile oil/gas
Completely agreed. We will be flying around in kerosene powered airliners, and burning natural gas for electricity for a long, long time to come. But that doesn't mean it won't draw down to a fraction of what it is today. Personal vehicle gasoline consumption, for example, will be almost nonexistent in 20 years.
(And that's assuming it wasn't simply shifted from gasoline ICEs to natural gas power plants.)
Believe it. Heavy equipment is a prime candidate for electrification. Mining companies are already using electric dump trucks in production, and they are incredibly more efficient because of regen braking with the mass differential of unloading at the bottom of a hill [0]. Literally anything that isn't dependent on the energy density of hydrocarbons will be electrified in the next few decades. That leaves basically aircraft and spacecraft as consumers outside the petrochemical and energy industry.
[0] http://revolution-green.com/worlds-first-electric-dump-truck...
Indeed: this policy, like many others, just makes me think, "own goal."
I'm genuinely interested in hearing your reasoning.
The first, from the Chinese side, is the demonstration that the US can and will impact the immediate Chinese economy. That coldwar tactic is on the table (while open warfare in the south sea is not). Take the tariffs off, move on to a tariff on toys tomorrow.
From the US side, the government has a tacit approval to bring up other relationship imbalances that have gone on for too long. The fact that my machines are attacked by Chinese IPs more often than any other locality (via casual IP lookups) makes me think that this is actually part of a greater response to various Chinese incursions into various arenas in the world (not the least of which is the US infrastructure).
Another good is in regard to the impact on the US manufacturing base. Dealing with the fact that costing in existing processes and materials (based on abroad cheap labor and materials) is not reliable, is an important step. This will force higher capital investment into experimental materials and processes for alternatives (maybe with other 3rd party countries). There will also be a boon to choice US companies that the federal government favor, through existing and new contracts where these tariffs will otherwise be abated. It's not going to kill every existing company, but it hurts a lot. This is a future-investment move. It's possible it's a misstep and we will never have anything better than steel and cheap plastics, but I doubt it.
There is the geo-political arena to consider. The US has been in a cold war with China since after WW2, same as we have with Russia. The moves with regard to North Korea are suspicious. North Korea has been the heel of China for some time. NK has had no way to bargain, with anyone, much less their greatest benefactor. Setting a stake against China then making overtures to NK allows NK (KimJong) to consider becoming a valuable Geopolitical figure and US partner in a critical area, surpassing south korea (for once). It just happened to coincide (I have a feeling Trump is ironically talented at speaking to KJ) and happened to influence the ultimate decision to place the tariffs at this time.
I'm assuming you meant "it beats the cost of coal"?
Sorry, I'm confused. Did you mean the other in one of those two sentences, or am I misreading? If you did, which one?
EDIT: Ah, I see the sibling comment, thanks.
Solar takes space. It takes far more land than coal-fired plants. But land prices are going up and everyone expects interest rates to go up too. So how can they afford to acquire and maintain the needed land at these prices?
If the cost of land is going up, then it's an asset that after the 20-30 year lifetime of the project could be sold for a profit. Therefore, the "cost" of the land is just the financing cost, and the cost of capital has been very low up until now. We'll see what happens with interest rates...
If the land is productive, i.e. for grazing or farming, then the profit from solar must be compared to the profit of the agricultural activity. But there's so much unproductive land that it's doubtless that solar makes a lot of sense.
And even for agricultural activity, there's soooo much excess agricultural production of corn and soybeans, that with only very modest amounts of incentive (in the form of tax incentives), investors will put solar panels on land that had been farmed previously. You'll see it all over the countryside in Minnesota these days.
Edit: Let me back this up with some numbers. Figure 28 of this NREL PDF [1] puts land acquisition at $0.03/W - $0.04/W out of the $1.03/Wdc cost of large fixed tilt systems. Here's an OSU article [2] that puts solar leases of farm land at $1600/acre/30years, which apparently looks to be a great deal for farmers in Ohio.
[1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68925.pdf
[2] https://u.osu.edu/extensioncd/2017/02/23/considerations-for-...
The real problem with agriculture these days have been caused by subsidizing industrial production of basically two crops, corn and beans. Farms were smaller a generation ago, and produced more diverse kinds of crops as well -- actual food crops. For example, much of the corn goes straight to ethanol plants these days.
Ethanol that causes wear and tear on cars while producing approximately the same energy that was used in fossil fuels to produce the ethanol.
Worse yet are the sugar tariffs. We would be better off if we got rid of the tariff then paid each person involved in growing sugarcane to not work. As https://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2017/01/18/if-us-su... says, this policy would be estimated to make the USA approximately $1 billion per year richer.
Government intervention frequently results in perverse incentives that produce nonsensical results.
Ethanol isn't great on it's own, but added to gasoline in small amounts, it reduces emissions & smog.
According to https://www.nature.com/news/ethanol-fuels-ozone-pollution-1.... there are contradictory theories, but experimental evidence says that it increases smog. According to https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/reduce-air-pollut... even ethanol in the quantities used in the USA is worse for public health than straight gasoline without anything added.
Ethanol has been promoted as a ‘green’ fuel because its combustion tends to produce lower emissions of carbon dioxide, hydrocarbons and NOx than petrol. But the impact on air quality of a wholesale transition from petrol to ethanol has been difficult to assess, with different atmospheric chemistry models predicting a variety of consequences. [...] air-quality campaigners should not start advocating for petrol instead of ethanol quite yet. Increased petrol burning clearly raised levels of NOx, which also poses direct health concerns, and it probably boosted the amount of particulate matter in the air, something the study did not look at. And because every city has its own unique air chemistry, a similar fuel switch might produce very different results in London or Los Angeles. Nevertheless, says Salvo, the findings illustrate that “ethanol is not a panacea”.
So, maybe I'm wrong in claiming it reduces smog, due to an ozone increase at the same time as NOx is decreased. The important point though, is why ethanol is interesting in the first place. It's not supposed to be a petrol replacement, it's an additive to modify the combustion. Specifically, by increasing the oxygen available in the combustion chamber for more complete combustion- aka a fuel oxygenate.
The second link, FWIW, specifically addresses "ethanol as fuel", which is different from "ethanol as additive to improve emissions of petrol".
"Fueling the automobile fleet primarily with ethanol rather than gasoline might increase air pollution"
Environmental engineer Mark Jacobson of Stanford University used a computer model to assess how the air pollution in the U.S. would react if vehicles remained primarily fueled by gasoline in 2020 or if the fleet transferred to a fuel that was a blend of 85 percent ethanol and 15 percent gasoline, so-called E85.
The reason why it remains politically interesting is that you can't become President without doing well in the Iowa primary, and Iowa is full of corn farmers whose income benefits directly from our ethanol policies. So every Presidential nominee from both parties have been vocally been for ethanol for some time now. And most major candidates as well. (Ted Cruz managed to get away with opposing ethanol, but I can't think of another.)
https://www.epa.gov/gasoline-standards/gasoline-winter-oxyge...
So a smaller fraction of the fuel than used in Brazil, nowhere near E-85.
It replaced MTBE¹, which contaminates groundwater.
Prior to the 2000s, the electrical utilities had basically static and unchanging technology, which meant that utilities could use long-established price estimates when determining technologies.
No longer is that possible, solar, wind and storage are dropping so fast in costs that it can be hard to keep pace. A California utility recently tried to get bids for a new gas peaker plant, unaware that storage was now cost competitive, because they were using cost estimates that were only a few years old.
And the NextEra CEO, quoted in the article above I linked, said way back in 2015 that by 2020, no more gas peaker plants would be built.
This is a revolution, where costs are falling faster than even the most enthusiastic boosters were expecting.
I wonder though if it is safe to predict a continuous drop in panel prices. A few years ago Germany saw prices rise due to increased demand, demand fuels ironically by subsidies. And there is a good chance that the US administration might deliberately cripple the solar market, either by increasing costs or reducing demand (ie the proposed mandate to buy coal/nuclear energy first). Give that unpredictability, these low bids are more business strategy than a reflection of actual costs structures.
If you think that these providers are going to default, well, then that's a bet you can make. But these are the people with skin in the game that are betting real, actual money and the future of their companies.
And consider that even if the footprint of a coal plant is smaller, that doesn't mean it would be cheaper. Coal plants have huge construction costs, and unlike solar, have huge ongoing costs to remediate their waste products. Plus there's the cost of buying and trucking in the fuel.
Here's a 120 megawatt project advertised as needing 1000 acres:
https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2017/04/120-mw-first-s...
So coal plants really are a lot more compact than solar, and they do their nameplate capacity nearly 24/7.
Which hey, bring on the solar, but expect it to use a lot of land, especially when/if energy intensive industries switch to using it.
https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2017/09/berkeley-labs-...
Average capacity factor for utility scale solar PV is 27% in the US:
https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph...
That would put O&M costs at
18000 / (24 * 365 * 0.27) = $7.60 per megawatt hour, out of a total price quoted by epistasis of $30-$32 per megawatt hour. O&M could be up to 25% of total costs. It is indeed, a significant part of total costs. It is also a smaller fraction of total costs dedicated to O&M than wind or fossil power (including fuel in O&M).
Honestly, WY would be a better place for this, but the state government has its head way too far up the coal industries rear for that to get much traction.
Without numbers in front of me, I'd guess that most of Colorado is not trees and mountains. Plains on one side, desert on the other. Plenty of room to put up panels and not remove a single tree.
https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2018/06/07/worlds-largest-lithiu...
They're planning a GWh of grid storage attached to 700MW of solar, at a cost of 3.0-3.2 cents/kWh, which completely beats the cost of coal. And that's without taking in to account coal's massive costs that it doesn't pay, in terms of our health (COPD, mercury consumption in fish, etc...).
We have some absolutely awful leadership in this area that is trying to kneecap the future of our country. Colorado's process makes me hopeful that by 2022, this will mostly be in our past. But losing several years of a technology shift is nothing good for the US.