News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by maerF0x0 on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @05:46PM (#17251375)
means testing is super unfair to those who sacrificed lifestyle in their youth to save for retirement.

Consider the person that could have, but didnt, live a lavish lifestyle and instead responsibly saved. Then a benefit (which they paid into, and maybe rely upon) is removed after the fact? Bad news.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by encoderer on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:30PM (#17251664)
Social Security is not a retirement account. We're paying today for the current generation of retirees so we don't have a class of elderly homeless eating cat food and dying in our streets.

Means testing is consistent with this outcome.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by prklmn on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @07:04PM (#17251876)
Means testing gets you nowhere because there are so few people who would qualify as too rich- it would be less than a drop in the bucket "saved." It would be purely symbolic, and it's another way for those in power to say that we punish the rich and social security is a wealth transfer to the poor, then use that as a reason to abolish it. The idea of means testing is totally counterproductive to your goal.

Also as an aside, there are wealthy elderly people already not cashing their social security checks, you just don't know it because it makes nearly no difference in the scheme of things.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by encoderer on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @07:53PM (#17252148)
Probably true, though separate from the argument that means testing is "unfair".
Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by roenxi on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:53PM (#17251806)
Incentives are much more powerful than intent. It isn't meaningful to talk about intent when assessing the likely outcome of an economic initiative. I can't emphasise this as strongly as I'd like to; in economics we want fairness and the incentives to align, but if they are not going to then incentives trump fairness. Fairness with poor incentives drives bad outcomes, and usually reveals that 'fairness' is 'fairness for some in groups, at the expense of the rest'.

Resources are no longer growing as quickly relative to population as they were in the 70s and 80s. We need normal people to make uncomfortable decisions _not_ to consume. Otherwise there are not enough resources when they grow old.

Incentivising spending in the present is not a clever idea, even if it isn't intended.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by coredog64 on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @07:04PM (#17251882)
One of the problems with means testing is that as the average payout declines, so too does support for the program. Without broad support, cuts/changes to SS become less of a third-rail problem.
Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by craftyguy on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:46PM (#17251754)
> so we don't have a class of elderly homeless eating cat food and dying in our streets.

Too bad we already do, and the number seems to be increasing rapidly: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/31/us/americas-aging-homeles...

So if Social Security isn't helping with that, what other excuses are there?

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by allthenews on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:55PM (#17251821)
The fact that elderly homeless people exist does not imply that current social security policy does nothing.

Presumably, if we did away with SS, there would be more on the streets.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by krapp on Thursday June 07, 2018 @10:02AM (#17255798)
>Consider the person that could have, but didnt, live a lavish lifestyle and instead responsibly saved. Then a benefit (which they paid into, and maybe rely upon) is removed after the fact? Bad news.

Such a person wouldn't be able to live a "lavish lifestyle" with the benefits alone - that's not what they're for. And if they saved up throughout their entire life then they wouldn't depend on those benefits in the first place, and could likely live far more lavishly than the average recipient, anyway.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by maerF0x0 on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:43PM (#17257564)
If I am paying into SS in my 20s and expect to get, say, $1000 per month in my 60s, and I responsibly design my 401k savings etc around that promise, and then have it taken away because I saved more than the average person then I will have a $1000 hole in my budget .

Itd be no different than a bank keeping the contents of my savings account and giving me the excuse "we changed the rules"

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by krapp on Thursday June 07, 2018 @03:56PM (#17259631)
Except Social Security isn't a bank account, nor is it really a "promise," at least not a promise of a specific return on investment.

One could argue that designing your financial expectations around that program remaining exactly as is for the forseeable future given that history wouldn't be reasonable - any number of events could lead to that $1000 hole in your budget. Who's "keeping your savings" when stocks fall or inflation rises?

But, if the feasibility of the Social Security program as a whole depends on restructuring the program, as it has in the past, then I believe it's better for society that those cuts be distributed to those who can best afford them.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by arebop on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:59PM (#17251845)
If it's not a hard cutoff as suggested upthread but just a progressive phaseout then the responsible person still has a reward and yet the benefits can be focused on the needy.

I'm a proponent of BI but I have to point out that means-testing doesn't imply perverse incentives.

Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by jhayward on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:34PM (#17251679)
The marginal value of each dollar of social security benefit is smaller for those with independent wealth. Means testing is a way of making sure that each SSI dollar is highly valued.
Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by ryandrake on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:16PM (#17251572)
Unfairness is arguably in the eye of the beholder. If someone “responsibly saved” then they are not relying on the benefit as much as someone who didn’t or couldn’t save. Is it fair that a person who does not need financial aid receives it anyway?
Re:Social Security says system's costs will exceed income th... by kingbirdy on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @06:27PM (#17251633)
But this then incentivizes people to not save and spend their money while young instead, on the assumption that social security will help them when they're old, leading to even larger burdens on the system.