Consider the person that could have, but didnt, live a lavish lifestyle and instead responsibly saved. Then a benefit (which they paid into, and maybe rely upon) is removed after the fact? Bad news.
Means testing is consistent with this outcome.
Also as an aside, there are wealthy elderly people already not cashing their social security checks, you just don't know it because it makes nearly no difference in the scheme of things.
Resources are no longer growing as quickly relative to population as they were in the 70s and 80s. We need normal people to make uncomfortable decisions _not_ to consume. Otherwise there are not enough resources when they grow old.
Incentivising spending in the present is not a clever idea, even if it isn't intended.
Too bad we already do, and the number seems to be increasing rapidly: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/31/us/americas-aging-homeles...
So if Social Security isn't helping with that, what other excuses are there?
Presumably, if we did away with SS, there would be more on the streets.
Such a person wouldn't be able to live a "lavish lifestyle" with the benefits alone - that's not what they're for. And if they saved up throughout their entire life then they wouldn't depend on those benefits in the first place, and could likely live far more lavishly than the average recipient, anyway.
Itd be no different than a bank keeping the contents of my savings account and giving me the excuse "we changed the rules"
One could argue that designing your financial expectations around that program remaining exactly as is for the forseeable future given that history wouldn't be reasonable - any number of events could lead to that $1000 hole in your budget. Who's "keeping your savings" when stocks fall or inflation rises?
But, if the feasibility of the Social Security program as a whole depends on restructuring the program, as it has in the past, then I believe it's better for society that those cuts be distributed to those who can best afford them.
I'm a proponent of BI but I have to point out that means-testing doesn't imply perverse incentives.
I'd really be interested in seeing the math on this. If a person retires 2 years early (receive 86% of benefits) that person's total social security withdraw should be equal to someone that retired at normal age 13 years after retirement. With a retirement age of 67 and considering a life expectancy of 80, retiring early looks like favors the goverment on average.
There are additional factors to consider:
* How much more a person will pay into social security while continuing to work longer.
* If the last two years are the highest earning then it can increase the base payout.
* Does retirement age have an impact of life expectancy?
* Does a person's current health have an impact of if they decide to draw early?
* I don't really know how inflation changes social security, but it seems relevant to consider.
Medicare, however, is another story.
It's funny, I see this meme sometimes around tax day: "Well, I just paid my taxes. Those roads should be fixed anytime now". It's funny because the excuses people use (my roads!) to justify reckless and out-of-control taxation ($21T debt, that's T for Trillion) are almost never at the head of where the tax revenue is actually spent.
As a US government contractor, governments are great at overspending and under-delivering.
There were far, far more inputs to that than just "taxes are bad".
"As a US government contractor, governments are great at overspending and under-delivering."
And as a contractor, you're part of that problem.
Very true, and excessive taxation was one of the major factors.
> And as a contractor, you're part of that problem.
Not myself, but it's a reasonable accusation about the company I work for. Even if that were true, we offer a product that the government could never engineer. The product is good, the government needs it, so they take money from their citizens to buy it. My points still stand unfortunately.
- Remove the cap and tax income above $120k, just like medicare and income tax
- Increased tax rate, possibly just on payroll not income (the employer-paid portion)
- Limited forms of means-testing (Maybe, attenuated survivor benefits as your estate value clears a certain high mark like $3 million)
- Eliminate "early" retirement ages and force the "full" age
- Extending minimum retirement age to 70 and beyond