News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by manigandham on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:14PM (#17242142)
For all the complaints about Microsoft, I've yet to hear what they could do that would be so bad? Change the homepage to actually be useful? Improve the search? Give away free private repos?
Re:GitHub Alternatives by alkonaut on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:22PM (#17242200)
Kill Atom was the most reasonable fear I heard. And I can’t see how that wouldn’t be a well founded fear. If I was Microsoft I wouldn’t want to keep paying devs to make two so similar products (atom, code). They are much more similar than e.g code/vs or github/vsts.

But even so: I agree the fear that the product will be worse in a few feels completely irrational.

What I can agree with is that it’s unfortunate that it’s no longer seen as a neutral ground for development. It felt almost like a standard or like a piece of infrastructure, rather than a for-profit. But that was of course never the case. But now it becomes obvious, which might fracture the community (it was very nice to have everything in one place - e.g package managers literally started drawing stuff from github links). The appearance of neutrality and trust was the #1 feature of GitHub. Everything else is polish. Microsoft will have to work hard to keep the #1 feature working.

Re:GitHub Alternatives by HelloNurse on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @03:58AM (#17245200)
I see simply a generic fear of Microsoft, with their history of destructive acquisitions and unpleasant marketing strategies, doing something bad to GitHub users: something only they could do (involving LinkedIn, Windows, Visual Studio, etc.) and/or something that the far more harmless original GitHub wouldn't have considered.

From this point of view, speculation about what Microsoft could do is redundant; whatever they do, including nothing at all, will be considered suspect unless obviously harmful.

Re:GitHub Alternatives by brightball on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:46PM (#17242368)
Kill Electron would be the bigger fear. I know a lot of people don’t like it, but it has enabled so many more applications for Linux that killing it would be a major blow.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by manigandham on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @06:29PM (#17242648)
Microsoft uses Electron for VS Code, SQL Operations Studio, Azure Storage Explorer, Teams Desktop, Skype, and many other tools, and it has major traction with Slack, the Github Desktop App, Discord, and many other big companies. It's not going anywhere.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by ytpete on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @04:51AM (#17245452)
They could be pretty interested in shifting it away from Chromium an V8-based Node to something that uses platform webviews (Edge on Windows) and a platform-specific JS engine backing Node (ChakraCore on Windows). I believe they have posted open-source experimental forks in that direction in the past.

That's very different from killing it, but it could make developing or supporting Electron apps more difficult - plus the fear that it could then start sliding down the slope of the Windows version getting more investment, eventually leading to the classic "it's best on Windows" embrace/extend platform lockin. I'm not betting on that being their play, but I could see how people would worry...

Re:GitHub Alternatives by manigandham on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @05:56AM (#17245705)
The whole point of Electron is equal cross-platform abilities from a single code-base. Making it run "best on windows" is the complete opposite goal and rather silly considering they already have several native UI and app frameworks made for Windows.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by vxNsr on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:25PM (#17243698)
And by far the most unfounded fear. As others have said MS has tons of their own apps using electron, to kill it would be to shoot themselves in both arms.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by sfraise on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:58PM (#17242447)
We're actually working on 2 Electron apps for a very very large corporate client right now so how they handle Electron is definitely a concern for us.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by alkonaut on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:52PM (#17242408)
But... vs code is based on electron too.
Re:GitHub Alternatives by Kipters on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @06:29PM (#17242651)
They have a bunch of Electron-based products (VS Code, Teams), it's unlikely they'd kill Electron
Re:GitHub Alternatives by manigandham on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @08:08PM (#17243307)
But what does neutrality even mean? It's the git protocol, what is there to make non-neutral?
Re:GitHub Alternatives by alkonaut on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @01:55AM (#17244656)
Not influenced by any of the major software giants. That’s about it.

Github is very little about git and mostly about the hub. The inertia is in the issue tracker, forks/stars/...

Re:GitHub Alternatives by avenius on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @04:14AM (#17245274)
My fears, in no particular order:

- Worsen the usability of the site, introduce dark patterns

- Steal users' code (it has been rumored to happen before)

- Introduce mandatory usage of Microsoft accounts

- Gain a competitive advantage by spying on competitors' private repos

- Sell information about the users to the highest bidder